Page 1 of 4
Can this board survive Censorshipmongering?
Posted: Fri Jan 04, 2008 7:23 pm
by _solomarineris
Of his predecessors, most notably MAD&D, RFM?
I did post & read both boards, as you guys know, they are heavily moderated.
This place is full of refugees from MADD (including me). I still don't get it, what causes
mods to silence someone? Who is above the criticism? From what I read, it seems so ridiculous
to put "me' or someone else on "ice" for few days. I commented on MADD on homosexuality;
"God is an old homophobic guy" and this Mod thinks I crossed the line, but obviously God doesn't
think so because he didn't take an offense.
Another example, dartagnan was commenting on how he would never trust DCP and put a lengthy
essay about DCP's pimping of Islam. I commented that his writings of Islam resembles Goebbels
propaganda about Germany. So he was pissed and did cut&paste my post to MADD and of course the rest
is history, I was expelled like you guys.
RFM follows a very strange pattern, keeps alienating decent posters year after year for most asinine reasons
which are hard to understand.
What is my beef other than writing what I think? I hope you mod guys can keep your fingers to yourselves and let us
read what people think.
So far so good.
Posted: Fri Jan 04, 2008 7:25 pm
by _charity
If you don't know what it means to play nice nobody can tell. Obviously.
Posted: Fri Jan 04, 2008 7:25 pm
by _Moniker
Have you read the board rules? I would suggest you do so before you rant any more such nonsense and get yourself banned. Just sayin'.
Posted: Fri Jan 04, 2008 7:32 pm
by _Mercury
charity wrote:If you don't know what it means to play nice nobody can tell. Obviously.
Playing nice on MAD means that you sacrifice intelligent comments so you can stay in the good graces of the zealots in charge.
Posted: Fri Jan 04, 2008 7:50 pm
by _moksha
charity wrote:If you don't know what it means to play nice nobody can tell. Obviously.
I submit you can still be banned even if you are polite, refrain from ad hominem attacks of other posters, never use profanity, and are supportive of other posters. In the traditional American lexicon, are these not the components of nice? What do you mean by nice?
Posted: Fri Jan 04, 2008 7:51 pm
by _charity
Mercury wrote:charity wrote:If you don't know what it means to play nice nobody can tell. Obviously.
Playing nice on MAD means that you sacrifice intelligent comments so you can stay in the good graces of the zealots in charge.
Mercury, this just shows you are one of the crowd who doesn't understand playing nice. You can say what you want, as long as you leave out the insults, the name calling, the flame throwing. But of course, you are blinded to the civil rules of debate.
Posted: Fri Jan 04, 2008 8:13 pm
by _Scottie
I don't believe you should moderate content and discussion on ideas, but I think personal attacks should be moderated.
This board needs more moderation of those kinds of posts, if you ask me. which nobody did...
Posted: Fri Jan 04, 2008 8:15 pm
by _solomarineris
charity wrote:Mercury wrote:charity wrote:If you don't know what it means to play nice nobody can tell. Obviously.
Playing nice on MAD means that you sacrifice intelligent comments so you can stay in the good graces of the zealots in charge.
Mercury, this just shows you are one of the crowd who doesn't understand playing nice. You can say what you want, as long as you leave out the insults, the name calling, the flame throwing. But of course, you are blinded to the civil rules of debate.
charity
I have nothing but my compliments to you. You face many skeptics here.
Same time "playing nice", what is that mean? Do I have to refrain saying something?
"heavy-handed" moderation dilutes the freedom of expression.
i.e. don't be afraid of saying what is in your mind. (Which is impossible on MADD).
Posted: Fri Jan 04, 2008 8:16 pm
by _vinegrr
charity wrote:Mercury, this just shows you are one of the crowd who doesn't understand playing nice. You can say what you want, as long as you leave out the insults, the name calling, the flame throwing. But of course, you are blinded to the civil rules of debate.
Cngratulations! You've just won the Hypocrite of the Year award! An especially impressive feat, too, since it's only January 4th!
I simply cannot fathom how you believe yourself to follow the "civil rules of debate." When was the last time you didn't resort to personal attacks? Hell, look at the post you just made. What was that thing Jesus said about having a plank in your own eye while trying to point out the speck in others'? I'm not saying that other people aren't just as guilty of personal attacks, but YOU are the one who has the nerve to bring up civility.
These mods, despite your ongoing venom, allow you to stay and say whatever you want. They let others do the same. An "anti" posting with even half your bad attitude on MAD would be excomm -- sorry,
expelled, in a heartbeat. Come on.
Posted: Fri Jan 04, 2008 8:24 pm
by _solomarineris
vinegrr wrote:charity wrote:Mercury, this just shows you are one of the crowd who doesn't understand playing
These mods, despite your ongoing venom, allow you to stay and say whatever you want. They let others do the same. An "anti" posting with even half your bad attitude on MAD would be excomm -- sorry, expelled, in a heartbeat. Come on.
This is exactly what needs to be said.
Actually my lamentation was a compliment to this board's mods keeping their hands off.
Just keep expressing yourself! Ignore the ones you despise and do not respond them.