DCP rejects all conspiracy theories except his own

[Marcus]

And yet somehow dowsing works. I wished he had addressed that.

He only thinks it works because he 'experienced' it working. He applies no critical thinking to his experience at all, and simply values his feelings. It tells us a lot about his intellectual thought process.

[drumdude]

Noel scores a goal point:

(Clifford's Other Principle) “It is wrong always, everywhere, and for anyone to ignore evidence that is relevant to his beliefs, or to dismiss relevant evidence in a facile way.” (Van Inwagen 1996, 145) Royal Skousen accepts the evidence that convinces him that the facsimiles should be removed from the Book of Abraham. Is he guilty of "dogmatic -rigidity"?

Obviously. LOL. I admit, noel, that your continual attempts to hijack threads can sometimes be pretty amusing. Especially when, like this one, they're so embarrassingly ham-handed.

Nothing to do with "dogmatic rigidity"?

No connection that I can see.

I see the connection Noel. And I bet Dan sees it too. I don't think he sees the irony of dismissing your point in a facile way, though!

[Dr Exiled]

And yet somehow dowsing works. I wished he had addressed that.

He only thinks it works because he 'experienced' it working. He applies no critical thinking to his experience at all, and simply values his feelings. It tells us a lot about his intellectual thought process.

It's why people see DCP for the disingenuous person he is. Of course dowsing is nonsense and he knows it, yet claims it's possible, based on a nonsense experiment he supposedly did.

[Rivendale]

And yet somehow dowsing works. I wished he had addressed that.

He only thinks it works because he 'experienced' it working. He applies no critical thinking to his experience at all, and simply values his feelings. It tells us a lot about his intellectual thought process.

I had a dowser tell me his method for establishing water lines on a property. He would get paid $300 to map out general areas where the pipes with running water were located. He had the coat hanger L shaped wires that he used. Now he really believed it worked but he did tell me that the first thing he would do on a property was look for where the outside hoses were hanging on the house and work from that. Why those? Because in high water pressure areas many of the outside watering lines for lawns and gardens were bypassed for more water flow. That would clue him in on angles of approach from various property lines. Of course dowsing has been tested over and over and over and fails . James Randi and his million dollar challenge solidified that. Yet this gets deposited in the mysterious bucket by Dan and relegated to a gift as one Mormon coworker told me.