I’d be interested in understanding what “fruits” can only be produced when connected to a belief in God.
Philosophers have argued for a long time about from where goodness comes. Is goodness something that is inherent to humans or does goodness exist independently?
It’s not unusual or exclusivist to believe that love and life come from a source beyond ourselves. And I don’t think it would be unusual to “tap into” that external source as part of an approach to life.
Atheists demonstrate goodness. I suspect they wouldn’t agree that such goodness stems from having a connection to God.
You are quite correct. I took the quote from the transcript. I should have double checked by watching that part of the video. I apologise.
Ah, OK. No worries. I can see how that happened. The transcript did not clearly indicate who the speaker was.
That’s generous. I could (and should) have figured it out with a bit more care. You were right to call me on it and I’m glad you did so that I can acknowledge the error and correct my comments.
Premise 1. Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable.
Premise 2. The best evidence for the Book of Mormon is eyewitness testimony.
Conclusion. Therefore, the best evidence for the Book of Mormon is notoriously unreliable.
That’s generous. I could (and should) have figured it out with a bit more care. You were right to call me on it and I’m glad you did so that I can acknowledge the error and correct my comments.
Well, I make similar mistakes all the time. So, there's that.
"He disturbs the laws of his country, he forces himself upon women, and he puts men to death without trial.” ~Otanes on the monarch, Herodotus Histories 3.80.
Philosophers have argued for a long time about from where goodness comes. Is goodness something that is inherent to humans or does goodness exist independently?
It’s not unusual or exclusivist to believe that love and life come from a source beyond ourselves. And I don’t think it would be unusual to “tap into” that external source as part of an approach to life.
Atheists demonstrate goodness. I suspect they wouldn’t agree that such goodness stems from having a connection to God.
I’m not saying that someone must believe in God to do good. I’m asking whether goodness itself comes from ourselves or if it has a source beyond ourselves, whether we recognize that source or not, or even call it God.
Atheists demonstrate goodness. I suspect they wouldn’t agree that such goodness stems from having a connection to God.
I’m not saying that someone must believe in God to do good. I’m asking whether goodness itself comes from ourselves or if it has a source beyond ourselves, whether we recognize that source or not, or even call it God.
I suppose that depends on what one determines is goodness. My take (based on nothing scientific whatsoever) would be that humans have evolved based on an inbuilt survival instinct. If it aids survival, it’s good. I’d guess that instinct has developed over a long period and would be nuanced by things like perceived security and availability of food and shelter and an ability to reproduce. Humanity has developed a herd mentality, that there’s safety in numbers etc. so my take would be that “goodness” is related to “survival”. It’s instinctive. We learn right and wrong. But right and wrong are based on what is good for survival and what isn’t.
Is it our nature, our genetic make up, our instinct, or a creators doing…I guess all you can do is pick your poison. But I’d say there’s more objective evidence supporting the survival instinct source of goodness than there is supporting the idea of a supernatural being who behaves in seemingly random ways towards us. If goodness comes from God instilling it in us then you’d have to explain his choice of creating child abusers or psychopaths etc.
“God” seems to be a place holder for “We don’t know so let’s invent something that makes us feel comfortable about not knowing”.
Premise 1. Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable.
Premise 2. The best evidence for the Book of Mormon is eyewitness testimony.
Conclusion. Therefore, the best evidence for the Book of Mormon is notoriously unreliable.