It was common for people to claim to be the resurrected person of a deceased person. Nero one of the more famous. One was so convincing that he convinced armies to go to battle and was eventually executed.Limnor wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 7:13 pmI don’t disagree with any of this as being convenient. But I think the epistemic point, if there is any one thing that would cancel out, for me, would be whether Jesus was actually raised bodily from the dead. I think faith could survive symbolic interpretations, but the resurrection is different. If Jesus wasn’t actually raised from the dead, then there is no real victory over death. I realize that the historical evidence only demonstrates that Jesus’ followers “believed” he was raised, that there are alternative explanations, and I acknowledge those alternatives can’t be ruled out definitively. Plus I wouldn’t say that belief is proof, either, it’s just witness evidence.Rivendale wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 6:11 pmThe usual apologetics for failed prophecies or troublesome commentary has several forms. Its symbolic. It hasn't come to pass yet. That was spiritual meaning. The Hebrew version was very clear about the text and if it did indeed mean that it they would have said that. Words don't mean words. You have to take it in context. All of this makes as much sense as paying your tithing spiritually.
I also recognize the similarity between my approach and MG’s. We both seem willing to allow for uncertainty and deviate from traditional interpretations. The difference I think is that I can identify a breaking point: If the bodily resurrection didn’t happen, my faith would lose its foundation. I don’t think MG has a breaking point regarding Joseph and the Restoration, or whether there is anything that would change his conclusions.
My question is, if the Resurrection was granted how do we make the leap it was supernatural? There are many naturalistic explanations that are far more probable.