Markk wrote: ↑Wed Jun 11, 2025 11:58 am
The art thread is about art. I won't address anything but art there, whether critical or appreciation. It's that simple. This is a free forum and you can discuss anything you like, where ever you like, and I support that.
Sure. Here it is, ported over here:
Markk wrote: ↑Tue Jun 10, 2025 2:59 am
Morley wrote: ↑Tue Jun 10, 2025 2:11 am
So, it hurt when I told you that I wasn’t fond of Bramblitt? Or when I suggested I thought that he wasn’t good enough to get any recognition at all, if he weren’t blind?
Lol...No, it just showed how you think and were being condescending given the thread. You are gentle compared to other folks here Morley, and whether you believe it or not I respect you. If I got offended over things said about me here I would not have been posting here for what....20 years?
Lol, Schmo calls me cuss words I have never even heard before, and I have been in construction of about 50 years.
I wasn't being condescending. I was being honest about my preferences. Before that, I’d tried to stand back a bit because I didn’t want to interfere with the flow. But, as you've seen, sometimes I can’t keep my mouth shut or my fingers off the keyboard.
It's apparent that I misunderstood your reasons for starting the art thread. You may have seen it as a safe space to celebrate what each of us finds beautiful in art. I saw it as a place to write about and discuss our personal opinions on art. The two can be very different things.
Art's a funny thing. While no one can agree about what should be important in aesthetics and technique, everyone considers themselves to be something of a lay expert about aesthetics and technique. These manifest in a way they wouldn't about, say, bridge building or quadratic equations. This shouldn't be surprising, given that even those with formal expertise in art often can't agree on these things.
Art critics and practicing artists often silently cringe when someone outside of the field tells them what they should be doing or either celebrates or criticizes a certain style or subject. Statements like "I don't know art, but I know what I like" and "My five-year-old could do that" are two of the fan favorites that make most artists want to shake their heads and walk away.
Most people involved in art carry some pretty strong ideas about which artists and genres they consider to be significant and relevant. That's probably because, being informed by education, practice, and experience, the urge to opine can often be difficult to throttle. You probably have the same fervor about architecture and construction. If I began waxing enthusiastic about the utility and beauty of spit entries or aluminum wiring, you might express an opinion suggesting I was something of an idiot. But then again, maybe you wouldn't.
It's hilarious, because in this thread, I actually thought that I was being pretty generous and mild about some of the stuff I have strong negative feelings about. While I have nowhere the talent for being as reasonable and tactful as Huckelberry, I do make an effort.