What constitutes in real life information and what is the punishment?

[_marg]

Would this be an example of what you are talking about?

No because you have your last name in the moniker.

Edit: I'm not sure. Yours might be a bit iffy since if one googled your name on your moniker alone they wouldn't arrive here whereas posting your first and last name they would. So perhaps no one should refer to you using your last name.

[_Scottie]

Would this be an example of what you are talking about? http://www.mormondiscussions.com/phpBB3 ... 54#p313054

YES! Most definitely!!

No because you have your last name in the moniker.

Wrong.

[_Trevor]

I think marg has really hit the nail on the head here in the 11:44 am post.

[_marg]

Would this be an example of what you are talking about? viewtopic.php?p=313054#p313054

YES! Most definitely!!

No because you have your last name in the moniker.

Wrong.

I agree Scott after thinking about it, he shouldn't be referred to by his last name. I did change my post before seeing your post.

[_Jersey Girl]

Tervor

Yes. I like the "three strikes" approach here.

Three strikes are exactly what my proposal was based on.

1. You get a month to cool your jets and come back.

2. If a month wasn't enough to cool your jets, try 6 months.

3. By the end of 6 months, your jets will either be ice, you will forget about the board entirely or you'll come back in a vengeful fury in which case I deem you a psycho and don't want you on the board. Period.

[_ttribe]

I agree Scott after thinking about it, he shouldn't be referred to by his last name. I did change my post before seeing your post.

This was how I expressed my concern at the time: viewtopic.php?p=313059#p313059

I was just curious if you thought it was consistent with the spirit of your suggestion.

[_Scottie]

I agree Scott after thinking about it, he shouldn't be referred to by his last name. I did change my post before seeing your post.

I think what ttribe is referring to is the fact that Scratch had posted a picture of him without his permission.

Granted, he did get the picture from the linkedin link on Tim's signature, but that still doesn't give him the right to post it.

I also believe that Scratch's use of Tim's first and last name were done maliciously. That would be a tough call, since technically, Tim HAS used both his first and last name on this board, so I don't know that Scratch broke a rule per say. Tim, what would your call be on that one?

[_Doctor CamNC4Me]

Hello,

Oh my. Now we have full blown hysteria on display by our neurotics; equating Mr. Trevor's hypocritically hurt feelings to racial equality and urinating in a public pool? I had to remove my reading spectacles, rub my temples, and sip on my Ovaltine as I pondered the ramifications of a board ran by people who are so willing to abandon free speech to soothe the feelings of an immature fellow.

If Mr. Trevor did not want to be outed he should not have outed himself.

It is, quite simply, the crux of the issue.

Very Respectfully,

Doctor CamNC4Me

[_Phaedrus Ut]

Posting the in real life information on someone has little value other than the implied intimidation that comes with that disclosure. If the goal of the board is to have open and free speech, disclosing in real life information would discourage that openness. in my opinion

I think there are some situations that will have to be judgment calls. For example, I recall Pahoran throwing a fit anytime someone refers to him by his real name but it's commonly known among many of the long time participants of these boards.


Phaedrus

[_Some Schmo]

...equating Mr. Trevor's hypocritically hurt feelings to racial equality and urinating in a public pool?

Dude... sometimes you make me laugh, and I'm really tempted to not take this seriously. In fact, I can't.

But on the off chance you are serious... really? Hurt feelings? I thought we were talking about matters of personal privacy, not hurt feelings. by the way, PM me your personal information, and I'll divulge it at a later date. It's no big deal, right?

But no, you can't be serious. It's all good. This one just wasn't as funny as other comments you've made in the past. Comedy is hit and miss. I totally understand.