Page 1 of 9
Those Were the Days.
Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2026 12:21 am
by MG 2.0
I was looking at a post on another thread today and my mind wandered down memory lane. I thought about those that used to be on this board and what an interesting, kind, and thoughtful group that was here. Not to say that this isn’t the case nowadays… but I think it is less so. I’m going to cut and paste what I posted on the other thread in response to a poster that categorcally ‘demolished’ the Book of Mormon in one short paragraph.
MG 2.0 wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 11:56 pm
There have been a lot of conversations dealing with the Book of Mormon on this board over the years. Rather than beating a dead horse I will refer to just two of those I participated in:
viewtopic.php?f=4&t=101259&p=1524815&hi ... s#p1524815
viewtopic.php?f=4&t=100830&p=1516037&hi ... s#p1516037
There are actually whole bunch of threads that deal either partially or completely with truth claims and the Book of Mormon. I only spent five-ten minutes hitting on a few from way back.The Book of Mormon always comes to the forefront when discussing whether or not the CofJCofLDS is God’s church.
I think we ought to be careful about stating and/or coming to the conclusion…no questions asked…that the Book of Mormon is not what it purports to be. LONG and detailed conversations have been had on this board. Many of those involved are long gone. Boy, were they a joy to talk to. Things have unfortunately changed.
There wasn’t the vitriolic content we have seen here for too long. It is what it is and probably won’t change. I made a number of entreaties leading that direction yesterday with less than hopeful responses. I’m still hoping for change.
I’m sure that no one will actually spend any time with these blasts from the past. I only spent a few minutes. Long enough, however to see that we really had some good conversations about the Book of Mormon and other truth claims. This was back before many of the current board participants were around I think. Someone can correct me on that if I’m wrong.
Shades was here!
There was a degree of respect for all. Poisoning the well was more or less nonexistent.
Those were the days my friends I thought they’d never end we talk and chat forever and a day…and then things crashed. Now you have to be Board Certified and follow Free Speech Rules and be subject to Board Nannies.
Some of the older threads from years ago make me wish for a better time. I’m still hopeful.
Regards,
MG
Yesterday I spent a large part of the day working towards amends and also suggesting that the board could become a more civil and friendly place. I pretty much randomly picked a couple of threads, blasts from the past, to show how people interacted. I could pull many more that would show the same. You might notice that I, in particular, was not the “troll” that I have been painted as by Board Certified participants.
There are a few people here nowadays that are unable to let bygones be bygones and move on from what they saw as an isolated instance in which myself and another poster went back and forth and things did get rather heated. That poster later passed away from some sort of illness/ailment. Some posters here today wanted to essentially blame me even after I expressed my own sorrow and condolences that this poster had died.
Those grudges are expressed to this day by a few posters that are unable, apparently, to follow Jesus’s admonition to forgive each other. My hope is that after my expressions yesterday we can forgive and forget and move on. Otherwise the board will not be of the same caliber that it was a number of years ago.
Regards,
MG
Re: Those Were the Days.
Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2026 1:02 am
by Limnor
Ah, nostalgia. It seems like just yesterday the thread originator was accusing people of lying, circling the wagons to protect the guilty, something about fiddles, and elephant behavior.
Re: Those Were the Days.
Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2026 1:12 am
by MG 2.0
Limnor wrote: ↑Thu Nov 05, 2026 1:02 am
Ah, nostalgia. It seems like just yesterday the thread originator was accusing people of lying, circling the wagons to protect the guilty, something about fiddles, and elephant behavior.
Thank you for your response, Limnor. By the way, I think you would have enjoyed the board way back when. You’re right, nostalgia can bring back what are at many times happy memories.
I would imagine that if I continued my search…I literally spent about 5-10 minutes doing a quick search and getting a taste for the two threads I posted, I would not come up with a thread on the Book of Mormon having to do with your particular theory. There have been lots of theories regarding Book of Mormon origins over the years!
Yours is another one to add to the stack.
Regards,
MG
Re: Those Were the Days.
Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2026 3:43 am
by Marcus
MG 2.0 wrote: ↑Thu Nov 05, 2026 12:21 am
I was looking at a post on another thread today and my mind wandered down memory lane. I thought about those that used to be on this board and what an interesting, kind, and thoughtful group that was here...
..My hope is that after my expressions yesterday we can forgive and forget and move on. Otherwise the board will not be of the same caliber that it was a number of years ago...
Sigh. Every so often it's worth taking a look at mentalgymnast's history. Here's part of one of his earliest posts on this board, from 2007. Notice how judgmental and mean-spirited he is about that "interesting, kind, and thoughtful group" he is now reminiscing about.
posted June 2007:
_mentalgymnast wrote: ↑Sun Jun 03, 2007 6:35 am
...The PP's, Scratch's, Bond's, Shades of this board have issues because they have not been able to move beyond a primary/seminary outlook towards the world and the church. They will say they have, but I honestly don't believe this to be the case. They are black/white thinkers...if you can call it thinking.
They grew up literally thinking that all the thinking that ever had to be thunk had been done by someone other than themselves. They are very simplistic and naïve in their outlook towards what and who God is and how he may or may not operate in the universe. If he doesn't conform to their image, then he doesn't exist. They are ready and happy to jump on the secular bandwagon without the least provocation.
They will say otherwise and call those such as myself a fool for even alluding to the possibility that this may be the case, but nonetheless, it is not unreasonable to come to the conclusion that they are the ones that have been duped and deluded into thinking "inside the box" of skepticism and doubt, to the exclusion of other possibilities.
To find out that Mormonism was not simply what they larned in primary/seminary and reading the New Era or Ensign threw them for a loop from which they never were able to extricate themselves and recover. Thus, we find them and others like them supposedly "recovering" over at the RFM board or here...
MG's been stereotyping and trolling participants on this board in exactly the same manner for decades.
Re: Those Were the Days.
Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2026 4:02 am
by MG 2.0
Marcus wrote: ↑Thu Nov 05, 2026 3:43 am
MG 2.0 wrote: ↑Thu Nov 05, 2026 12:21 am
I was looking at a post on another thread today and my mind wandered down memory lane. I thought about those that used to be on this board and what an interesting, kind, and thoughtful group that was here...
..My hope is that after my expressions yesterday we can forgive and forget and move on. Otherwise the board will not be of the same caliber that it was a number of years ago...
Sigh. Every so often it's worth taking a look at mentalgymnast's history. Here's part of one of his earliest posts on this board, from 2007. Notice how judgmental and mean-spirited he is about that "interesting, kind, and thoughtful group" he is now reminiscing about.
posted June 2007:
_mentalgymnast wrote: ↑Sun Jun 03, 2007 6:35 am
...The PP's, Scratch's, Bond's, Shades of this board have issues because they have not been able to move beyond a primary/seminary outlook towards the world and the church. They will say they have, but I honestly don't believe this to be the case. They are black/white thinkers...if you can call it thinking.
They grew up literally thinking that all the thinking that ever had to be thunk had been done by someone other than themselves. They are very simplistic and naïve in their outlook towards what and who God is and how he may or may not operate in the universe. If he doesn't conform to their image, then he doesn't exist. They are ready and happy to jump on the secular bandwagon without the least provocation.
They will say otherwise and call those such as myself a fool for even alluding to the possibility that this may be the case, but nonetheless, it is not unreasonable to come to the conclusion that they are the ones that have been duped and deluded into thinking "inside the box" of skepticism and doubt, to the exclusion of other possibilities.
To find out that Mormonism was not simply what they larned in primary/seminary and reading the New Era or Ensign threw them for a loop from which they never were able to extricate themselves and recover. Thus, we find them and others like them supposedly "recovering" over at the RFM board or here...
MG's been stereotyping and trolling participants on this board in exactly the same manner for decades.
Thank you Marcus for posting this “blast from the past”. What I miss is being able to be somewhat frank with each other back then and express our views without being confrontational in the sense of having one, two, or three people among the mix that would perform the function of board certified interlocutor and finger pointer (I’ll leave it you to determine which finger

).
We were comfortable with each other and did not look over our shoulders wondering if the thought/speech police were going to inhibit our free speech. We worked things out.
It is now much different. If there are others that are still here from way back I think…if they are not afraid…they would back me up. We disagreed but knew we could come back and play in the sandbox of ideas again and again. Remember the days of Tip O’ Neill and Ronald Reagan and Gerald Ford? Antagonists yet friends.
Yesterday I attempted to make amends…along with putting other feelers out lately…and asked that we, meaning you and two or three others let bygones be bygones. I know bringing the teachings of Christ into it might not be what you would like…but He did have some awesome moral teachings that have been integrated into successful world cultures.
Forgiveness being near the top of the list.
I hope that you can find it within yourself to do so. I think I can. I don’t think it helps when we look for every little “offense”. Thanks for your response and I look forward to some productive conversations.
Regards,
MG
Re: Those Were the Days.
Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2026 4:56 am
by Gadianton
What I miss is being able to be somewhat frank with each other back then and express our views without being confrontational
I browsed through one of the links and it was very different from how an "MG" thread goes down today. In the thread I browsed, MG pretty much ignored everyone and just conversed wall-of-text style with Truth Dancer. For those who weren't there, Truth Dancer was an exceptionally kind-hearted and nice person, seemingly (to me) open to woo-style beliefs, and if I recall, she was also a therapist of some kind. And so basically, it looks like MG quickly latched onto this incredibly sympathetic, non-judgmental person with career experience helping people with psychological problems. Other people were responding to MG right and left, Dr. Shades himself completely eviscerated one of MG's posts, but MG just ignored it all and only responded to Truth Dancer. He did throw a couple bones to Guy, but Guy had made quite detailed and compelling responses that mostly got ignored.
Quite a different context -- I'm split on how to interpret it. The A theory is that having a sympathetic interlocutor who tolerated his interminable thought circles allowed him to ignore "detractors" in a conspicuous way. If he's got someone responding with sunshine, he could show he didn't need the others. The B theory is that he was better at controlling his impulses. He said upfront he wasn't the kind of person to be argumentative, and maybe he was better at ignoring posts that could lead in that direction. What I didn't see evidence of was the C theory that MG proposes, that there was more room for "frank expression" or whatever. If that were the case, then MG would have had some "respectful" back-and-forth with Shades, Guy, and a couple of others, instead of just ignoring them.
The presence of Truth Dancer, who was persistently nice to everyone no matter what, was nice to MG. That seems to be the main difference between then and now, and its hard to say whether that gave MG an out for flaring up against agitators or if he was just more determined to avoid conflict, but I'm not seeing evidence that "more civil" difficult discussions were going on, but that such discussions were avoided.
Re: Those Were the Days.
Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2026 5:52 am
by Marcus
MG 2.0 wrote: ↑Thu Nov 05, 2026 12:21 am
...There are a few people here nowadays that are unable to let bygones be bygones and move on from what they saw as an isolated instance in which myself and another poster went back and forth and things did get rather heated. That poster later passed away from some sort of illness/ailment. Some posters here today wanted to essentially blame me even after I expressed my own sorrow and condolences that this poster had died...
Ah, memory lane and those incidents MG sees as "isolated." His memories are so different!! You'd think he'd quit bringing these issues up, but he continues. No problem, quoting him sets the record straight..
Marcus wrote: ↑Fri Sep 05, 2025 3:29 am
...[MG] called grindael a 'loser' in the thread grindael started to announce that his paper had been accepted by a prestigious journal and that he had been asked to give a presentation on it at their annual conference. It was an amazing moment for our friend, and the mental gymnast did his best to destroy that moment by calling him a loser...
In mg's own words:
mg to grindael wrote:By the way, loser, we are already well aware that you don't believe in the Divine calling of Joseph Smith...so what's your point in preaching to the choir? You already know you're gonna just get high fives. So what's your point? Much ado about nothing, isn't it?
You're a loser, grindael. Ya, I know I just called you a loser. But the shoe fits.
Re: Those Were the Days.
Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2026 6:03 am
by MG 2.0
Marcus wrote: ↑Thu Nov 05, 2026 5:52 am
MG 2.0 wrote: ↑Thu Nov 05, 2026 12:21 am
...There are a few people here nowadays that are unable to let bygones be bygones and move on from what they saw as an isolated instance in which myself and another poster went back and forth and things did get rather heated. That poster later passed away from some sort of illness/ailment. Some posters here today wanted to essentially blame me even after I expressed my own sorrow and condolences that this poster had died...
Ah, memory lane and those incidents MG sees as "isolated." His memories are so different!! You'd think he'd quit bringing these issues up, but he continues. No problem, quoting him sets the record straight..
Marcus wrote: ↑Fri Sep 05, 2025 3:29 am
...[MG] called grindael a 'loser' in the thread grindael started to announce that his paper had been accepted by a prestigious journal and that he had been asked to give a presentation on it at their annual conference. It was an amazing moment for our friend, and the mental gymnast did his best to destroy that moment by calling him a loser...
In mg's own words:
mg to grindael wrote:By the way, loser, we are already well aware that you don't believe in the Divine calling of Joseph Smith...so what's your point in preaching to the choir? You already know you're gonna just get high fives. So what's your point? Much ado about nothing, isn't it?
You're a loser, grindael. Ya, I know I just called you a loser. But the shoe fits.
Again, thanks for taking us down memory lane, Marcus. I did call grindael a loser during our conversations. One thing to consider, it takes two to tango. We don’t have all the transcripts of our conversations in front of us at this point.
But yes, I said what I said within the context of a larger conversation where in my recollection he was no angel. Be that as it may, the time has come and gone. He is/will be missed.
I hope that knowing time is the great healer you will be able to get past this personal trauma that has caused you a great deal of distress. I feel bad you have had to experience the grief/trauma of seeing a friend being called a “loser” on a public message board. If I could do it all over I would have used more humane language as we each, unfortunately, threw insults at each other.
Definitely not one of my proudest moments.
Time has gone by. I’ve had time to reflect. I believe in repentance and forgiveness.
Regards,
MG
Re: Those Were the Days.
Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2026 6:11 am
by I Have Questions
Just for reference
this link leads to the path of forgiveness for MG2.0

Re: Those Were the Days.
Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2026 6:12 am
by MG 2.0
Gadianton wrote: ↑Thu Nov 05, 2026 4:56 am
What I miss is being able to be somewhat frank with each other back then and express our views without being confrontational
I browsed through one of the links and it was very different from how an "MG" thread goes down today. In the thread I browsed, MG pretty much ignored everyone and just conversed wall-of-text style with Truth Dancer. For those who weren't there, Truth Dancer was an exceptionally kind-hearted and nice person, seemingly (to me) open to woo-style beliefs, and if I recall, she was also a therapist of some kind. And so basically, it looks like MG quickly latched onto this incredibly sympathetic, non-judgmental person with career experience helping people with psychological problems. Other people were responding to MG right and left, Dr. Shades himself completely eviscerated one of MG's posts, but MG just ignored it all and only responded to Truth Dancer. He did throw a couple bones to Guy, but Guy had made quite detailed and compelling responses that mostly got ignored.
Quite a different context -- I'm split on how to interpret it. The A theory is that having a sympathetic interlocutor who tolerated his interminable thought circles allowed him to ignore "detractors" in a conspicuous way. If he's got someone responding with sunshine, he could show he didn't need the others. The B theory is that he was better at controlling his impulses. He said upfront he wasn't the kind of person to be argumentative, and maybe he was better at ignoring posts that could lead in that direction. What I didn't see evidence of was the C theory that MG proposes, that there was more room for "frank expression" or whatever. If that were the case, then MG would have had some "respectful" back-and-forth with Shades, Guy, and a couple of others, instead of just ignoring them.
The presence of Truth Dancer, who was persistently nice to everyone no matter what, was nice to MG. That seems to be the main difference between then and now, and its hard to say whether that gave MG an out for flaring up against agitators or if he was just more determined to avoid conflict, but I'm not seeing evidence that "more civil" difficult discussions were going on, but that such discussions were avoided.
Yes, also remember truth dancer to be quite civil and easy to talk to. I think this may be why we were able to carry on conversations like we did. Otherwise, I think you may be reading too much into the psychology of the conversations we had. I think you might agree that in many instances the tone and tenor of the conversations back then were not as overlayed with judgement, condemnation, and extreme hyperbole.
I would like to see this board actually go back to the ‘glory days’. I have that hope. Everyone has to on board though. There are some hold outs at this point. It might be slow but I think we could get there.
I really don’t think that constant offense/judgement needs to be the norm.
Thanks for the time you took to respond, gadianton.
Regards,
MG