I'm afraid I'm getting the impression that if there is ever anything good about any instance of religion, then it was no true religion.
On the thread topic, there are no good creationist arguments, if by “creation” one means to rule out naturalistic abiogenesis and evolution.
The closest there is to a good argument is just to appreciate how complex life is, and say, Whoa!
Cells are full of complex molecular machinery. Could all that really just happen? If that doesn’t daunt your imagination, you probably haven’t grasped how complex it all is.
The biggest surprise, though, is that it does all just happen, every millisecond. The molecular machinery works. It isn’t just random. The laws of Nature are rules, and although they don’t fundamentally seem to foster life, in fact life is a wonderfully effective exploit of the rules. Given that it works now, its evolution is really not so surprising. Self-assembling is non-trivial but working at all is the hard part. Given that it does work, the question of how it could have evolved is a fascinating one, but by no means an unthinkable quandary.
Evolutionary Biologist Reacts to Creationist Arguments
- Physics Guy
- God
- Posts: 2353
- Joined: Tue Oct 27, 2020 7:40 am
- Location: on the battlefield of life
Re: Evolutionary Biologist Reacts to Creationist Arguments
Philosophical pirates think, therefore they Arrr!
- Some Schmo
- God
- Posts: 4073
- Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 3:21 am
Re: Evolutionary Biologist Reacts to Creationist Arguments
I'm with you that it's all fascinating, but I can't say that life feels any more wonderous than the formation of other complex structures in the universe, like stars, planets, moons, and massive clouds of dust. Even on earth, the formation of geological structures boggles the mind. Go to Yellowstone Park and try walking away without being amazed at what the non-living earth does every day. It feels to me like gravity does a ton of heavy lifting in terms of basic creation.Physics Guy wrote: ↑Sat Aug 22, 2026 11:36 pmI'm afraid I'm getting the impression that if there is ever anything good about any instance of religion, then it was no true religion.
On the thread topic, there are no good creationist arguments, if by “creation” one means to rule out naturalistic abiogenesis and evolution.
The closest there is to a good argument is just to appreciate how complex life is, and say, Whoa!
Cells are full of complex molecular machinery. Could all that really just happen? If that doesn’t daunt your imagination, you probably haven’t grasped how complex it all is.
The biggest surprise, though, is that it does all just happen, every millisecond. The molecular machinery works. It isn’t just random. The laws of Nature are rules, and although they don’t fundamentally seem to foster life, in fact life is a wonderfully effective exploit of the rules. Given that it works now, its evolution is really not so surprising. Self-assembling is non-trivial but working at all is the hard part. Given that it does work, the question of how it could have evolved is a fascinating one, but by no means an unthinkable quandary.
But as wonderous as, say, a geyser is, it has a physical explanation, and no magic or supernatural explanation is required. I actually think the introduction of magic as a component force diminishes how awesome and interesting natural processes (like evolution and geology) really are.
Religion is for people whose existential fear is greater than their common sense. It's also the favored cover for hypocrites.
The god idea is popular with desperate people.
The god idea is popular with desperate people.
- Dr. Shades
- Founder and Visionary
- Posts: 3287
- Joined: Mon Oct 26, 2020 2:48 pm
Re: Evolutionary Biologist Reacts to Creationist Arguments
I see what you did there.Some Schmo wrote: ↑Sun Aug 23, 2026 7:14 amIt feels to me like gravity does a ton of heavy lifting in terms of basic creation.
.
"When the Mormon God requires a PR crisis to act moral, we've clearly outgrown him."
--Everybody Wang Chung, 06-01-2026
"When the Mormon God requires a PR crisis to act moral, we've clearly outgrown him."
--Everybody Wang Chung, 06-01-2026
- Physics Guy
- God
- Posts: 2353
- Joined: Tue Oct 27, 2020 7:40 am
- Location: on the battlefield of life
Re: Evolutionary Biologist Reacts to Creationist Arguments
Astrophysics is currently much better understood than biophysics. A current textbook on biophysics still has the title, Biophysics: Searching for Principles. If astrophysics were the physics of intracellular machinery, it would be fair to say that we would have no astrophysics at all yet, but only astronomy: a decent amount of data about what is out there but no understanding of how it all works.
This isn't just some sociological coincidence of astrophysics getting more funding or something. Biological systems really are enormously more complicated than stars. The "ladder of science" that has physics at the bottom and biology at the top is really a ladder of complexity. The real definition of physics is our dirty secret: physics is the study of simple things. It doesn't matter whether the simple things are galaxy clusters or subatomic particles. The only requirement for something to be claimed by physicists is that it be simple enough that we can make controlled comparisons between quantitative data and comprehensible mathematical models. If it's too complicated for that, then it must be chemistry, or biology, or psychology, or something.
The flip side of that is Rutherford's infamous dictum that "all science is either physics or stamp collecting." He may just have been miffed at winning the Nobel prize in chemistry, for discovering the atomic nucleus, when he had always identified as a physicist, but he had a point. In comparison with the predictive and explanatory power of theory in physics, what other natural sciences do is much more like arranging empirical facts into patterns. This is by no means due to any failing on the part of chemists and biologists, however. It is simply that their subjects are too complex for human minds to have succeeded, so far, in connecting all the dots between important phenomena and basic natural laws.
These comments of mine are not those of a spectator. They're the somewhat anxious remarks of a rookie player. I'm getting into biophysics, writing a grant proposal for a joint project with a biologist colleague. I'm hoping to figure out some things about how phytochromes work. They're light-sensitive switches, in which a single modest-sized molecule makes a sudden change of shape when it absorbs a single photon, and then a surrounding protein somehow reacts to the molecule's shape change, dot dot dot. Each plant cell—each plant cell, not each plant!—may have thousands or even millions of phytochromes, and together they make the whole plant grow differently depending on light conditions. We're not totally clear about how and why these molecules change shape as quickly and efficiently as they do, just from absorbing a photon, even when they're isolated, and the interactions between the light-absorbing molecule and the surrounding protein are really unclear. So this will be our project, hopefully.
I've picked this project because it's the very simplest kind of molecular machine I could find—a mere switch. What I'd really like to understand is molecular pumps. They are the real secret of life. The reason that plants need to absorb light, and that animals need to eat and breathe, is to keep the molecular pumps running, because they maintain the proton concentration imbalances that drive the "proton mill" gadgets that recycle ADP into ATP to power everything else in a cell. If I can understand switches, I can try to move on to pumps, and if I can understand them, I'll try to tackle the simplest process that is powered by ATP-to-ADP hydrolysis. We know that all of that happens, but we don't yet know how it all happens, in the sense of "knowing how" that applies in physics.
This isn't just some sociological coincidence of astrophysics getting more funding or something. Biological systems really are enormously more complicated than stars. The "ladder of science" that has physics at the bottom and biology at the top is really a ladder of complexity. The real definition of physics is our dirty secret: physics is the study of simple things. It doesn't matter whether the simple things are galaxy clusters or subatomic particles. The only requirement for something to be claimed by physicists is that it be simple enough that we can make controlled comparisons between quantitative data and comprehensible mathematical models. If it's too complicated for that, then it must be chemistry, or biology, or psychology, or something.
The flip side of that is Rutherford's infamous dictum that "all science is either physics or stamp collecting." He may just have been miffed at winning the Nobel prize in chemistry, for discovering the atomic nucleus, when he had always identified as a physicist, but he had a point. In comparison with the predictive and explanatory power of theory in physics, what other natural sciences do is much more like arranging empirical facts into patterns. This is by no means due to any failing on the part of chemists and biologists, however. It is simply that their subjects are too complex for human minds to have succeeded, so far, in connecting all the dots between important phenomena and basic natural laws.
These comments of mine are not those of a spectator. They're the somewhat anxious remarks of a rookie player. I'm getting into biophysics, writing a grant proposal for a joint project with a biologist colleague. I'm hoping to figure out some things about how phytochromes work. They're light-sensitive switches, in which a single modest-sized molecule makes a sudden change of shape when it absorbs a single photon, and then a surrounding protein somehow reacts to the molecule's shape change, dot dot dot. Each plant cell—each plant cell, not each plant!—may have thousands or even millions of phytochromes, and together they make the whole plant grow differently depending on light conditions. We're not totally clear about how and why these molecules change shape as quickly and efficiently as they do, just from absorbing a photon, even when they're isolated, and the interactions between the light-absorbing molecule and the surrounding protein are really unclear. So this will be our project, hopefully.
I've picked this project because it's the very simplest kind of molecular machine I could find—a mere switch. What I'd really like to understand is molecular pumps. They are the real secret of life. The reason that plants need to absorb light, and that animals need to eat and breathe, is to keep the molecular pumps running, because they maintain the proton concentration imbalances that drive the "proton mill" gadgets that recycle ADP into ATP to power everything else in a cell. If I can understand switches, I can try to move on to pumps, and if I can understand them, I'll try to tackle the simplest process that is powered by ATP-to-ADP hydrolysis. We know that all of that happens, but we don't yet know how it all happens, in the sense of "knowing how" that applies in physics.
Philosophical pirates think, therefore they Arrr!