Page 1 of 1

You ain't seen nothing yet, Joseph Smith Papers finished

Posted: Wed Jun 28, 2023 11:20 am
by Dwight
The last volume in the Joseph Smith Papers was published yesterday on the 179th anniversary of his death. Salt Lake Tribune article on it https://www.sltrib.com/religion/2023/06 ... st-volume/
Joseph Smith Papers: Last volume in the moonshot of Mormon history is published

Final of 27 print books documents the last six weeks of church founder’s life. “I am very much resigned to my lot,” he wrote just before he was slain at Carthage.

After 22 years of documenting, filing, writing and editing, the historians and researchers behind The Joseph Smith Papers published the final volume of their groundbreaking project Tuesday on the 179th anniversary of the church founder’s death.

The full 27-volume library — dubbed the “lunar mission” of Mormon historical research — follows Smith, the first prophet-president of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, from the beginning of his spiritual revelations to his martyrdom in Carthage Jail. “Documents Volume 15,” released Tuesday, contains 104 records that include the official announcement of Smith’s slaying in 1844 and the last six weeks of his life.

“Future historians may well call The Joseph Smith Papers the most important church-sponsored historical project of the 21st century,” Benjamin Park, a history professor at Sam Houston State University, wrote in an email. “The project has trained a generation of historians, forced church leaders and members alike to confront difficult historical issues, and demonstrated that the faith need not be afraid of its past.”

Park, author of the acclaimed “Kingdom of Nauvoo: The Rise and Fall of a Religious Empire on the American Frontier” and whose historical training began as an undergraduate research assistant for the project while he was a Brigham Young University student, called the sweeping effort a “landmark work of documentary editing, and a harbinger of what can happen when ecclesiastical leaders trust and enable their best historians.”

Joseph’s last days

(The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints)
Church founder Joseph Smith's letter to wife Emma dated the day of his death on June 27, 1844.
(The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints) Church founder Joseph Smith's letter to wife Emma dated the day of his death on June 27, 1844.

The final volume presents a frenzy of letters sent between Smith, his friends and wife Emma Smith during the time leading up to his murder in an Illinois jail. Though most of Emma’s letters have not been recovered, historian Elizabeth Kuehn uses her husband’s remaining letters to “read between the lines.”

When Smith writes to Emma while incarcerated, he urges her to let him know if she leaves Nauvoo, implying that she had plans to take their family elsewhere. This, Kuehn noted, was previously unknown to church historians.

Smith’s letters suggest that he expected to be found innocent of the treason charges on which he was jailed. The then-38-year-old church leader told her not to have “any fear” of harm coming to him.

“I am very much resigned to my lot,” he wrote, “knowing I am justified and have done the best that could be done.”

For head archivist Sharalyn Howcroft, recording Smith’s death parallels the ending of the project. Saying goodbye means she finally is able to look back on how she has been changed by it. She has been a part of The Joseph Smith Papers since its genesis in 2001, representing the longest project she has ever undertaken.

“This is the monolith,” Howcroft said. “It’s made me more persistent. There’s something to be said for the type of tenacity that creates in oneself.”

Recording the roots of the Utah-based faith is key not only for future historians, Howcroft said, but also for rank-and-file Latter-day Saints, so they can have a complete understanding of the church to which they belong.

Moving beyond the myth

The denomination finds itself in a rare position, Howcroft said, because many other Christian sects do not have full documentation of their origins. Latter-day Saints have the opportunity to get to know crucial figures, with Smith at the forefront, in their religion’s past.

“You start to create a myth around this person,” Howcroft said, “because they are so significant and so enormous in their impact. The one thing The Joseph Smith Papers does is strips that away.”

During her studies, Howcroft has found Smith to be a complex person. She sees him as someone who was trying to propel the church from an organization with a dozen members into something much larger, with a much more uplifting and lasting influence.

He was, Howcroft said, a big-picture kind of man.

And the tale of the tape for The Joseph Smith Papers reveals a big-picture endeavor. It includes, according to a news release, 1,306 journal entries, 643 letters, 155 revelations, 18,822 pages and 7,452,072 words.

“This project has produced the most authoritative, comprehensive and reliable source available on the subject of Joseph Smith and the [church’s] history,” said Utah business leader and philanthropist Gail Miller, who along with her late husband, Larry Miller, helped fund the undertaking. The release pointed out that Larry, expanding on a popular Latter-day Saint hymn, had professed that through these books “billions [the song says millions] will know brother Joseph again.”

Increasing the focus on women

This is hardly the end of the church’s efforts to record its own history. Howcroft will also participate, for instance, as an archivist in several more projects alongside R. Eric Smith, who worked as a Joseph Smith Papers general editor. Ongoing projects include recording the lives of other influential church figures such as Brigham Young, William Clayton, Emmeline Wells and Eliza Snow.

But these projects take four to five years. Shifting from decades’ worth of work — as with The Joseph Smith Papers — to shorter bursts has felt strange, said Smith, who has been on the project for 17 years.

“Somehow it’s gone by really fast,” Smith said. “And here we are using the past tense to talk about all that we’ve published. It’s surprising.”

Smith said he looks forward, however, to exploring other parts of church history that the formal organization sometimes glosses over. He is especially excited about women’s history within the faith, including the formation of the women’s Relief Society, the children’s Primary and the Young Women for teenage girls.

Viewing those organizations through the eyes of Snow and Wells is important for today’s Latter-day Saint women, he said. Smith believes such work can boost their visibility.

“Everybody knows that area has been long neglected,” Smith said. “And now you can just see that there’s people out there who are now able to see themselves in history in a way that they weren’t before.”

Latter-day Saint apostle David Bednar is thrilled to see that church history work is far from over. The reach of the organization’s past into its present is evident, he said, and he hopes to see as much documented as possible.

“All I would simply say,” Bednar said, “is that you ain’t seen nothing yet.”

Re: You ain't seen nothing yet, Joseph Smith Papers finished

Posted: Wed Jun 28, 2023 11:24 am
by Dwight
I guess the point of this is that last quote:
“All I would simply say,” Bednar said, “is that you ain’t seen nothing yet.”
What pray tell does your peep stone/intuition/etc. think we have in store?

Will the church reveal more around the succession crisis? Will the various journals in the vault be fully published?

It might be fun to speculate on, I'm going to think on it some more, but my gut says this is a vapid promise that makes members feel good, and nothing of note is on the way.

Re: You ain't seen nothing yet, Joseph Smith Papers finished

Posted: Wed Jun 28, 2023 11:59 am
by I Have Questions
The final volume presents a frenzy of letters sent between Smith, his friends and wife Emma Smith during the time leading up to his murder in an Illinois jail. Though most of Emma’s letters have not been recovered, historian Elizabeth Kuehn uses her husband’s remaining letters to “read between the lines.”
Which gives everyone else licence to "read between the lines" and be equally valid in their conclusions.
When Smith writes to Emma while incarcerated, he urges her to let him know if she leaves Nauvoo, implying that she had plans to take their family elsewhere. This, Kuehn noted, was previously unknown to church historians.
When Smith writes to Emma while incarcerated, he urges her to let him know if she leaves Nauvoo, implying he knew that she knew about all the affairs and that he was still trying to control the consequences of his bad behaviour - see Nauvoo Expositor for further reading.
Smith’s letters suggest that he expected to be found innocent of the treason charges on which he was jailed. The then-38-year-old church leader told her not to have “any fear” of harm coming to him.

“I am very much resigned to my lot,” he wrote, “knowing I am justified and have done the best that could be done.”
Smith's letters suggest that he was a narcissist who expected his version of events to be accepted by everyone without question and that he was the hero in all this - see Donald J. Trump for further reading.
“All I would simply say,” Bednar said, “is that you ain’t seen nothing yet.”
This is Bednar trying to con members into accepting the Church historians conclusions without question, without digging deeper, and telling members "nothing to see here, move along..."

Re: You ain't seen nothing yet, Joseph Smith Papers finished

Posted: Wed Jun 28, 2023 11:30 pm
by Philo Sofee
“You start to create a myth around this person,” Howcroft said, “because they are so significant and so enormous in their impact. The one thing The Joseph Smith Papers does is strips that away.”
So TRUE... and it is the real man which I suspect Dan Vogel has captured with captivating clarity in his new Book Charisma Under Pressure, showing the myth of the man who inspired the song "Praise to the Man" has been overly pernicious and false testimony building around unrealities of said Smith.

Re: You ain't seen nothing yet, Joseph Smith Papers finished

Posted: Fri Jun 30, 2023 7:33 pm
by Rivendale
Dwight wrote:
Wed Jun 28, 2023 11:24 am
I guess the point of this is that last quote:
“All I would simply say,” Bednar said, “is that you ain’t seen nothing yet.”
What pray tell does your peep stone/intuition/etc. think we have in store?

Will the church reveal more around the succession crisis? Will the various journals in the vault be fully published?

It might be fun to speculate on, I'm going to think on it some more, but my gut says this is a vapid promise that makes members feel good, and nothing of note is on the way.
And why the glacial roll out? They have been promising to release all kinds of records and we still haven't seen anything.

Re: You ain't seen nothing yet, Joseph Smith Papers finished

Posted: Mon Jul 03, 2023 5:17 pm
by Philo Sofee
Rivendale wrote:
Fri Jun 30, 2023 7:33 pm
Dwight wrote:
Wed Jun 28, 2023 11:24 am
I guess the point of this is that last quote:



What pray tell does your peep stone/intuition/etc. think we have in store?

Will the church reveal more around the succession crisis? Will the various journals in the vault be fully published?

It might be fun to speculate on, I'm going to think on it some more, but my gut says this is a vapid promise that makes members feel good, and nothing of note is on the way.
And why the glacial roll out? They have been promising to release all kinds of records and we still haven't seen anything.
Because they know they are handing us the "anti-Mormon" arguments they have lied about for centuries now. They have to do it slow, so the younger generations will not have the historical prowess and understanding of the full history, and they can remain brainwashed. Why be so eager to hand your opponent a nuke when all you did is bring a musket to the fight?

Re: You ain't seen nothing yet, Joseph Smith Papers finished

Posted: Mon Jul 03, 2023 7:42 pm
by Rivendale
Philo Sofee wrote:
Mon Jul 03, 2023 5:17 pm
Rivendale wrote:
Fri Jun 30, 2023 7:33 pm


And why the glacial roll out? They have been promising to release all kinds of records and we still haven't seen anything.
Because they know they are handing us the "anti-Mormon" arguments they have lied about for centuries now. They have to do it slow, so the younger generations will not have the historical prowess and understanding of the full history, and they can remain brainwashed. Why be so eager to hand your opponent a nuke when all you did is bring a musket to the fight?
I think Packer said that they are willing to sacrifice a generation for the widows in Sanpete county. Seems like that is coming true.

Re: You ain't seen nothing yet, Joseph Smith Papers finished

Posted: Tue Jul 04, 2023 4:06 pm
by Philo Sofee
Rivendale wrote:
Mon Jul 03, 2023 7:42 pm
Philo Sofee wrote:
Mon Jul 03, 2023 5:17 pm

Because they know they are handing us the "anti-Mormon" arguments they have lied about for centuries now. They have to do it slow, so the younger generations will not have the historical prowess and understanding of the full history, and they can remain brainwashed. Why be so eager to hand your opponent a nuke when all you did is bring a musket to the fight?
I think Packer said that they are willing to sacrifice a generation for the widows in Sanpete county. Seems like that is coming true.
Indeed! And we can rejoice in our new found freedom to worship God as we wish and know she is happy about it as well, instead of be mental slaves to ancient tomes of flesh out of touch with reality.

Re: You ain't seen nothing yet, Joseph Smith Papers finished

Posted: Tue Jul 04, 2023 6:10 pm
by Fence Sitter
Regardless of how one feels about past efforts by the church to hide its history, The JSP is impressive. I own about half the volumes and hope to eventually collect the entire set.