subgenius wrote:MeDotOrg wrote:To me, waxing nostalgic about the Antebellum south is like ...(snip)....
This is my point about nostalgia as noted above. And further how you have no insight into southern culture or its nuances at all levels. And this only inasmuch as nostalgia is not just a political tool here, but everywhere.
By your narrow measure any evocation of the past must be dismissed because it is impossible to not find some group of disenfranchised people from that time.
History is winners and loses my friend. Sure there was slavery in some places, and povery in others, and disease, and illiteracy, and wild animals, and Apollo crashes, and deceit....and those who forgo nostalgia because the glass will never be full.
The Andrews Sisters had some great advice, that apparently should be dismissed because...well, because Negroes couldn't vote when the song was popular and thus....
Moore doesn't think any time since the civil war was great. That's the last time the US was great. Meanwhile, flash-forward to the present, and Moore thinks the US is the focus of modern evil in the world due to gay marriage. So this isn't generic nostalgia for an amorphous past. It's Moore identifying the antebellum South as peak US culture in comparison to anything that came since. Thinking about slavery is not a blemish on this sufficient to take the bloom off that rose, but gay marriage is sufficient reason to condemn the United States in the harshest terms possible.
When Obama was scandalized because he attended Church with a pastor who said "God damn America" because of its ongoing problems with racism, that was a conflagration of outrage in mainstream conservatism. When the actual Republican candidate also criticizes America as a font of evil, in this case because of same sex marriage, and that is contrasted with is praise for America when millions of people were in slavery, why that's totes fine. What's the problem?