Problems With Christianity

The catch-all forum for general topics and debates. Minimal moderation. Rated PG to PG-13.
Post Reply
_Some Schmo
_Emeritus
Posts: 15602
Joined: Tue Mar 27, 2007 2:59 pm

Re: Problems With Christianity

Post by _Some Schmo »

Calculus Crusader wrote:I do not believe hell is a literal lake of fire. As Origen wrote in De Principiis, Book II: ...

OK, so they either make crap up or quote crap someone else has made up. Either way...

It reminds me of the child who makes up a story to cover his butt, and then has to keep on elaborating on the lie to cover up all the past lies and inconsistencies.

One thing I will give religion: it sure can make people creative.
God belief is for people who don't want to live life on the universe's terms.
_huckelberry
_Emeritus
Posts: 4559
Joined: Wed Dec 27, 2006 2:29 am

Re: Problems With Christianity

Post by _huckelberry »

Anti shock, I am not sure why you think God is unaware of his portion of responsiblity for the shortcoming of people. He has after all indicated he is doing all he can to forgive people.

I am going to make a bit of a reply to the too many uglies in life argument. First I think it is an argument against Gods existence that has some weight. After all there is always that possiblity that there is no god. It is an possible theory. But I think that several of you are trying to make the argumeant go further than it has wings. You are saying that if there is a God he is either dumb or ill willed. I think there are serious shortcoming ing the knowledge assumption employed to say that.

I do not wish to say you ought to believe in God due to these knowlege limits. I think you might recogize certain limits they imply.

Simply I find it astonishing that people feel perfectly confident in saying God ought to have been able to make a universe with live real people with out the pains and problems we see. I cannot imagine how or on what basis any of you know any such thing. There could be serious difficulty in making any kind of humans. I believe and Christianity as always assumed that in addition to that God created us with larger intentions than are immediately visible. I cannot say for sure how each portion of the difficulties of life contribute to that better end. I can only see indications in how our mutual concern and courage contribute to a better body human. To say that God could accomplish creation and the Kingdom of God with humans full participants without the dangers and suffering of this present age is the highth of absurd presumption. None of us here have the fainest idea what difficuty may be involved in creating heavens and earth.

I am reminded of myself and a friend who while barely starting grade school decided to make a spaceship. It was a fine idea we had the shape and a plan for a engion. We set up a workshop and bought materiials. However it was not all that long before we found that fashioning sheet metal into a rocket five ft tall was easier said than done. Gasoline made good heat but was diffult to focus into a thrust producing rocket. Oh well the cronstuction was too ugly to be public and the bon fire its finest moment.

Us humans presuming we know what God should do making heaven and earth is like grade school chlldren making rockets. The only difference is that we children were proportionately far closer to knowing how to make a space ship than our critics of God are to knowing how to make heaven and earth.

As a believer I realize that the point of suffering is something I must explore and discover to what extent I can. I really have no choice, it is part of life. Yall have to do the same, believe in God or not.
_Chap
_Emeritus
Posts: 14190
Joined: Mon Jun 11, 2007 10:23 am

Re: Problems With Christianity

Post by _Chap »

Some Schmo wrote:
Calculus Crusader wrote:I do not believe hell is a literal lake of fire. As Origen wrote in De Principiis, Book II: ...

OK, so they either make crap up or quote crap someone else has made up. Either way...

It reminds me of the child who makes up a story to cover his butt, and then has to keep on elaborating on the lie to cover up all the past lies and inconsistencies.

One thing I will give religion: it sure can make people creative.


Some Schmo's contribution is cast in a style appropriate to what he is having to comment on, and I think it is right on the button.

"You have a valid criticism of my theology as stated, and I can't think of a way to rebut it directly? OK, then I shall go back and re-word my theology so as to allow myself to slither past the criticism in some way."

And so on ... until the critic gets bored and goes away. Then you get to say;

"These unbelievers have such crude and simplistic views of our wonderful and subtle faith."

But what faith? It is a target that simply will not stay still.
Zadok:
I did not have a faith crisis. I discovered that the Church was having a truth crisis.
Maksutov:
That's the problem with this supernatural stuff, it doesn't really solve anything. It's a placeholder for ignorance.
_antishock8
_Emeritus
Posts: 2425
Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2008 2:02 am

Re: Problems With Christianity

Post by _antishock8 »

Huck,

I'm agreeing with you. That's the point. Your god knows exactly what he's doing, and it's disgusting. He delights in:

http://www.wickedrock.co.za/Images/gene ... balism.jpg
(Moderator Note)Picture listed above is graphic. Click on link at your own risk. Liz

Otherwise, he wouldn't have designed a system and creatures that would participate in such a thing. Your god knew, beforehand, that what he was creating would eventually kill, and then eat, another human being.

That, my friend, is sick. That's your god. He did it. He designed it. He programmed it. He let it play out. And he watches. Do the math.
You can’t trust adults to tell you the truth.

Scream the lie, whisper the retraction.- The Left
_Roger Morrison
_Emeritus
Posts: 1831
Joined: Sat Nov 11, 2006 4:13 am

Re: Problems With Christianity

Post by _Roger Morrison »

antishock8 wrote:Huck,

I'm agreeing with you. That's the point. Your god knows exactly what he's doing, and it's disgusting. He delights in:

http://www.wickedrock.co.za/Images/gene ... balism.jpg
(Moderator Note) Picture is graphic. Click on above link at our own risk. Liz

Otherwise, he wouldn't have designed a system and creatures that would participate in such a thing. Your god knew, beforehand, that what he was creating would eventually kill, and then eat, another human being.

That, my friend, is sick. That's your god. He did it. He designed it. He programmed it. He let it play out. And he watches. Do the math.


YIKES!!!!!!!! Yeah, "GOD" IS good, eh!?

It is REALLY hard to believe that thinking, intelligent beings can be so mislead and duped to believe in any form of a "God" as presented in Judeo-Christianism. Or, in any other religion that I am aware of...

How long did it take the Irish to let go their belief in Leprechauns? (Assuming they have :-) How long will it take Religious-God-believers to understand they are spiritually/mentally/emotionally dwelling in the realm of fantasy, while living in and exploiting the natural, material world???

"God" only knows... :rolleyes:
Roger
*
*
Have you noticed what a beautiful day it is? Some can't...
"God": nick-name for the Universe...
_Jason Bourne
_Emeritus
Posts: 9207
Joined: Sun Oct 29, 2006 8:00 pm

Re: Problems With Christianity

Post by _Jason Bourne »

I'm agreeing with you. That's the point. Your god knows exactly what he's doing, and it's disgusting. He delights in:


Can we delete the disgusting picture please?
_Jason Bourne
_Emeritus
Posts: 9207
Joined: Sun Oct 29, 2006 8:00 pm

Re: Problems With Christianity

Post by _Jason Bourne »



I can understand why they baptize babies but don't understand why any Catholic could believe these babies are going to hell if they didn't do this ordinance before their death. We are born into a fallen world and are baptized to be symbolically reclaimed by Christ but why that would literally be required I don't understand. Anyone who has raised children can tell you that a two year old having a temper tantrum is a fallen being and not innocent. We are born into carnal bodies, learning to overcome the natural man desires and become Godly. It makes less sense to baptize at age 8 as some kind of magic number of accountability. My 4 year old is perfectly capable of sinning and understanding it was wrong.
The point of baptism is not to wash away Adam's sins, or because we are now accountable for our own, it's that we are fallen from the moment we are born on this earth because of Adam and Eve's Fall, all part of the plan.
This is why Mormons have it wrong on the age of baptism, and Catholics have the age right in my opinion.


If you believe original sin is a true doctrine of course you would conclude this. But others disagree. And honestly, one questions the mercy of a God that would send a baby to Hell because it was born into a sinful world and did nothing of its own accord to sin.



This point is wrong because Christians believe that Christ is God. If my Savior came to suffer for me, and He is my Father, I don't see it as sick and twisted. The Mormon belief on the Father sending His only begotten Son instead of himself makes no sense to me.


Uh no. What you say above that Christians believe is called modalism. And why many understand the trinity this way it is a heresy. Christians believe that God the Son, one personage of the One God came to earth, not God the Father.

The sacrifice of Jesus is evidence of how much He loves us.
The atonement was needed to teach us charity, to become perfected by learning the pure love of Christ, the Father. Without it, we wouldn't have to forgive and couldn't become like Him.


But why can't an omnipotent God just forgive? Why does he demand blood? Nobody seems able to answer this.



I'm not sure how many Christians believe this.


Oh I think quite a few do.


I also don't believe Mormons have it right either. I believe if there is a heaven with
kingdoms of glory, that there will be progression through them. The temple endowment teaches that progression is REQUIRED. Hell is the place of darkness and separation within us because of our sins. We won't have peace until we repent.


You could be right. Nobody really knows.


If we have charity, we wouldn't care about Hitler being in the same place as us if he repents. That's the purpose of the atonement. There is not a get out of hell free card for them. They will suffer horribly for their sins when they repent. What matters is that we love them the way Christ does and hope for them to progress and have salvation if we expect to be saved for our sins. Would you want any of your children in hell for eternity? NO. We would always hope for our children to repent and come home. That's how I believe God loves us and how we should love even the most evil men. I like this quote from Mark Twain:

"But who prays for Satan? Who, in eighteen centuries, has had the common humanity to pray for the one sinner that needed it most?"


I guess that is true. We would want even the most heinous person to be forgiven if the repent if we have true charity.

I disagree. By Mormonism claiming to have solutions for these problems, they introduced many new ones.
I had MANY items on my shelf as a TBM that I wouldn't have had with mainstream Christianity.


Well I think Mormonism goes a long way to answering some of the absurdities of historical Christianity. Does it create some other problems? yep.
_Calculus Crusader
_Emeritus
Posts: 1495
Joined: Sun Jan 28, 2007 5:52 am

Re: Problems With Christianity

Post by _Calculus Crusader »

Chap wrote:
Some Schmo's contribution is cast in a style appropriate to what he is having to comment on, and I think it is right on the button.

"You have a valid criticism of my theology as stated, and I can't think of a way to rebut it directly? OK, then I shall go back and re-word my theology so as to allow myself to slither past the criticism in some way."

And so on ... until the critic gets bored and goes away. Then you get to say;

"These unbelievers have such crude and simplistic views of our wonderful and subtle faith."

But what faith? It is a target that simply will not stay still.


Origen wrote well over seventeen centuries ago, so this interpretation is hardly new. Besides which, it still involves punishment. In fact, no theologian I know of who believed/believes in a literal lake of fire thought/thinks poena sensus (pain of sense) is a greater punishment than poena damni (pain of loss).
Caeli enarrant gloriam Dei

(I lost access to my Milesius account, so I had to retrieve this one from the mothballs.)
_Jason Bourne
_Emeritus
Posts: 9207
Joined: Sun Oct 29, 2006 8:00 pm

Re: Problems With Christianity

Post by _Jason Bourne »


Simply I find it astonishing that people feel perfectly confident in saying God ought to have been able to make a universe with live real people with out the pains and problems we see. I cannot imagine how or on what basis any of you know any such thing. There could be serious difficulty in making any kind of humans. I believe and Christianity as always assumed that in addition to that God created us with larger intentions than are immediately visible. I cannot say for sure how each portion of the difficulties of life contribute to that better end. I can only see indications in how our mutual concern and courage contribute to a better body human. To say that God could accomplish creation and the Kingdom of God with humans full participants without the dangers and suffering of this present age is the highth of absurd presumption. None of us here have the fainest idea what difficuty may be involved in creating heavens and earth.


But Huck

Even in Christian theology you have a God that did create a more perfect state of existence for created beings called angels. Angels, while invested with free will, do not experience anything like the suffering heaped on mankind due to Adam's fall.
_antishock8
_Emeritus
Posts: 2425
Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2008 2:02 am

Re: Problems With Christianity

Post by _antishock8 »

Jason,

Why are you disgusted by your god's creation? He apparently isn't.

Huck,

Your god DID create a place without suffering... It's called Heaven. Again, your god delights in creating pain and misery because he created it. There's really no room for argument here if you consider your god all-powerful and all-knowing.
You can’t trust adults to tell you the truth.

Scream the lie, whisper the retraction.- The Left
Post Reply