Temporal lobe epilepsy and religious visions

The catch-all forum for general topics and debates. Minimal moderation. Rated PG to PG-13.
Post Reply
_Chap
_Emeritus
Posts: 14190
Joined: Mon Jun 11, 2007 10:23 am

Temporal lobe epilepsy and religious visions

Post by _Chap »

See this article on the extent to which visions of a deity can occur in persons suffering from temporal lobe epilepsy - even in one case where the person who had the vision was an atheist:

Despite the fact that he is a confirmed atheist, when he was 43, Rudi had a powerful religious vision which convinced him he had gone to hell.

"I was told that I had gone there because I had not been a devout Christian, a believer in God. I was very depressed at the thought that I was going to remain there forever."


That article is a piece of scientific journalism, but there is a lot more out there in the form of serious scientific literature. Interesting that some have said that Ellen G. White, founder of Seventh Day Adventism, may have been a sufferer. Relevant to the present board is the fact that one person on it has repeatedly referred to the effect on his own life of an unexpected and somewhat unwelcome vision of a deity. Has it ever been argued that this disorder might also be behind the First Vision? In that case, we could have a prophet amongst us who is as real as they ever get ...
Zadok:
I did not have a faith crisis. I discovered that the Church was having a truth crisis.
Maksutov:
That's the problem with this supernatural stuff, it doesn't really solve anything. It's a placeholder for ignorance.
_Willy Law
_Emeritus
Posts: 1623
Joined: Sat Apr 17, 2010 10:53 pm

Re: Temporal lobe epilepsy and religious visions

Post by _Willy Law »

Chap wrote: Has it ever been argued that this disorder might also be behind the First Vision? In that case, we could have a prophet amongst us who is as real as they ever get ...


I am of the opinion that the first vision is a complete fabrication. Now the visions that were induced by Joseph on the gang, that is another story. For those I vote for entheogens.
It is my province to teach to the Church what the doctrine is. It is your province to echo what I say or to remain silent.
Bruce R. McConkie
_DrW
_Emeritus
Posts: 7222
Joined: Thu Apr 02, 2009 2:57 am

Re: Temporal lobe epilepsy and religious visions

Post by _DrW »

Willy Law wrote:
Chap wrote: Has it ever been argued that this disorder might also be behind the First Vision? In that case, we could have a prophet amongst us who is as real as they ever get ...


I am of the opinion that the first vision is a complete fabrication. Now the visions that were induced by Joseph on the gang, that is another story. For those I vote for entheogens.


Since there are so many versions of the First Vision story, and since it appeared as a matter of convenience as a part of a larger make-it-up-as- you-go-along narrative, I would agree that the first vision stories, all (seven?) of them, are complete fabrications, and not a very convincing ones once the facts about how and when they appeared are taken into account.

With regard to temporal lobe epilepsy, I know of no evidence that would indicate Joseph Smith suffered from this disorder. There is, however, a massive amount of evidence that he was a con man, liar, and philanderer. From what I have read, I would not put it past him, or Rigdon (or Cowdery, for that matter) to have given the spirit some assistance with ethnobotanical extracts.
Last edited by Guest on Tue Oct 16, 2012 7:59 am, edited 1 time in total.
David Hume: "---Mistakes in philosophy are merely ridiculous, those in religion are dangerous."

DrW: "Mistakes in science are learning opportunities and are eventually corrected."
_Ceeboo
_Emeritus
Posts: 7625
Joined: Sun Feb 14, 2010 1:58 am

Re: Temporal lobe epilepsy and religious visions

Post by _Ceeboo »

Hello Chap :smile:
Chap wrote:See this article on the extent to which visions of a deity can occur in persons suffering from temporal lobe epilepsy - even in one case where the person who had the vision was an atheist:


Wait......... atheists have brains? :surprised:




Jenn Kamp :smile:

Peace,
Ceeboo
_ludwigm
_Emeritus
Posts: 10158
Joined: Thu Oct 18, 2007 8:07 am

Re: Temporal lobe epilepsy and religious visions

Post by _ludwigm »

Ceeboo wrote:Wait......... atheists have brains? :surprised:

Peace,
Ceeboo
This may be the object of a research. (***)

There are things they don't have.
Prophets, seers, revelators. Priests, augurs, ministers, gurus.

I have to add: they don't have temples.
A temple (from the Latin word templum) is a structure reserved for religious or spiritual activities, such as prayer and sacrifice, or analogous rites. A templum constituted a sacred precinct as defined by a priest, or augur. It has the same root as the word "template," a plan in preparation of the building that was marked out on the ground by the augur. Templa also became associated with the dwelling places of a god or gods. Despite the specific set of meanings associated with the religion of the ancient Rome, the word has now become quite widely used to describe a house of worship for any number of religions and is even used for time periods prior to the Romans.


_________________
(***) Minority report:
I am, therefore I am atheist - if I may paraphrase Descartes.
I have recorded EEG waves.
This proves I have neurons of my brain.
This doesn't prove I have brain.

(EEG measures voltage fluctuations resulting from ionic current flows within the neurons of the brain.)
- Whenever a poet or preacher, chief or wizard spouts gibberish, the human race spends centuries deciphering the message. - Umberto Eco
- To assert that the earth revolves around the sun is as erroneous as to claim that Jesus was not born of a virgin. - Cardinal Bellarmine at the trial of Galilei
Post Reply