I'm not quite sure where you are coming from, am I picking up on a parallel to Mormonism, where people read and pray and fail to get a spiritual witness their entire lives but just keep trying anyway?
I would say that the Evangelical salvation prayer isn't centered on epistemology like Mormonism's prayer to know what they know. So there isn't this endless attempting to "accept Jesus", where people pray to accept Jesus thirty times a year and aren't sure if it worked or not, as in the case of Mormons chasing a surreal experience to be sure it's a real witness.
I don't think there is a lot of theory on the front end. If you walked up to the stage at a revival and accepted the Lord with electric guitars blaring, then you're saved. If you read a Chick tract, gave it ten seconds of thought and recite the words it says to recite on the back then you're saved. If you're stone drunk, throw the bottle down, and say "I'm done with this" and accept Jesus in prayer then you're saved. If you're in a stuffy church and say the prayer after an hour long technical sermon then you're also saved. There isn't a lot of debate over the handful of words it takes to accept the Lord.
So going into it, it could be subconscious, barely conscious, fully conscious, high on weed, it doesn't matter, did you say the words? If so, check, you're in heaven.
But after that it gets a lot more technical. The problem is, after saying the prayer, what are you allowed to get away with from there in terms of behavior or beliefs that stray from the party line?