Page 1 of 2

Christianity is a historical accident

Posted: Wed Apr 11, 2012 2:26 pm
by _Panopticon
I was in Rome on Good Friday, and it occured to me how different things would be if Constantine had not adopted Christianty as the state religion.

Image

Re: Christianity is a historical accident

Posted: Wed Apr 11, 2012 2:56 pm
by _jskains
Panopticon wrote:I was in Rome on Good Friday, and it occured to me how different things would be if Constantine had not adopted Christianty as the state religion.

Image


Since it is the concept of the week, this also technically an argument from Ignorance.

And the flaw here is that not only is there an assumption that society would accept it, but that it would have continued beyond Rome. Some religions have not survived beyond their controlling empires.

You also assume you'd be an Atheist, which is also flawed. The butterfly effect is an insense reality. The one change you mentioned would have caused massive differences in history.

Hell, you might not even exist.

JMS

Re: Christianity is a historical accident

Posted: Wed Apr 11, 2012 2:59 pm
by _Drifting
Panopticon wrote:I was in Rome on Good Friday, and it occured to me how different things would be if Constantine had not adopted Christianty as the state religion.

Image





Since it is the concept of the week, this also technically an argument from Ignorance.

And the flaw here is that not only is there an assumption that society would accept it, but that it would have continued beyond Rome. Some religions have not survived beyond their controlling empires.

You also assume you'd be an Atheist, which is also flawed. The butterfly effect is an insense reality. The one change you mentioned would have caused massive differences in history.

Hell, you might not even exist.

JMS



Why is there a penis intruding?

(No, not you skains, in the picture lower right hand corner)

Re: Christianity is a historical accident

Posted: Thu Apr 12, 2012 2:05 am
by _huckelberry
"i would be a..."

no.

Mithrism had plenty of opportunity to recomend iteself to the empire. It had plenty of opportunity to recomend itself as the empire fell apart. People choose for reasons of preference.

Re: Christianity is a historical accident

Posted: Thu Apr 12, 2012 1:52 pm
by _zeezrom
Haha Drifting I wondered the same thing.

Re: Christianity is a historical accident

Posted: Thu Apr 12, 2012 2:01 pm
by _harmony
Drifting wrote:Why is there a penis intruding?

(No, not you skains, in the picture lower right hand corner)


Oh, please. That is a finger. Good grief.

Re: Christianity is a historical accident

Posted: Thu Apr 12, 2012 2:02 pm
by _Drifting
harmony wrote:
Drifting wrote:Why is there a penis intruding?

(No, not you skains, in the picture lower right hand corner)


Oh, please. That is a finger. Good grief.


Sorry.... :redface:

Re: Christianity is a historical accident

Posted: Thu Apr 12, 2012 2:11 pm
by _BartBurk
Panopticon wrote:I was in Rome on Good Friday, and it occured to me how different things would be if Constantine had not adopted Christianty as the state religion.

Image


My eighth-grade Ancient History teacher (a good Episcopalian) said it was such a miracle that Christianity survived that the best explanation was that it was Divine Providence.

Re: Christianity is a historical accident

Posted: Thu Apr 12, 2012 2:50 pm
by _DarkHelmet
That's funny. I wonder what the Book of Mormon would have been like if Joseph Smith was a Mithraist.

Re: Christianity is a historical accident

Posted: Thu Apr 12, 2012 2:52 pm
by _Aristotle Smith
DarkHelmet wrote:That's funny. I wonder what the Book of Mormon would have been like if Joseph Smith was a Mithraist.


Probably a lot like the Book of Abraham.