MrStakhanovite wrote:The limited view of God is a tricky one, and I’m not sure it could really work. The first problem I foresee is one of worship, would we worship a powerful alien force if we knew of it’s limitations? Could one be justified in that worship?
The second problem that comes to mind is that, if God is some how impotent to stop evils, how can we be guaranteed that it is possible for God to actually have the power to reward people with an afterlife.
OMG, What an excellent topic!
And an opportunity to debate with Mr. Stak! OMG!
Mr. Stak,
Please know that I am most honored to have this opportunity. I hope you will engage with me. First, let us address your first comment about worship.
Yes, I think we really would worship a powerful force if we knew its limitations. I think we (most people today) don't because it is not very popular.
Can one be justified in worshiping such a being?
Yes! One can be justified. Worship is a process that involves introspection and meditation. It involves a process of thought and devotion and energy put forth towards an idea. This devotion and energy certainly could cause a person to change for the better, despite the nature of this being they worship.
On your second point: "The second problem that comes to mind is that, if God is some how impotent to stop evils, how can we be guaranteed that it is possible for God to actually have the power to reward people with an afterlife."
I don't think I understand this point. Are you suggesting that God must be the one to create a state of being after this life? Must God be the creator of an afterlife? Must all rewards come from God? Who made up these rules?
Stak, I'm likely asking these questions out of ignorance. Please have patience with me. I'll search through this thread for more comments from you...
Zee.