I thought that I would begin today's review of "Pt 3 FAIR Conference" with an epigraph:
I'm not sure why you think this somehow a personal insult. Making judgments about the reliability of scholars and scholarly books is a principal and quite legitimate task of academic reviewing, just as judging the quality of films, plays, symphonies, and novels is the legitimate principal task of film, drama, music, and literary critics. ---Daniel C. Peterson
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IjUUFBkjjz8&feature=userThe film, once again featuring K. Shirt's signature
cinema verite style, opens up with The Backyard Professor exclaiming "Eight-five bucks!" as he hefts and inspects the price of a book on Mormon history/geography. On to the highlights:
---At 30 seconds in, Jan makes an appearance. This, I believe, is the same Jan who became notorious during the whole "Murphy transcript" episode. K. Shirts urges her to "Say hello to Bill Hamblin" since he is "too snooty" to join the goings-on at the FAIR conference.
---At 1:25, Kerry Shirts addresses the camera once again, this time with his arm slung around the shoulders of Renee Olson. He tells both Renee and the camera that Bill Hamblin is busy at Oxford. Sis. Olson responds by stating, "I'm busy being the token Black." Shirts uncorks an uncomfortable laugh at this and searches Olson's face for meaning. He tries to diffuse the situation by saying, "Okay, I'll be the token White." Olson does him one better: "No, you're the token Court Jester." Well played, madame!
---2:28, we meet (in Shirts's words) the "World Famous Matt Roper." Roper, as many here will recall, was implicated by DCP as being responsible for the bogus "Florida Horse" citation on the FARMS FAQ. Roper is also believed to be on the full-time payroll as an apologist. He was also present during Louis Midgley's verbal harangue of Sandra Tanner.
---3:11, Shirts introduces us to LifeOnaPlate and his wife. Shirts says of her, "She's the better half." LoaP glumly replies, "She's the shorter half," forcing a smile and stalking off cantankerously, pretending to look at the book display. "That's the only thing impressive about her?" says Shirts, chuckling, to LoaP's back. But LoaP makes no reply.
---3:39, The Backyard Professor bashes the work of Dan Vogel: "Look at that!" he says. "We even have Dan Vogel's junk, er... 'stuff.'" "Don't ever let it be said that we're narrow-minded," he later muses.
--AT 6:00, Shirts notices a display for LDS "Women's Studies" books. "That's ridiculous!" he ejaculates. "We're supposed to be narrow-minded, and, uh, patriarchal, and---vicious! What are we doing promoting
women's studies???"
---The film concludes with Alan Wyatt stepping on both of Kerry's feet. The Backyard Professor yelps in obvious pain at this. Afterwards, he mugs with LoaP, and the young man from earlier, who is now identified as "rommelator."
I have to say, this installment offered far more drama and intrigue as compared with the prior to reviewed episodes. Because of this, I am going to rate this film 2 stars (out of four). If director Shirts can maintain this caliber of filmmaking and acting, then his career---which already totals well over 400 videos on YouTube---should take off.