Page 1 of 2

Scott Gordon at Fair Mormon conference - new year same old spiel

Posted: Fri Sep 04, 2026 9:33 pm
by drumdude
https://youtu.be/f0qWqRlqcSs

A common apologetic refrain is that ex-Mormons are stuck repeating old arguments. Scott Gordon seems to be joining that trend.

Notably, he takes down the CES letter with one smoking gun. In a feat of fact and gumshoe detective work, Scott discovered that Jeremy Runnels mixed up the place where the Book of Mormon was printed with the town Joseph Smith was born in. It’s shaken my doubts about Mormonism and now I’m questioning everything I ever read in the CES letter! :lol:

This bombshell discovery that Scott made is at 8 minutes into the video. Also of note, Scott can’t bring himself to say the name “John Dehlin.” Apparently John Dehlin has reached Lord Voldemort status amongst believing Mormons.

Don’t say it 3 times fast or he might appear and steal your faith in fictional Hebrew civilizations in the pre columbian Americas.

Re: Scott Gordon at Fair Mormon conference - new year same old spiel

Posted: Sun Sep 06, 2026 4:09 pm
by Gadianton
The arguments against putting sick people in front of raging fires as done in medieval times haven't changed since modern medical science began either.

Re: Scott Gordon at Fair Mormon conference - new year same old spiel

Posted: Sun Sep 06, 2026 5:54 pm
by The Before
Gadianton wrote: ↑
Sun Sep 06, 2026 4:09 pm
The arguments against putting sick people in front of raging fires as done in medieval times haven't changed since modern medical science began either.
They could get burned!

Re: Scott Gordon at Fair Mormon conference - new year same old spiel

Posted: Sun Sep 06, 2026 7:17 pm
by Everybody Wang Chung
It speaks volumes about the utter bankruptcy of modern mopologetics that after more than a decade, Scott Gordon's monumental takedown of the CES Letter relies on a clerical typo. This just exposes how completely the CES Letter has hijacked Scott Gordon’s waking life.

Re: Scott Gordon at Fair Mormon conference - new year same old spiel

Posted: Sun Sep 06, 2026 8:28 pm
by drumdude
Everybody Wang Chung wrote: ↑
Sun Sep 06, 2026 7:17 pm
It speaks volumes about the utter bankruptcy of modern mopologetics that after more than a decade, Scott Gordon's monumental takedown of the CES Letter relies on a clerical typo. This just exposes how completely the CES Letter has hijacked Scott Gordon’s waking life.
I’m almost certain that there are bigger legitimate criticisms of the CES letter. Gordon is just incredibly lazy. Or he doesn’t value the time of the FairMormon conference attendees.

Re: Scott Gordon at Fair Mormon conference - new year same old spiel

Posted: Sun Sep 06, 2026 10:07 pm
by I Have Questions
drumdude wrote: ↑
Fri Sep 04, 2026 9:33 pm
https://youtu.be/f0qWqRlqcSs

A common apologetic refrain is that ex-Mormons are stuck repeating old arguments. Scott Gordon seems to be joining that trend.

Notably, he takes down the CES letter with one smoking gun. In a feat of fact and gumshoe detective work, Scott discovered that Jeremy Runnels mixed up the place where the Book of Mormon was printed with the town Joseph Smith was born in. It’s shaken my doubts about Mormonism and now I’m questioning everything I ever read in the CES letter! :lol:

This bombshell discovery that Scott made is at 8 minutes into the video. Also of note, Scott can’t bring himself to say the name “John Dehlin.” Apparently John Dehlin has reached Lord Voldemort status amongst believing Mormons.

Don’t say it 3 times fast or he might appear and steal your faith in fictional Hebrew civilizations in the pre columbian Americas.
Did Scott make mention of Joseph Smith mixing up the names of Nephi and Moroni in his accounts of angelic visitations? Because if a clerical error ruins the credibility of the CES letter, then a clerical error ruins the credibility of Joseph’s claimed angelic encounters. Scott’s defences of the Church always seem to make things worse…

Re: Scott Gordon at Fair Mormon conference - new year same old spiel

Posted: Sun Sep 06, 2026 10:28 pm
by Shulem
I Have Questions wrote: ↑
Sun Sep 06, 2026 10:07 pm
Did Scott make mention of Joseph Smith mixing up the names of Nephi and Moroni in his accounts of angelic visitations?
Scott Gordon is a pussy-boy -- whipped and beaten. He's a piece of crap and a poor excuse of a human being. He's an ape-man, having descending from primates. Gordon is a stale Cheeto out of a bag that's been sitting on the shelf for years and years.

Let him come here (Discuss Mormonism) and talk to me and I WILL KICK HIS SORRY ASS BACK TO HELL from whence he came.

Scott Gordon's middle name is, SATAN.

:twisted:

Come on, Scotty-boy, you little pussy -- I will kick your freaking ass! I will take your testimony and shove it down your throat until you gag and choke on it! Your Spirit is nothing more than a slit throat!

You liar for the Lord. You're scum.

:evil:

Disgusting man.

Re: Scott Gordon at Fair Mormon conference - new year same old spiel

Posted: Mon Sep 07, 2026 12:29 pm
by Kishkumen
Apologists and critics are locked into a repeating conversation.

Re: Scott Gordon at Fair Mormon conference - new year same old spiel

Posted: Mon Sep 07, 2026 1:59 pm
by Dwight
I feel there is sometimes new things, but it does seem like after the gold rush of early podcasts there is less new things, though sometimes I think it is good to hear new perspectives on things I often feel I know more about than the podcast/YouTube hosts, but a guy I listen to his podcasts sometimes recounted this from his youth about why the local UHF channel kept showing the Flintstones.
WXIX channel 19 manager wrote:Every day, somebody's born who's never seen The Flintstones.
https://gist.github.com/merlinmann/03c6 ... ab9a67d349

Re: Scott Gordon at Fair Mormon conference - new year same old spiel

Posted: Mon Sep 07, 2026 2:11 pm
by Shulem
Kishkumen wrote: ↑
Mon Sep 07, 2026 12:29 pm
Apologists and critics are locked into a repeating conversation.
What really pissed me off over the Scott Gordon issue is how he simply chalked up the critic's arguments as if they were under Satan's influence and therefore not to be trusted with the facts. I really can't stand how apologists coverup, lie, distort, twist, and use lipstick on a pig to try and disguise things. Uninformed faithful listeners with only 1/2 a brain are getting screwed by so much deception that spews out of the mouth of liars like Gordon.

It makes me angry at times but not so much as it used to. I've come a long way, I think. Trying to let things go and just let it be is pretty much good medicine. I've lost interest and am moving on...

That's probably a good thing.