Many, Many "Dimes" of DCP's "Paycheck" Came from Mopologetics: Explosive New Admissions on "SeN"

The catch-all forum for general topics and debates. Minimal moderation. Rated PG to PG-13.
User avatar
Doctor Scratch
B.H. Roberts Chair of Mopologetic Studies
Posts: 1660
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 7:24 pm
Location: Cassius University

Many, Many "Dimes" of DCP's "Paycheck" Came from Mopologetics: Explosive New Admissions on "SeN"

Post by Doctor Scratch »

Of course, of utmost importance in Mopologetics at the moment is Dr. Peterson's impending retirement. You have to wonder what that will mean for "Interpreter" and Mopologetics. What if he is called away on a mission? Will that spell doom for the movement? Then again, others have wondered if the retirement will usher in a new age of honesty.

Old school students of Mopologetics will no doubt remember Dr. Peterson's infamous assertion: "Not one dime of my salary comes from apologetics." This was a refrain that was repeated, perhaps, hundreds of times in various venues. It was hard to believe, though: so much of his professional time seemed to be devoted to Mopologetics and FARMS. He was clearly spending a lot of time doing that, and then we came to learn about the machinations that took place to allow FARMS publications to count towards promotions in certain BYU departments (not Hamblin's, though--he "took one for the team"). We even were made privy to publicly available, non-profit tax documents that showed, irrefutably, that Dr. Peterson had been compensated over $20,000 one year while he was serving as "Chair of FARMS." When we questioned him about this, he insisted that he was never paid the money. Was this an accounting error of some kind, then? "No," explained Jason Bourne--a poster from that era with experience in tax rules--"it's very common for a professor to get 'bought out' by another department, and that seems to be what happened here." Oh, okay! we said. That means that, yes, many, *MANY* dimes of DCP's salary came from Mopologetics: over $20,000, in fact, since that was the sum that, evidently, was "bought out." (It's either that, or he was paid the $20,000+ *on top* of his normal salary. Take your pick.)

This is an issue which has come up repeatedly on "Sic et Non," with the proprietor repeatedly denying the truth of the matter, which is that he was paid for his Mopologetic work at FARMS. Well, it may be that, at last, he's ready to come clean about it. Check this out:
DCP wrote:When I was hired, I was hired in some sense as a Jerusalem Center employee. Via arcane accounting paths that I never really cared to explore and cannot fully explain, I have always been a Jerusalem Center employee, although assigned to and responsible to the Department of Asian and Near Eastern Languages. And when I went over for several years to what became the Neal A. Maxwell Institute for Religious Scholarship, the primary portion of my paycheck still came from the Center via the Department. Or something like that.
Right...I guess? So he doesn't understand how he got paid. Sort of. But he at least was able to distinguish between "the primary portion of [his] paycheck," versus the "portion" that came from "the Neal A. Maxwell Institute for Religious Scholarship." So, yes: the $20,000+ was no doubt real. Glad to finally get that cleared up. You can't help but wonder, though, how big of a "portion" really was devoted to Mopologetics.

Meanwhile, Midgley had some extraordinarily uncouth things to day about Dr. Peterson's "work":
Louis Midgley wrote: Now that I am a ripe old 90, and sort of have time to think back on how I got to, as Hugh Nibley insisted on calling it, "the Brigham Young University," despite the fact that I had never once given teaching in Provo a single thought, I can see why Dan is now thinking back trying to figure out how he ended up in Provo. I must say that he being hired to do whatever he has been doing at the BYU has very much blessed my life.
Whoa...You mean he wasn't working as a Professor of Middle Eastern Studies? Midgley, once again, helps to clear things up:
Midgley wrote: I could not have imagined or designed a better EDITOR than Dan, of a better academic journal than what he began to call attention to publications on the Book of Mormon. That soon changed academic publishing among Latter-day Saints. My world also was radically changed by discovering Hugh Nibley who came to the University of Utah when I was an undergraduate to give a lecture on ancient political regimes. But I never imagined that I would end up teaching at BYU. But when I was working on my PhD at Brown University in Providence, Rhode Island, I suddenly was invited by Ernest Wilkinson, who was then the President of BYU, to visit with him in Provo. He did this to hire me, he told me, because an Apostle had ordered him to do so. My father had introduced me to several of the Brethren. One of whom asked my father how I was doing. That conversation led to my being hired by ELW. I taught for a year, and then, as planned, took a leave, and returned to Brown to finish my degree.
Holy crap! Talk about nepotism! This seems like an admission that Midgley basically doesn't have any actual skills beyond being born with a silver spoon in his mouth. Then again, I wonder if we might interpret this another way. Maybe this "Apostle" knew about young Midgley's temperament, and *wanted* him there at BYU in order to stir up trouble? Perhaps to get Wilkinson kicked out as Pres.? Midgley *was* embroiled in that affair, after all.

Very interesting revelations, in any case.
"If, while hoping that everybody else will be honest and so forth, I can personally prosper through unethical and immoral acts without being detected and without risk, why should I not?." --Daniel Peterson, 6/4/14
User avatar
Tom
God
Posts: 1070
Joined: Mon Oct 26, 2020 3:41 pm
Location: Sego, Utah
Contact:

Re: Many, Many "Dimes" of DCP's "Paycheck" Came from Mopologetics: Explosive New Admissions on "SeN"

Post by Tom »

I’m left wondering about a few matters:

1. What obligations, if any, did Dr. Peterson have to the Center as an employee? Did he serve as Center director or associate director? How many times did he direct an intensive language program or teach at the Center?

2. Who was the apostle who “ordered” Wilkinson to interview/hire Dr. Midgley? Did the unidentified apostle actually “order” Wilkinson? Perhaps Gary Bergera will stop by and share if Wilkinson made mention of an “order” or the interview in his diary.
User avatar
Gadianton
God
Posts: 6562
Joined: Sun Oct 25, 2020 11:56 pm
Location: Elsewhere

Re: Many, Many "Dimes" of DCP's "Paycheck" Came from Mopologetics: Explosive New Admissions on "SeN"

Post by Gadianton »

This is all quite a lot to take in, Doctor. It's fascinating that payment from a special project would be doled out for "run rate" university teaching. Did I read that correctly that the Jerusalem center paid part of the salary even while squarely "back home" working for the MI?

On the one hand, indeed it could mean that the Jerusalem Center was doing missionary work in a round-a-bout way. It could also mean something else more sinister. Now, this is pure speculation on my part, but I imagine at that time, there was quite a bit of anxiety and enthusiasm among the Saints for taking over Jerusalem. In the 70s and 80s, Mormons were excited about prophecy, and excited about the second coming, and unlike today, the excitement was contained within official church boundaries. There was rampant speculation that the prophet knew more than he let on about the second coming of Jesus Christ. Part of this prophecy is the gathering of Israel to Israel, and the rebuilding of the temple in Jerusalem itself.

I can imagine wealthy Saints being especially eager to contribute to anything directly related to prophecy like a Jerusalem Center. And as the main blogger on the site said, there indeed were initial plans to create a missionary program. I can only imagine that private funding with promises of a missionary effort to Israel, that directly plays into prophecies of the Second Coming, would have wealthy TBMs handing over their extra cash. But then, as reality set in, the dream became a compromise. And so it turns out, the project is ridiculously over-funded.

The Brethren may have said, why burn tithing money to pay salaries, especially if we have some of these "soft" in-between positions that are half teaching, and half "seeding" a core base of company men? Just let that over-funded project keep this stuff going.

Switching gears here, but didn't Midgley also say his wife was "ordered" to introduce herself to him, or something like that? God seems to have roughed up more than a few individuals to make sure Mr. Midgley felt special.
Lost Gospel of Thomas 1:8 - And Jesus said, "what about the Pharisees? They did it too! Wherefore, we shall do it even more!"
Philo Sofee
God
Posts: 5928
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 1:18 am

Re: Many, Many "Dimes" of DCP's "Paycheck" Came from Mopologetics: Explosive New Admissions on "SeN"

Post by Philo Sofee »

Gadianton
Switching gears here, but didn't Midgley also say his wife was "ordered" to introduce herself to him, or something like that? God seems to have roughed up more than a few individuals to make sure Mr. Midgley felt special.
This is just sooooooo Midgley. On the other hand, perhaps there is a God in control, because, forsooth! Midgley never became a General Authority. God could be said to have seen what future shenanigans would have come from General Conference with Midgley in charge, and therefore headed it off at the pass before it got started in the earthly paperwork.... :D
User avatar
Bought Yahoo
High Councilman
Posts: 523
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 8:59 pm

Re: Many, Many "Dimes" of DCP's "Paycheck" Came from Mopologetics: Explosive New Admissions on "SeN"

Post by Bought Yahoo »

Midgley is a great man. I know him and interviewed him for a paper I never published over the Spy scandal.
User avatar
Everybody Wang Chung
God
Posts: 3700
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 1:52 am

Re: Many, Many "Dimes" of DCP's "Paycheck" Came from Mopologetics: Explosive New Admissions on "SeN"

Post by Everybody Wang Chung »

Bought Yahoo wrote:
Sun Apr 18, 2021 7:26 pm
Midgley is a great man.
That’s exactly what Gina Colvin and Gemli said.
"I'm on paid sabbatical from BYU in exchange for my promise to use this time to finish two books."

Daniel C. Peterson, 2014
User avatar
Dr Moore
Endowed Chair of Historical Innovation
Posts: 1908
Joined: Mon Oct 26, 2020 2:16 pm
Location: Cassius University

Re: Many, Many "Dimes" of DCP's "Paycheck" Came from Mopologetics: Explosive New Admissions on "SeN"

Post by Dr Moore »

It’s an odd twist on the Faustian bargain. Sure, to give up on great worldly riches for the promise of eternal life, sounds moral and all. And who cares if BYU pays for it? BYU exists to serve the glory of God, right?

But that’s all just a straw man anyway because no one goes into academics for great riches. So what’s really being traded for what? I think it’s Faustian after all. In exchange for another year of employment, and the praise of a few ecclesiastical leaders, the Mopologist jettisons that which is most prized among peers: academic integrity.
User avatar
Doctor Scratch
B.H. Roberts Chair of Mopologetic Studies
Posts: 1660
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 7:24 pm
Location: Cassius University

Re: Many, Many "Dimes" of DCP's "Paycheck" Came from Mopologetics: Explosive New Admissions on "SeN"

Post by Doctor Scratch »

Gadianton wrote:
Sun Apr 18, 2021 4:47 pm
This is all quite a lot to take in, Doctor. It's fascinating that payment from a special project would be doled out for "run rate" university teaching. Did I read that correctly that the Jerusalem center paid part of the salary even while squarely "back home" working for the MI?
That was my impression. Of course, we've been told *many* things over the years! It seems always that the intention is to deflect attention away from the fact that dollars were spent on Mopologetics. I don't know why anybody tries to cover that up these days. With the mud being slung at the Heartlanders, plus the money flowing into BMC, FAIR, and other organizations--either directly, or funneled through the More Good Foundation--it seems pretty much an established fact at this point that Mopologetics gets money from the Church.
On the one hand, indeed it could mean that the Jerusalem Center was doing missionary work in a round-a-bout way. It could also mean something else more sinister. Now, this is pure speculation on my part, but I imagine at that time, there was quite a bit of anxiety and enthusiasm among the Saints for taking over Jerusalem. In the 70s and 80s, Mormons were excited about prophecy, and excited about the second coming, and unlike today, the excitement was contained within official church boundaries. There was rampant speculation that the prophet knew more than he let on about the second coming of Jesus Christ. Part of this prophecy is the gathering of Israel to Israel, and the rebuilding of the temple in Jerusalem itself.

I can imagine wealthy Saints being especially eager to contribute to anything directly related to prophecy like a Jerusalem Center. And as the main blogger on the site said, there indeed were initial plans to create a missionary program. I can only imagine that private funding with promises of a missionary effort to Israel, that directly plays into prophecies of the Second Coming, would have wealthy TBMs handing over their extra cash. But then, as reality set in, the dream became a compromise. And so it turns out, the project is ridiculously over-funded.

The Brethren may have said, why burn tithing money to pay salaries, especially if we have some of these "soft" in-between positions that are half teaching, and half "seeding" a core base of company men? Just let that over-funded project keep this stuff going.
Huh. That's certainly an idiosyncratic interpretation, Dean Robbers. You're saying that DCP's BYU position was a "failed" marketing strategy on the part of the Brethren? Like, they had him on board with this Second Coming/Jerusalem plan, but that fell through, and so they shuffled him off to BYU? The thing is: I think his BYU position somewhat predates his involvement with FARMS, though I could be wrong about that. Plus, it's not clear to me when, exactly, the Brethren took an interest in "co-opting" Mopologetics.
"If, while hoping that everybody else will be honest and so forth, I can personally prosper through unethical and immoral acts without being detected and without risk, why should I not?." --Daniel Peterson, 6/4/14
User avatar
Gadianton
God
Posts: 6562
Joined: Sun Oct 25, 2020 11:56 pm
Location: Elsewhere

Re: Many, Many "Dimes" of DCP's "Paycheck" Came from Mopologetics: Explosive New Admissions on "SeN"

Post by Gadianton »

Doctor Scratch wrote:Huh. That's certainly an idiosyncratic interpretation, Dean Robbers. You're saying that DCP's BYU position was a "failed" marketing strategy on the part of the Brethren? Like, they had him on board with this Second Coming/Jerusalem plan, but that fell through, and so they shuffled him off to BYU? The thing is: I think his BYU position somewhat predates his involvement with FARMS, though I could be wrong about that. Plus, it's not clear to me when, exactly, the Brethren took an interest in "co-opting" Mopologetics.
Not exactly -- I'm saying that the "Jerusalem plan" was marketed as something really huge and brought in a lot of money. From what was described, by the time the thing actually got going, it's vision had shrunk substantially. Like, let's say originally the plan would have included hiring a hundred people for the Jerusalem facility, but turned out to only employ 10. So when he went back to BYU, and again this is speculation, they could just continue to pay for his salary from that project fund, which was way overfunded, rather than waste tithing money.
Lost Gospel of Thomas 1:8 - And Jesus said, "what about the Pharisees? They did it too! Wherefore, we shall do it even more!"
User avatar
Kishkumen
God
Posts: 10376
Joined: Tue Oct 27, 2020 2:37 pm
Location: Cassius University
Contact:

Re: Many, Many "Dimes" of DCP's "Paycheck" Came from Mopologetics: Explosive New Admissions on "SeN"

Post by Kishkumen »

I always enjoy Prof. Midgley's reminiscences about his BYU experience. They are usually revelatory.
"He disturbs the laws of his country, he forces himself upon women, and he puts men to death without trial.” ~Otanes on the monarch, Herodotus Histories 3.80.
Post Reply