Choyo Chagas wrote:Meadowchik wrote:In my ideal church, no one has divine authority. People share spiritual experiences, insight, and real support, and there's always room for skepticism.
no church bears skepticism.
don't you believe? then quote one, please...
here is something saying about skepticism:
"Driven to despair by his fruitless attempts to understand the Universe, the sage Devadasa finally announced in exasperation:
ALL STATEMENTS THAT CONTAIN THE WORD GOD ARE FALSE.
Instantly, his least-favourite disciple Somasiri replied "The sentence I am now speaking contains the word God. I fail to see, Oh Noble Master, how that simple statement can be false."
Devadasa considered the matter for several Poyas. Then he answered, this time with apparent satisfaction:
ONLY STATEMENTS THAT DO NOT CONTAIN THE WORD GOD CAN BE TRUE.
After a pause barely sufficient for a starving mongoose to swallow a millet seed, Somasiri replied: "If this statement applies to itself; Oh Venerable One, it cannot be true, because it contains the word God. But if it is not true... -"
At this point, Devadasa broke his begging-bowl upon Somasiri's head, and should therefore be honoured as the true founder of Zen.
(From a fragment of the Culavamsa, as yet undiscovered)"
No church bears skepticism? Really? Have you heard of the Quakers? Unitarian Universalists? Even then, just because something does not exist now, does not mean it cannot.
Regarding your Devadasa anecdotes, there is a difference between "Thus Saith The Lord..." statements and "I believe..." statements.