What's Up With the Mormons?
-
Philo Sofee
- God
- Posts: 6145
- Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 1:18 am
Re: What's Up With the Mormons?
The biggest thing for me is the admission that church leadership deliberately breaks the law and lies in order to procure billions and billions and billions of bucks. Not to use righteously, but to make more buildings. Anyone else getting caught flagrantly breaking the law would be arrested and thrown in jail. But it's leadership so they can do "The Lord's Work" illegally, and Mormons will ululate and praise them til the cows come home. I don't sustain, support, or encourage that, so the video killed it for me regarless of how happy, healthy, and good the members are. The leadership is corrupt. That's the deal breaker. I can be happy, healthy and moral without their leadership and hypocrisy. Once that is figured out, it's a done deal for anyone with brains.
- Limnor
- God
- Posts: 2014
- Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am
Re: What's Up With the Mormons?
Not to insult anyone’s family members here, but I’ve known far too many Mormons over the years to believe that Mormonism produces some kind of better human being. In my brief stint on this green ball, I’ve noticed that people are generally just people, none of them are perfect.
If anything, I’ve found Mormons to be more guarded, hesitant, and concerned with appearances than people outside the faith.
Take MG himself, for example.
He’s a mess of internal contradiction, defensiveness, and illogical, even dopey, reasoning as anyone I’ve ever met. I’m not even trying to single him out. He’s a perfectly ordinary example of Mormonism.
I’ve said before here that I’d rather deal with someone who is rough externally than someone whose outside is polished. It’s a matter of authenticity, and reminds me of the “I never knew you” commentary from Jesus. In fact, the longer I live the more it makes sense that Jesus seemed more comfortable around “publicans and sinners” than the “righteous.”
Whatever Mormonism claims to do to improve people, I haven’t seen anything that convinces me it “makes better humans.” I think at best it produces externally righteous people.
If anything, I’ve found Mormons to be more guarded, hesitant, and concerned with appearances than people outside the faith.
Take MG himself, for example.
He’s a mess of internal contradiction, defensiveness, and illogical, even dopey, reasoning as anyone I’ve ever met. I’m not even trying to single him out. He’s a perfectly ordinary example of Mormonism.
I’ve said before here that I’d rather deal with someone who is rough externally than someone whose outside is polished. It’s a matter of authenticity, and reminds me of the “I never knew you” commentary from Jesus. In fact, the longer I live the more it makes sense that Jesus seemed more comfortable around “publicans and sinners” than the “righteous.”
Whatever Mormonism claims to do to improve people, I haven’t seen anything that convinces me it “makes better humans.” I think at best it produces externally righteous people.
- Gadianton
- God
- Posts: 6916
- Joined: Sun Oct 25, 2020 11:56 pm
- Location: Elsewhere
Re: What's Up With the Mormons?
It doesn't "make people better". I'll tell you this, Limnor, in the MTC, and leading up to the MTC, you're taught that people are "suffering to the left and to the right". Sure, there's suffering everywhere. Okay. If only someone can throw them a life preserver -- the Book of Mormon. Fine. But, my mission focused on middle to the upper middle class and beyond and something like 80% plus are Christian of some variety -- very mixed. MG wants to compare the most successful Utah businessmen to third world conditions and behold the power of the church. But I got to see apples-to-apples comparison. Holding social-economic status constant. I didn't want to convert anyone, because most of the people who let us in were cooler than crap. Most seemed to have their lives together way better than the branch members. Nobody needed "the gospel" on the grounds of "suffering" without "the truth". One thing big in that region was freemasonry. I became friends with several who later admitted they were masons, the coolest most educated yet laid back people I knew. I regret I didn't keep in contact. In fact, members in those regions had issues with the youth -- crazy, but Utah-Mormon unwelcoming "clique" culture somehow gets preserved halfway across the world. Their kids were often attending the "Christian" mega-churches because the youth groups were so much more accepting. I mean, they were weird as crap, I got to be friends with a youth Pastor and attended some of their meetings, but they definitely seemed a hell of a lot more welcoming than any Mormon youth program I've seen.
And then lets look at family success. Dozens of examples over the two sides of my family. On one side everyone is mostly broken lives and the Church mattered zero. On the other side its a mixed bag. You've got a lot of money there and apostle friendships, there is some reasonable to high success in terms of money and family -- but a lot of money got pumped into that success to help it get started. At the same time, there are still massive broken lives, multiple suicides (in my opinion the church playing a direct role with at least one), early deaths due to health neglect, a very recent one due to right-wing misinformation church culture doesn't care to correct. Alcoholism and drug use -- drugs are big in Mormon central -- I mean my best friend from mission OD'd on heroin (and the church was a factor). Extending to friends, there are a couple who have done very well. Then again, they both graduated top of their class and married women who also graduated top of their class. So what do you expect? Others haven't done so well.
In all of this, one controlling factor is belief in the Church. MG loves to cherry pick after the fact. If somebody turned to drugs, MG is quick to say "Look, they couldn't handle the gospel and that's what happens!" which is completely dumb reasoning. If the gospel were something so special, it would prevent people from wanting to turn to drugs and so on in the first place. But if we want to take MG's dumb reasoning into account anyway, If I look across all my family and friends who are Mormon, and now look at all the broken lives, I'm not aware of ANY examples that include rejecting the Church in principle (with the possible exception of one family who I had the least contact with and they are successful). Everyone, to my knowledge, other than me, with lots of "problems", still believe(d) in the Church. And their lives are marked by drifting in and out of activity. One of the suicides bore a powerful testimony shortly before committing the deed.
And then lets look at family success. Dozens of examples over the two sides of my family. On one side everyone is mostly broken lives and the Church mattered zero. On the other side its a mixed bag. You've got a lot of money there and apostle friendships, there is some reasonable to high success in terms of money and family -- but a lot of money got pumped into that success to help it get started. At the same time, there are still massive broken lives, multiple suicides (in my opinion the church playing a direct role with at least one), early deaths due to health neglect, a very recent one due to right-wing misinformation church culture doesn't care to correct. Alcoholism and drug use -- drugs are big in Mormon central -- I mean my best friend from mission OD'd on heroin (and the church was a factor). Extending to friends, there are a couple who have done very well. Then again, they both graduated top of their class and married women who also graduated top of their class. So what do you expect? Others haven't done so well.
In all of this, one controlling factor is belief in the Church. MG loves to cherry pick after the fact. If somebody turned to drugs, MG is quick to say "Look, they couldn't handle the gospel and that's what happens!" which is completely dumb reasoning. If the gospel were something so special, it would prevent people from wanting to turn to drugs and so on in the first place. But if we want to take MG's dumb reasoning into account anyway, If I look across all my family and friends who are Mormon, and now look at all the broken lives, I'm not aware of ANY examples that include rejecting the Church in principle (with the possible exception of one family who I had the least contact with and they are successful). Everyone, to my knowledge, other than me, with lots of "problems", still believe(d) in the Church. And their lives are marked by drifting in and out of activity. One of the suicides bore a powerful testimony shortly before committing the deed.
"...gain control of land that FARMS owned..." -- Bill Hamblin
"Why did FARMS own land to begin with?" -- Me
"Why did FARMS own land to begin with?" -- Me
- Limnor
- God
- Posts: 2014
- Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am
Re: What's Up With the Mormons?
Your commentary sparked some thought for me gad. Things I’ve wondered about regarding “spreading the gospel.” First on the list I suppose is aligned to your comments—what are missionaries supposed to be rescuing people from?
As i understand Mormon theology, everyone is freely resurrected (saved?) through Christ’s atonement, whether or not they accept Mormonism. And almost everyone inherits some sort of glory. But if resurrection is essential synonymous with salvation, what “saving” is the missionary preaching? I guess it’s less “salvation” and more “exaltation,” which adds a bunch of extra things to do, like ordinances, covenants, temple ceremonies, and of course tithing. Upgrades.
I can see reactions like you’ve described as being a natural output from that sort of system in which you’ve never really “done enough.” It’s sad, really.
Looking back on this post it seems like one big run on sentence. Hopefully it makes sense and leads to a better understanding.
As i understand Mormon theology, everyone is freely resurrected (saved?) through Christ’s atonement, whether or not they accept Mormonism. And almost everyone inherits some sort of glory. But if resurrection is essential synonymous with salvation, what “saving” is the missionary preaching? I guess it’s less “salvation” and more “exaltation,” which adds a bunch of extra things to do, like ordinances, covenants, temple ceremonies, and of course tithing. Upgrades.
I can see reactions like you’ve described as being a natural output from that sort of system in which you’ve never really “done enough.” It’s sad, really.
Looking back on this post it seems like one big run on sentence. Hopefully it makes sense and leads to a better understanding.
-
MG 2.0
- God
- Posts: 8847
- Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2021 4:45 pm
Re: What's Up With the Mormons?
My my, well, I didn’t expect a hostile reaction. I don’t know how many times others have recommended watching a video link via a short introduction. Why they don’t get the same treatment is beyond me.
Or not.
Regards,
MD
-
MG 2.0
- God
- Posts: 8847
- Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2021 4:45 pm
Re: What's Up With the Mormons?
It’s unfortunate we are not able to meet in real life. My perceptions and some of the conclusions I’ve come to about you and your honesty/integrity might be alleviated, at least partially, if we were to have a one to one conversation, eye to eye, Mano to Mano. I might even come to realize that you’re pretty much a decent/regular/smart guy.
That will probably never happen. All we have is this.
Regards,
MG
-
MG 2.0
- God
- Posts: 8847
- Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2021 4:45 pm
Re: What's Up With the Mormons?
Gadianton wrote: ↑Sat Oct 31, 2026 4:26 pmIt doesn't "make people better". I'll tell you this, Limnor, in the MTC, and leading up to the MTC, you're taught that people are "suffering to the left and to the right". Sure, there's suffering everywhere. Okay. If only someone can throw them a life preserver -- the Book of Mormon. Fine. But, my mission focused on middle to the upper middle class and beyond and something like 80% plus are Christian of some variety -- very mixed. MG wants to compare the most successful Utah businessmen to third world conditions and behold the power of the church. But I got to see apples-to-apples comparison. Holding social-economic status constant. I didn't want to convert anyone, because most of the people who let us in were cooler than crap. Most seemed to have their lives together way better than the branch members. Nobody needed "the gospel" on the grounds of "suffering" without "the truth". One thing big in that region was freemasonry. I became friends with several who later admitted they were masons, the coolest most educated yet laid back people I knew. I regret I didn't keep in contact. In fact, members in those regions had issues with the youth -- crazy, but Utah-Mormon unwelcoming "clique" culture somehow gets preserved halfway across the world. Their kids were often attending the "Christian" mega-churches because the youth groups were so much more accepting. I mean, they were weird as crap, I got to be friends with a youth Pastor and attended some of their meetings, but they definitely seemed a hell of a lot more welcoming than any Mormon youth program I've seen.
And then lets look at family success. Dozens of examples over the two sides of my family. On one side everyone is mostly broken lives and the Church mattered zero. On the other side its a mixed bag. You've got a lot of money there and apostle friendships, there is some reasonable to high success in terms of money and family -- but a lot of money got pumped into that success to help it get started. At the same time, there are still massive broken lives, multiple suicides (in my opinion the church playing a direct role with at least one), early deaths due to health neglect, a very recent one due to right-wing misinformation church culture doesn't care to correct. Alcoholism and drug use -- drugs are big in Mormon central -- I mean my best friend from mission OD'd on heroin (and the church was a factor). Extending to friends, there are a couple who have done very well. Then again, they both graduated top of their class and married women who also graduated top of their class. So what do you expect? Others haven't done so well.
In all of this, one controlling factor is belief in the Church. MG loves to cherry pick after the fact. If somebody turned to drugs, MG is quick to say "Look, they couldn't handle the gospel and that's what happens!" which is completely dumb reasoning. If the gospel were something so special, it would prevent people from wanting to turn to drugs and so on in the first place. But if we want to take MG's dumb reasoning into account anyway, If I look across all my family and friends who are Mormon, and now look at all the broken lives, I'm not aware of ANY examples that include rejecting the Church in principle (with the possible exception of one family who I had the least contact with and they are successful). Everyone, to my knowledge, other than me, with lots of "problems", still believe(d) in the Church. And their lives are marked by drifting in and out of activity. One of the suicides bore a powerful testimony shortly before committing the deed.
Each one of us has observed lives lived in and out of the church. My experience with you, Gadianton, is that you seem to love building caricatures and then shooting them down. So much of what you have said here has not been my experience. I grew up in California, served a mission on the East coast. It’s not like I’ve lived in a bubble.
The caracature you’ve built of me, not only this time/post, but others, is not even recognizable to me.
Oh well, such is life.
Regards,
MG
- Limnor
- God
- Posts: 2014
- Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am
Re: What's Up With the Mormons?
See above for additional evidence of dopey reasoning. Meeting someone face-to-face is unlikely to change anyone’s ability to reason. Incoherency remains incoherent whether you look someone in the eye or not. I don’t expect the author of that idea to understand that though.
Plus I don’t see the point of seeking the approval of someone whose judgment I find questionable. Why would someone seek validation from a person whose judgment they don't respect?
Edited to add: I think this conversation has happened before and I recall malkie coming away from a meeting with you with nothing changing—or even turning our worse. If I remember correctly there was another who had met you as well, though their report was simply that you didn’t seem like a terrible person.
Neither of those reports move the needle on your tendency to employ faulty logic.
Plus I don’t see the point of seeking the approval of someone whose judgment I find questionable. Why would someone seek validation from a person whose judgment they don't respect?
Edited to add: I think this conversation has happened before and I recall malkie coming away from a meeting with you with nothing changing—or even turning our worse. If I remember correctly there was another who had met you as well, though their report was simply that you didn’t seem like a terrible person.
Neither of those reports move the needle on your tendency to employ faulty logic.
Last edited by Limnor on Sat Oct 31, 2026 9:40 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
MG 2.0
- God
- Posts: 8847
- Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2021 4:45 pm
Re: What's Up With the Mormons?
I suppose on that count you may have a point…although, like I said, hearts and minds can be changed through real life contacts. I would expect that some of the presuppositions I have of you could be changed for the better through actual face to face conversation. As it is, all I have is what you write on this message board.Limnor wrote: ↑Sat Oct 31, 2026 9:32 pmSee above for additional evidence of dopey reasoning. Meeting someone face-to-face is unlikely to change anyone’s ability to reason. Incoherency remains incoherent whether you look someone in the eye or not. I don’t expect the author of that idea to understand that though.
Plus I don’t see the point of seeking the approval of someone whose judgment I find questionable. Why would someone seek validation from a person whose judgment they don't respect?
I don’t always come away terribly impressed. Such is the nature of online media conversations.
Regards,
MG
-
Marcus
- God
- Posts: 8297
- Joined: Mon Oct 25, 2021 10:44 pm
Re: What's Up With the Mormons?
On the other hand, I'm pretty sure I'm the only person mg has actually told he didn't want to meet for lunch. He said it was because he wouldn't be able to stop himself from throwing food in my face. He also asked me once if my husband was aware of how I posted here.Limnor wrote: ↑Sat Oct 31, 2026 9:32 pmSee above for additional evidence of dopey reasoning. Meeting someone face-to-face is unlikely to change anyone’s ability to reason. Incoherency remains incoherent whether you look someone in the eye or not. I don’t expect the author of that idea to understand that though.
Plus I don’t see the point of seeking the approval of someone whose judgment I find questionable. Why would someone seek validation from a person whose judgment they don't respect?
Edited to add: I think this conversation has happened before and I recall malkie coming away from a meeting with you with nothing changing—or even turning our worse. If I remember correctly there was another who had met you as well, though their report was simply that you didn’t seem like a terrible person.
Neither of those reports move the needle on your tendency to employ faulty logic.
Funny how that Mormon upbringing can result in such sexism while stll reinforcing the faulty logic conclusion.