Dr. DCP Discusses Dr. Scratch on the MAD Board

[_stemelbow]

Since it's a joke, why would Peterson object to the joke being perpetuated in a sig line, quoting Will?

I think there's a rather obvious answer, Buffalo. the quote wasn't offered as any sort of joke. It was used by one guy who has repeatedly attempted to paint Peterson as a bad person.

This all is plainly obvious.

[_Molok]

Since it's a joke, why would Peterson object to the joke being perpetuated in a sig line, quoting Will?

I think there's a rather obvious answer, Buffalo. the quote wasn't offered as any sort of joke. It was used by one guy who has repeatedly attempted to paint Peterson as a bad person.

This all is plainly obvious.

That's right Stem, if Will writes a quote joking about killing Doctor Scratch, obviously Doctor Scratch is the one with the problem. Your logic is sound.

[_Some Schmo]

Can't we all just admit what's really going on here, that DCP is a homicidal maniac but he doesn't want anyone to know it? Being an obtuse, attention starved fat-ass is just a cover.

I mean, come on, people! It's so obvious! You people...

[_stemelbow]

That's right Stem, if Will writes a quote joking about killing Doctor Scratch, obviously Doctor Scratch is the one with the problem. Your logic is sound.

I didn't say anything about that.

[_Buffalo]

Since it's a joke, why would Peterson object to the joke being perpetuated in a sig line, quoting Will?

I think there's a rather obvious answer, Buffalo. the quote wasn't offered as any sort of joke. It was used by one guy who has repeatedly attempted to paint Peterson as a bad person.

This all is plainly obvious.

You'd think if Peterson thought the joke could be mistaken for something serious, he would have been very foolish to make the joke in the first place.

[_Molok]

That's right Stem, if Will writes a quote joking about killing Doctor Scratch, obviously Doctor Scratch is the one with the problem. Your logic is sound.

I didn't say anything about that.

Liar.

[_stemelbow]

You'd think if Peterson thought the joke could be mistaken for something serious, he would have been very foolish to make the joke in the first place.

Fine. So just because the joke was made that means its cool to exploit comments from another, years later?

[_Buffalo]

That's right Stem, if Will writes a quote joking about killing Doctor Scratch, obviously Doctor Scratch is the one with the problem. Your logic is sound.

I didn't say anything about that.

Pep pep! If a critic were to make a joke about killing a mopologist, I doubt you'd be criticizing the mopologist for sigging it. How about some balance, stem?

[_Buffalo]

You'd think if Peterson thought the joke could be mistaken for something serious, he would have been very foolish to make the joke in the first place.

Fine. So just because the joke was made that means its cool to exploit comments from another, years later?

If anyone jokes about killing me, I reserve the right to use the quotes however I wish in years to come. Fair notice, Stem, in case you were tempted! Pep pep!

[_stemelbow]

Pep pep! If a critic were to make a joke about killing a mopologist, I doubt you'd be criticizing the mopologist for sigging it. How about some balance, stem?

I'd condemn it. Here's the joking threat: "If you prefer to instead give him what he's got coming, I gots a grinder you may borrow, John."

Its in that thread that this quote surfaced from, written by KA (Kimberly-Anne, i think). Anyway. No one took it seriously. It was a joke. No one's going to use it as a sig. There are no Scratch's on the pro-LDS side. He's one of a kind.