Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

The catch-all forum for general topics and debates. Minimal moderation. Rated PG to PG-13.
User avatar
Doctor Scratch
B.H. Roberts Chair of Mopologetic Studies
Posts: 1788
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 7:24 pm
Location: Cassius University

Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Doctor Scratch »

An interesting post with a nearly accurate title ("An Action Movie and Some Vacuous Theology"; it should say, "An Action Movie and Some Vacuous Commentary"--a perfect description for virtually all of the content on "SeN," and the Interpreter Blog, for that matter) appeared recently at "SeN." In it, the Proprietor describes his experience watching the film Runner--an Angel Studios release. Angel Studios, of course, is the LDS distributor which describes itself as producing "uplifting shows for the whole family," including titles like, Unitards Jesus Revolution, and Charlie Kirk American Martyr [sic]. The Afore notes that he is, "very interested in what Angel Studios is up to" but acknowledges that, given the violent content of Runner, he "was curious about how Runner fits in with overall Angel Studios approach." Yes: that's a good question. How is it that a violent action film, released by a distributor that is helmed by loyal Latter-day Saints, can be described as "uplifting...for the whole family"? Indeed, the Proprietor winds up having quite a positive experience:
That said, I really rather liked Runner. More than I had expected to do. It’s an exciting movie and, I thought, a quite entertaining way to spend an hour and thirty-eight minutes. If you enjoy action films, you’ll very probably like Runner.
Eh, I don't know. I think about some of the classics of action filmmaking: The Road Warrior, for example, or perhaps The French Connection or Die Hard. But of course, those are not "Brethren-approved" since they're rated "R" and have "harsh language." But it makes perfect sense that Mopologists would be drawn to a watered-down version of an action film which still includes all the gratuitous violence but deletes all the cuss words. Indeed, frequent "SeN" commentator Larry Arnett notes:
We also saw the movie “Runner”. I would describe it as wholesome extreme violence since the language used by all the characters would be rated “G”. We also enjoyed it and we were surprised that it exceeded our expectations.
Lol. Worth noting is the seeming oxymoron "wholesome extremes violence" ("wholesome"???) and also that the movie "exceeded our expectations." The assumption being, I guess, that an "uplifting" film from Angel Studios would limit the amount of gore and violence on screen, too?

Luckily, the invaluable poster "Chet" immediately notices that something is amiss:
LA: "We also saw the movie “Runner”. I would describe it as wholesome extreme violence since the language used by all the characters would be rated “G”. We also enjoyed it and we were surprised that it exceeded our expectations."

That sounds like a Tarantino movie directed by Mister Rogers where everyone politely says "golly" right before blowing each other to smithereens. What exactly is "wholesome extreme violence"? Also, speaking of cinematic double standards, do you think screen violence is genuinely more harmful than nudity, or are Americans just weirdly squeamish about the wrong things?
And the Afore immediately reacts:
I think it safe to say that, for normal people, onscreen violence isn't alluring, seductive, stimulating, and enticing in the same way, and to the same degree, that onscreen sex and nudity are enticing, stimulating, seductive, and alluring to normal people. Your mileage may vary.
Chet wrote:Claiming onscreen violence isn't enticing, seductive or alluring to "normal people" is quite the leap, considering Hollywood has spent decades turning extreme violence, explosions, car chases, and violent smackdowns into billion dollar box office hits for those very same "normal people." It seems that most "normal people," when faced with a movie that contains extreme violence or sexual content, consistently choose to spend their money on extreme violence. It says a lot about our culture that we treat disembowelment, killings as harmless wholesome entertainment and intimacy/nudity as a moral crisis.
The Afore wrote:"Chet:" "Claiming onscreen violence isn't enticing, seductive or alluring to "normal people" is quite the leap"

And I'm quite confident in making it.

In any given year, more people engage in sex (and more frequently) than in car chases, extreme violence, disemboweling, and murder. I suspect, too, that the desire for the former exceeds the desire for the latter in normal people. Again, your mileage may vary.

While, given its moral teachings, the Church feels a need to encourage its membership to live chaste and sexually restrained lives, I don't think that the Church feels a similarly urgent need to discourage disemboweling, extreme violence, and homicide among its members -- and I think that completely understandable and realistic.

If you're trying to portray me as endorsing the brutalization of human beings, by the way, you should probably not spend too much time or effort on that quixotic undertaking.
While I think that Chet is making some valuable points here, I think his aim is a bit too wide. He writes, "It seems that most "normal people," when faced with a movie that contains extreme violence or sexual content, consistently choose to spend their money on extreme violence." He should have written, "It seems that most Mopologists, when faced with a movie that contains extreme violence or sexual content, consistently choose to spend their money on extreme violence." Phrased that way, it is absolutely, 100% correct, and I doubt even the Afore would argue. The Afore might not "endorse...the brutalization of human beings," but he's happy to fork over his money in order to enjoy it as entertainment.

Yes: it's no doubt true that "in any given year, more people engage in sex (and more frequently) than in car chases, extreme violence, disemboweling, and murder. I suspect, too, that the desire for the former exceeds the desire for the latter in normal people." But that is not really the issue here. Instead, the question is: Which do certain people--esp. Mopologists--consistently pick when it comes time for entertainment? The implication, of course, is a prudish one: a naked breast or the utterance of the "F" word is repellent; but seeing people get beat to a pulp or having their heads blown off with a rocket-propelled grenade is not only acceptable but "good, wholesome" fun. There is, in other words, something to be said here about the fundamental values of the Mopologists, and the values that are inculcated in them by the dictates of the Brethren. Beheadings and dismemberment, so long as there is no cussing? Totally okay! Watching Sirens and thinking about it afterwards, even if you don't act on it? You better make an appointment to see your bishop.

Meanwhile, it is perhaps worth thinking about the reasons why the Afore seems to interested in Angel Studios. According to a Rolling Stone article from a couple of years ago, the company was valued at $1.6 billion when it went public in 2024. But as you can also see, the company was sued do to breach of contract and has faced accusations that it "screws" over the smaller filmmakers whose work it distributes. (If you want to see the whole article, you can check it out on this Reddit thread.) So, a billion-dollar film distribution company, run by Mormons that (allegedly) routinely shafts the "little guy"? Yes: no wonder the Proprietor is "very interested in what Angel Studios is up to."

And remember: watching a video of "J.Lo Hot Booty Shaking" elicits a public apology. Watching gratuitous, graphic violence, though, gets an affirmative review and a recommendation
"If, while hoping that everybody else will be honest and so forth, I can personally prosper through unethical and immoral acts without being detected and without risk, why should I not?." --Daniel Peterson, 6/4/14
I Have Questions
God
Posts: 4583
Joined: Tue May 23, 2023 9:09 am

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by I Have Questions »

I note that the Afore also mentions his liking for Reacher books and films. Which is interesting. Reacher is promiscuous, prone to extreme violence and law breaking if he feels it serves the greater good. A renegade hero roaming the streets of America fighting against what he has determined is injustice, and meting out punishment. Judge, jury, and executioner, whilst getting a bit of casual sex on the side.

Is that how the Afore sees himself and mopologetics? Above the law vigilantism that’s fully justified by the end result, with some personal fringe benefits?
Premise 1. Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable.
Premise 2. The best evidence for the Book of Mormon is eyewitness testimony.
Conclusion. Therefore, the best evidence for the Book of Mormon is notoriously unreliable.
User avatar
Tom
God
Posts: 1190
Joined: Mon Oct 26, 2020 3:41 pm
Location: Sego, Utah
Contact:

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Tom »

The Relief Society Sister in Parowan tells me that she’s deeply disappointed with Angel’s turn toward the dark side. Angel’s website invites prospective donors to “support films & filmmakers that share your values,” claiming that “your membership enables filmmakers to tell stories that amplify light and bring more goodness into the world” and “you can help bring these impactful stories to life and reintroduce positive values to the entertainment industry.”

Angel’s website admits, however, that
while the MPA [sic] has officially rated the movie PG-13, here at Angel we know that rating doesn’t always give parents the full picture. The Angel Guild—a community of thousands of parents, viewers, and supporters who screen and vote on Angel projects—has recommended the movie for Ages 16+ for strong action violence, bloodshed, intense peril, and some language, including 1 use of sh*t, 1 d*mn, 1 p*ss, and a crude threat.
The reviews of parents posted at Common Sense Media are more illuminating. One adult gives the film one out of five stars and writes:
Hard pass

The violence in this movie was just over the top which was disappointing coming from a studio that has a motto of promoting light. I enjoyed the movie heartland and the series so recognize that some violence is acceptable in a good movie. This was over the top especially for the studio that released it. Parents there is way too much violence - including an over-the-top fight sequence at the end that if there was any question before then answers that this just isn't appropriate for children. I wouldn't choose to watch that again but older teenagers I'm sure could handle it but why would you want to. Big thumbs down in spite of liking Owen Wilson and his character and the attempt at a feel good ending. So inadequate after that final bloody, violent fight scene.
Another adult also awards the movie one star and writes:
I was very disappointed that a family-friendly movie was pushing the edges of what it means to be PG-13. I've seen violence in a lot of movies like The Avengers but there's a way they do it to make it less real and not gory. This film seem to focus on Extreme violence, people being impaled painting the main character in blood showing bullet wounds covered in a soup of blood and so many other things. It was like they were glorying in the violence. All the while making sure not to swear because it's a family-friendly movie. I was greatly disappointed came away feeling a little sick to be honest. There are many other movies in Hollywood like this but when a movie studio claims to be at a quote higher level, family friendly and tries to use pay it forward to give moms free tickets to a movie they don't want to see I guess that strikes a nerve with me.
A third adult writes:
Gore galore with ample F bombs - what do you even stand for ANGEL studios? This was opposite of a "faith-based" film.

Rather disappointed with ANGEL on this one! For a "faith-based" studio, they really dropped the ball. There had to have been 40+ curse words, a couple uses of the Lords name in vain (including Jesus Christ) and intense gore (HUGE body count, ample blood spatter, and bad guy got a bike seat shoved through his neck and excessively long violent fight scenes). Far more action than comedy and, although the story is alright (delivering a time sensitive medical package), it dragged on a time or two. For sure NOT a family movie, barely worthy of a date night and definitely not a film worthy of a "faith based" reputation. Surprised it got such a high rating form [sic] the "guild members" of ANGEL, makes me think there's been an infiltration, but let's not get carried away with conspiracy.
A fourth adult also rates the movie one star and writes:
Don't go

I should have checked Common Sense reviews and avoided endless, mind-numbing violence. I, too, was duped by Angel studios, and thought I could trust their filming. This is Reacher 2.0 with an annoying, endearing sidekick. If you loved the violence in Reacher, step right up. I wish we had followed our guts and walked out of the theater. Be wise! We weren't.
Another website details the movie’s “wholesome extreme violence” here.

For my money, I get my fill of wholesome extreme violence by watching episodes of The Three Stooges.

Edited to remove the first [sic] in my comment.
Last edited by Tom on Sat Sep 26, 2026 10:35 pm, edited 1 time in total.
“We live by faith, not by sight” (2 For. 5:7 NIV).
User avatar
Gadianton
God
Posts: 6916
Joined: Sun Oct 25, 2020 11:56 pm
Location: Elsewhere

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Gadianton »

I think my friend and colleague Dan Peterson is taking the cart before the horse. If Mormons believe that exposure to sexuality will drive people to sex, then Why did Evergreen use vast amounts of porn in their "therapy"? Consumption of a certain kind of medium has no guaranteed results. However, it may be worth noting that at one time, Mormon men may have been the greatest consumers of National Geographic on the planet and not because they cared about geography. Tribal nudity doesn't seem to drive indigenous peoples into unrestrained sexual relationships and very many have adopted lifestyles that have continued them for thousands of years. Some were here thousands of years before Mormonism was invented, and some of those will perpetuate long after modern civilization has destroyed itself and Mormonism disappears.

Whatever legitimate concerns such as exploitation might be brought to the table, the reason for religious censorship of nudity and sexuality in our culture has to do with priestcraft and what might be called sex-maxing. How pervs like Joseph Smith used religion to guarantee access to sex for himself needs little explanation here. But as members fall into line and adopt their roles, willing to give their leaders access to their own family if called upon, they find ways to look after their own self interests also, and it's not entirely illogical.

Think of that song "Relax, don't do it," well, membership culture takes the point of delayed gratification to the extreme. I'll bet any highly promiscuous person out there would love a virtual reality that erases everything they know and lets them go back to the first time -- to chase that first high. Mormons put their entire lives into holding back so they can experience the ultimate "explosion" when the time comes. This further works as a tool to corral young people into marriage as their only avenue of relief, with birth control discouraged or forbidden such that one's entire life focus must bring in numbers for the brethren to financially exploit.

And for the guys at least, if the real thing fails to live up to the hype, the principle of delayed gratification allows a mind-blowing experience with very little effort, just by tuning into PBS "accidentally" at the right time. Further, sunk cost reasoning builds up a fantasy where one comes to understand that in the eternities, there will be little time for them to do anything else but F, to create billions upon billions of children, and it's strongly implied that they will have multiple wives for plenty of variety.

So basically, Mormonism's especially draconian forbiddance of anything sexual is an elaborate cultural and psychological scheme of sex-maxing.
"...gain control of land that FARMS owned..." -- Bill Hamblin
"Why did FARMS own land to begin with?" -- Me
User avatar
The Before
Sunbeam
Posts: 79
Joined: Sat Aug 08, 2026 2:11 am

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by The Before »

Tom wrote: ↑
Sat Sep 26, 2026 6:13 am
Angel’s website admits, however, that
while the MPA [sic] has officially rated
The excessive [sic]ing here is unnecessary. The Motion Picture Association, since 2019, has used the initialism “MPA.”

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motion_Pi ... ssociation
"Life never gives us what we want at the moment that we consider appropriate. Adventures do occur, but not punctually." - EMF
User avatar
Everybody Wang Chung
God
Posts: 3957
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 1:52 am

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Everybody Wang Chung »

The Before wrote: ↑
Sat Sep 26, 2026 8:49 pm
Tom wrote: ↑
Sat Sep 26, 2026 6:13 am
Angel’s website admits, however, that
The excessive [sic]ing here is unnecessary. The Motion Picture Association, since 2019, has used the initialism “MPA.”

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motion_Pi ... ssociation
Good grief, Nolan......
"I'm on paid sabbatical from BYU in exchange for my promise to use this time to finish two books."

Daniel C. Peterson, 2014
User avatar
Tom
God
Posts: 1190
Joined: Mon Oct 26, 2020 3:41 pm
Location: Sego, Utah
Contact:

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Tom »

The Before wrote: ↑
Sat Sep 26, 2026 8:49 pm
Tom wrote: ↑
Sat Sep 26, 2026 6:13 am
Angel’s website admits, however, that
The excessive [sic]ing here is unnecessary. The Motion Picture Association, since 2019, has used the initialism “MPA.”

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motion_Pi ... ssociation
Noted. Thank you.
“We live by faith, not by sight” (2 For. 5:7 NIV).
User avatar
malkie
God
Posts: 2863
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 2:41 pm
Location: Ontario, Canada

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by malkie »

The Before wrote: ↑
Sat Sep 26, 2026 8:49 pm
Tom wrote: ↑
Sat Sep 26, 2026 6:13 am
Angel’s website admits, however, that
The excessive [sic]ing here is unnecessary. The Motion Picture Association, since 2019, has used the initialism “MPA.”

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motion_Pi ... ssociation
In my experience, folks here are fine with a PM pointing out minor issues, like a misplaced "[sic]", and may fix the error and sometimes even give the pointer-outer a nod in passing.
You can help Ukraine by talking for an hour a week!! PM me, or check www.enginprogram.org for details.
Слава Україні!, 𝑺𝒍𝒂𝒗𝒂 𝑼𝒌𝒓𝒂𝒊𝒏𝒊!
User avatar
The Before
Sunbeam
Posts: 79
Joined: Sat Aug 08, 2026 2:11 am

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by The Before »

malkie wrote: ↑
Sun Sep 27, 2026 4:03 am
The Before wrote: ↑
Sat Sep 26, 2026 8:49 pm
The excessive [sic]ing here is unnecessary. The Motion Picture Association, since 2019, has used the initialism “MPA.”

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motion_Pi ... ssociation
In my experience, folks here are fine with a PM pointing out minor issues, like a misplaced "[sic]", and may fix the error and sometimes even give the pointer-outer a nod in passing.
Having read some of Tom’s threads, it seems like he likes precision, and I was just helping out in a friendly way.

What’s a PM[sic]?
"Life never gives us what we want at the moment that we consider appropriate. Adventures do occur, but not punctually." - EMF
User avatar
Gadianton
God
Posts: 6916
Joined: Sun Oct 25, 2020 11:56 pm
Location: Elsewhere

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Gadianton »

A few observations about violence in Mormonism are also in order. In present culture, which is a continuation of what we were brought up with, violence for Mormons is no big deal. The Book of Mormon is violent, but it's cartoon violence. Like in the Road Runner. A tale with lots of cartoon violence and war is the driving force of God's glory recapturing the earth at various time periods. Last Days prophecy is all about bodies laying everywhere and rotting and Jesus is going to come down and burn everyone who didn't believe like Mormons did -- will serve them right. Mormons have a lot of cartoonish war fantasies.

Mormons are largely desensitized to violence. If it's a war movie with good guys prevailing then it makes it all that more dramatic. My mom would watch war movies with dad and only cringe at the cussing, as Dr. Scratch observed. I guess it was a moral obligation to show disapproval for using that kind of language. A few hundred people are about to drown in a submarine and that one soldier could have said "gosh darn" instead.

Well, it's interesting, as I think it may be an open question as to whether apologists are more open to swearing in war movies. They might be. Apologists have long been aware of the cartoon violence of the Book of Mormon and been embarrassed by this. I think it was Jack Welch who wrote an essay for FARMS in the 90s about the beheading of Laban, and tried to recast it as gruesome and unsettling, basically as R-rated. Growing up, we reenacted the story of the plates for FHE. We dressed up for our parts and had cutout swords and everything. This is not the sort of thing the apologists want. Grant Hardy's epic work tries to make the Book of Mormon more serious and dark for the mature entertainment palate. Mormon apologists want the Book of Mormon to be taken seriously as a dark, gritty exploration of the raw human condition when in reality, it's a light-hearted hero's romp with zero dramatic value. It's Disney.

But yes, reenacting the Laban story with cutout swords is exactly the "wholesome extreme violence" that this poster was talking about. But this is a more complex matter for apologists because if it's too wholesome nobody takes it seriously.

A final thought is in order here, Mormons have desensitized themselves to the suffering of others, but this is not merely rooted in the Book of Mormon's inability to be taken serious as real literature about violence. It's their beliefs or culture surrounding the afterlife. When people die that don't matter to them personally, it's no big deal because they are in a better place now, even Hitler will get the Telestial Kingdom. It's like Pac-Man dying except he just respawns in a different maze. No big deal. They'll get the gospel in the next life and have their chance, what's the big deal? Like if you're going to cutoff USAID and hundreds of thousands of people die as a result, Mormons will say exactly this. No big deal, they're in a better place now anyway,.

But it's fascinating, because I've had yet more experiences that reinforce my belief that when it comes to themselves personally, if they don't fear death, they don't go towards it with the high beliefs of reuniting with everyone like they preached about constantly up to that point. It's like reality is setting in. Anyway, the main point was they are desensitized to the death and suffering of others; such suffering and death is a cartoonish thing and Pac-Man always respawns anyway.
"...gain control of land that FARMS owned..." -- Bill Hamblin
"Why did FARMS own land to begin with?" -- Me
Post Reply