You are not God. It is not up to you to decide the eternal fate of another individual. It is God's...and God's alone.
This is unscriptural and undoctrinal. bc is not judging anyone's eternal fate. God delegates to his prophets and his faithful Saints the authority and power (discerning of spirits etc.) to make judgements regarding ideas, concepts, attitudes, tendencies, and the behavior of others according to settled gospel standards. The Saints have a body of core purposes and missions while in mortality, and one of them is to
raise a voice of warning.I snipped the rest of these relativisitic rationalizations because none of it was relevant to the central point: we are here to judge, discriminate, scrutinize, comprehend, preach, teach, expound, exhort and warn.
We are also, in righteousness, to denounce and excoriate evil when appropriate, and not be intellectual and moral cowards and shrink away from that responsibility.
Need I say "Proposition 8?"