
I believe Welch did just come out with such a piece, didn't he?
That's not unreasonable, but I think it's a little hasty to say that all these feelings have to be the same, as well.
Chucking your kids out the window of a hotel is not really comparable to saying you have a testimony the church is true.
I think there's more psychosis than just strong emotions motivating those actions.
As far as the kids go, that's all they know. I don't think they've been given enough of a fair shake with reality to really accuse them of just being too believing.
Trying to lump it all together I think is going outside the lines to try to pigeonhole "faith."
Scottie wrote:maklelan wrote:Laman originally asked for the plates. Laban said he was a robber and tried to kill him. Then they all went and gathered their possessions and offered them to Laban in exchange for the plates. Laban tried to kill them again and stole their possessions. After twice trying to kill Nephi or his family, and after stealing their property, he was killed by Nephi. Nephi was perfectly justified.
No, he wasn't.
Nephi could have just as easily left Laban tied rather than kill him and still accomplish his task.
Sure, what Laban did was wrong, and I guess your God is a vengeful god, so it does make sense that he would command Nephi to kill him. I, myself, would like to think that a forgiving god would hold himself to a higher standard.