Brigham Young doesn’t deserve his online criticism

The catch-all forum for general topics and debates. Minimal moderation. Rated PG to PG-13.
Fence Sitter
Bishop
Posts: 486
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 2:02 am

Re: Brigham Young doesn’t deserve his online criticism

Post by Fence Sitter »

Doctor Steuss wrote:
Thu Apr 11, 2024 2:49 pm
Wild how people who have direct access to eternal truths, and divine morals and ethics tend to reliably just end up being products of their time.
Current prophetic leadership is the exception. Amiright?
User avatar
Tom
Apostle
Posts: 778
Joined: Mon Oct 26, 2020 3:41 pm

Re: Brigham Young doesn’t deserve his online criticism

Post by Tom »

Proprietor:
In 1859, Horace Greeley, the famous editor of the New York Daily Tribune, visited Utah Territory and interviewed Brigham Young. In the course of the interview, Greeley asked whether Utah planned to be a slave state. “No,” Brigham replied, “she will be a Free State.” He proceeded to explain that “Slavery here would prove useless and unprofitable. I regard it generally as a curse to the masters. . . . Utah is not adapted to Slave Labor.” (26)
A fuller excerpt from the interview (see column on far right) is worth providing:
Horace Greeley (H.G.)—What is the position of your Church with respect to slavery?

Brigham Young (B.Y.)—We consider it of Divine institution, and not to be abolished until the curse pronounced on Ham shall have been removed from his descendants.

H.G.—Are any slaves now held in this Territory?

B.Y.—There are.

H.G.—Do your Territorial laws uphold Slavery?

B.Y.—Those laws are printed—you can read for yourself. If slaves are brought here by those who owned them in the States, we do not favor their escape from the service of those owners.

H.G.—Am I to infer that Utah, if admitted as a member of the Federal Union, will be a Slave State?

B.Y.—No; she will be a Free State. Slavery here would prove useless and unprofitable. I regard it generally as a curse to the masters. I myself hire many laborers, and pay them fair wages; I could not afford to own them. I can do better than subject myself to an obligation to feed and clothe their families, to provide and care for them in sickness and health. Utah is not adapted to Slave Labor.
“But if you are told by your leader to do a thing, do it. None of your business whether it is right or wrong.” Heber C. Kimball, 8 Nov. 1857
User avatar
Dr. Shades
Founder and Visionary
Posts: 2323
Joined: Mon Oct 26, 2020 2:48 pm
Contact:

Re: Brigham Young doesn’t deserve his online criticism

Post by Dr. Shades »

Kishkumen wrote:
Wed Apr 10, 2024 9:56 pm
Criticism of historical figures is a practically irresistible pastime.
In your opinion, is it ever justified? If so, who?
.
"I think the idea of repairing a corpse does not work very well."

--huckelberry, 08-26-2024
User avatar
Doctor Steuss
God
Posts: 1912
Joined: Tue Oct 27, 2020 8:48 pm

Re: Brigham Young doesn’t deserve his online criticism

Post by Doctor Steuss »

Tom wrote:
Thu Apr 11, 2024 4:18 pm
Proprietor:
In 1859, Horace Greeley, the famous editor of the New York Daily Tribune, visited Utah Territory and interviewed Brigham Young. In the course of the interview, Greeley asked whether Utah planned to be a slave state. “No,” Brigham replied, “she will be a Free State.” He proceeded to explain that “Slavery here would prove useless and unprofitable. I regard it generally as a curse to the masters. . . . Utah is not adapted to Slave Labor.” (26)
A fuller excerpt from the interview (see column on far right) is worth providing:
Horace Greeley (H.G.)—What is the position of your Church with respect to slavery?

Brigham Young (B.Y.)—We consider it of Divine institution, and not to be abolished until the curse pronounced on Ham shall have been removed from his descendants.

H.G.—Are any slaves now held in this Territory?

B.Y.—There are.

H.G.—Do your Territorial laws uphold Slavery?

B.Y.—Those laws are printed—you can read for yourself. If slaves are brought here by those who owned them in the States, we do not favor their escape from the service of those owners.

H.G.—Am I to infer that Utah, if admitted as a member of the Federal Union, will be a Slave State?

B.Y.—No; she will be a Free State. Slavery here would prove useless and unprofitable. I regard it generally as a curse to the masters. I myself hire many laborers, and pay them fair wages; I could not afford to own them. I can do better than subject myself to an obligation to feed and clothe their families, to provide and care for them in sickness and health. Utah is not adapted to Slave Labor.
That's some interesting selective quoting.

It's good to know that Brigham's thoughts on why chattel slavery was a curse on the masters was because he thought it was more expensive than just paying someone a wage. Not because it was morally repugnant to keep a human being as personal property.
drumdude
God
Posts: 6418
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 5:29 am

Re: Brigham Young doesn’t deserve his online criticism

Post by drumdude »

Daniel is a very amateur historian, we should give him a break for unknowingly selectively quoting that passage. It’s not like he is a PhD scholar or anything. He probably had no idea the full context.
User avatar
Doctor Steuss
God
Posts: 1912
Joined: Tue Oct 27, 2020 8:48 pm

Re: Brigham Young doesn’t deserve his online criticism

Post by Doctor Steuss »

Doctor Steuss wrote:
Thu Apr 11, 2024 5:40 pm
It's good to know that Brigham's thoughts on why chattel slavery was a curse on the masters was because he thought it was more expensive than just paying someone a wage. Not because it was morally repugnant to keep a human being as personal property.
Incidentally, this incredibly enlightened moral view of Brigham Young's, that he espoused to Greeley, was after he had kept and used the enslaved Green Flake for several years.

This little light of mine...
toon
Valiant B
Posts: 197
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 5:23 pm

Re: Brigham Young doesn’t deserve his online criticism

Post by toon »

Fence Sitter wrote:
Thu Apr 11, 2024 4:07 pm
Doctor Steuss wrote:
Thu Apr 11, 2024 2:49 pm
Wild how people who have direct access to eternal truths, and divine morals and ethics tend to reliably just end up being products of their time.
Current prophetic leadership is the exception. Amiright?
We'll only know in 100 years, give or take. Until then ... follow the Prophet.
Last edited by toon on Thu Apr 11, 2024 6:49 pm, edited 1 time in total.
toon
Valiant B
Posts: 197
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 5:23 pm

Re: Brigham Young doesn’t deserve his online criticism

Post by toon »

Dr. Shades wrote:
Thu Apr 11, 2024 4:54 pm
Kishkumen wrote:
Wed Apr 10, 2024 9:56 pm
Criticism of historical figures is a practically irresistible pastime.
In your opinion, is it ever justified? If so, who?
Seems justified at least when and to the extent that those historical figures are still being held up as authoritative.
User avatar
Kishkumen
God
Posts: 7909
Joined: Tue Oct 27, 2020 2:37 pm
Location: Cassius University
Contact:

Re: Brigham Young doesn’t deserve his online criticism

Post by Kishkumen »

Dr. Shades wrote:
Thu Apr 11, 2024 4:54 pm
Kishkumen wrote:
Wed Apr 10, 2024 9:56 pm
Criticism of historical figures is a practically irresistible pastime.
In your opinion, is it ever justified? If so, who?
Ever justified? The act of critiquing historical figures is ALWAYS justified.
User avatar
Doctor CamNC4Me
God
Posts: 9682
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 2:04 am

Re: Brigham Young doesn’t deserve his online criticism

Post by Doctor CamNC4Me »

Kishkumen wrote:
Thu Apr 11, 2024 9:52 pm
Dr. Shades wrote:
Thu Apr 11, 2024 4:54 pm
In your opinion, is it ever justified? If so, who?
Ever justified? The act of critiquing historical figures is ALWAYS justified.
I remember the first time I learned about the *Battle of Fort Utah.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_at_Fort_Utah

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_Creek_massacre

- Doc

* that’s when BY ordered the massacre of the Timpanogos.
Donald Trump doesn’t know who is third in line for the Presidency.
Post Reply