Page 1 of 1

The Mormon bridge between Islam and Christianity

Posted: Wed Sep 02, 2026 3:30 pm
by drumdude
I’ve been impressed by a Mormon apologist recently standing up to the MAGA/Trump/Republican hysteria and misinformation about Islam. There’s a longstanding belief amongst many in the West that Islam is invading their culture and seeking to impose Sharia law. Some call Islam a death cult. Others are making memes saying Islam isn’t a religion at all.

Joseph Smith seems to have recognized the similarities between himself and Muhammad early on. I personally think he likely modeled himself after Muhammad but faithful Mormons can believe that God spread truth to all traditions for His own purposes.

In any case it makes Mormonism a unique bridge with this hostile divide between Christianity and Islam. A bridge that could foster friendship and understanding. I hope someday Americans become a little less bigoted and ignorant about Islam and perhaps Mormonism and this apologist in particular will have helped a little to advance that.

Image

Re: The Mormon bridge between Islam and Christianity

Posted: Wed Sep 02, 2026 7:29 pm
by huckelberry
Mormonism could be a helpful bridge for some. Its views are not unique. A variety of non fundamentalist Protestants can consider God as inspiring people all over the world. Even fairly conservative views might consider preparation for the gospel as an action God does.

Many years ago I had some good friends who were Bahai. I Investigated that belief fairly extensively. They make a point of the idea of God sending leaders and inspiration to peoples about the world. Being an outgrowth from Islam it is a larger source than others. I could find myself appreciating positive aspects of Islam. I was also horrified by past treatment of Bahais by Islam, particularly in Iran. I cannot help but see a very mixed bag in Islam.

Re: The Mormon bridge between Islam and Christianity

Posted: Wed Sep 02, 2026 7:41 pm
by drumdude
huckelberry wrote: ↑
Wed Sep 02, 2026 7:29 pm
Mormonism could be a helpful bridge for some. Its views are not unique. A variety of non fundamentalist Protestants can consider God as inspiring people all over the world. Even fairly conservative views might consider preparation for the gospel as an action God does.

Many years ago I had some good friends who were Bahai. I Investigated that belief fairly extensively. They make a point of the idea of God sending leaders and inspiration to peoples about the world. Being an outgrowth from Islam it is a larger source than others. I could find myself appreciating positive aspects of Islam. I was also horrified by past treatment of Bahais by Islam, particularly in Iran. I cannot help but see a very mixed bag in Islam.
Appreciate you sharing these thoughts! I know almost nothing about Bahai.

Re: The Mormon bridge between Islam and Christianity

Posted: Wed Sep 02, 2026 7:47 pm
by Everybody Wang Chung
drumdude wrote: ↑
Wed Sep 02, 2026 3:30 pm
I’ve been impressed by a Mormon apologist recently standing up to the MAGA/Trump/Republican hysteria and misinformation about Islam. There’s a longstanding belief amongst many in the West that Islam is invading their culture and seeking to impose Sharia law. Some call Islam a death cult. Others are making memes saying Islam isn’t a religion at all.

Joseph Smith seems to have recognized the similarities between himself and Muhammad early on. I personally think he likely modeled himself after Muhammad but faithful Mormons can believe that God spread truth to all traditions for His own purposes.

In any case it makes Mormonism a unique bridge with this hostile divide between Christianity and Islam. A bridge that could foster friendship and understanding. I hope someday Americans become a little less bigoted and ignorant about Islam and perhaps Mormonism and this apologist in particular will have helped a little to advance that.

Image
Count down the seconds until James Carlyle Green gets launched straight off DCP’s friends list into the permanently banned.

Also, that’s classic DCP for you, skipping the actual educating part just to spend a paragraph explaining why James Carlyle Green isn't qualified to talk about Sharia in the first place. Folks, you really can't make this crap up.

Re: The Mormon bridge between Islam and Christianity

Posted: Thu Sep 03, 2026 9:46 pm
by I Have Questions
Everybody Wang Chung wrote: ↑
Wed Sep 02, 2026 7:47 pm
drumdude wrote: ↑
Wed Sep 02, 2026 3:30 pm
I’ve been impressed by a Mormon apologist recently standing up to the MAGA/Trump/Republican hysteria and misinformation about Islam. There’s a longstanding belief amongst many in the West that Islam is invading their culture and seeking to impose Sharia law. Some call Islam a death cult. Others are making memes saying Islam isn’t a religion at all.

Joseph Smith seems to have recognized the similarities between himself and Muhammad early on. I personally think he likely modeled himself after Muhammad but faithful Mormons can believe that God spread truth to all traditions for His own purposes.

In any case it makes Mormonism a unique bridge with this hostile divide between Christianity and Islam. A bridge that could foster friendship and understanding. I hope someday Americans become a little less bigoted and ignorant about Islam and perhaps Mormonism and this apologist in particular will have helped a little to advance that.

Image
Count down the seconds until James Carlyle Green gets launched straight off DCP’s friends list into the permanently banned.

Also, that’s classic DCP for you, skipping the actual educating part just to spend a paragraph explaining why James Carlyle Green isn't qualified to talk about Sharia in the first place. Folks, you really can't make this crap up.
It is sad that for that particular mopoligist, religion really does poison everything.