MDDB: Jumping the Shark?

[_Carton]

I've noticed lately that MDB almost always has more posters logged in, much more activity, than MDDB. It used to be the other way around, but now MDB seems to be much more popular and active than MDDB.

Looks like MDDB has "jumped the shark" in the world of online Mormon discussions. It doesn't surprise me at all. MDDB is a board for intellectual pygmies. I'm only surprised it took so long.

[_Stormy Waters]

Their new policy of only allowing ten page views before you have to sign up was a bonehead move. Locking down interesting threads, and silently deleting comments and banning posters really hinder any kind of serious discussion.

[_moksha]

MDDB is a board for intellectual pygmies.

I don't believe that they are intellectual pygmies at all. It is simply a case of posters becoming weary of typing ditto over and over again. Well, that's to be expected on a censorious and overly controlled board.

[_bcspace]

Both boards seem relatively dead in terms of interesting new threads.

[_zeezrom]

It's because we have [...delete names of interesting posters...]

Nope, I can't do that again. I will forget to mention someone's name who deserves to be listed.

Anyway, MDD is missing some key people. Maybe they should recruit?

[_zeezrom]

Out of curiosity, are the following people allowed to post on MDD? Might any of these be recruited assuming they were willing to even go to MDD?

Scratch
Kish
Stak
MsJack
Harmony
Liz (I recall she said she was banned so likely not)
Chris
Quas
Drifting
Buffalo
Beastie
Moksha
Shades
Jason Bourne
Bond
SP
Darth
Some Schmo
Blixa
Mercury
truth dancer
etc?

Have all those people been banned?

[_MCB]

Who, having left the D & D game, dusting off their shoes, would want to go back? Only a masochist.

I have not been banned, to my knowledge. And I don't even lurk there.

[_kamenraider]

Even though it would be easy to make sock puppets to get around my limited status, (limited to zero posts but not technically banned, lol) it's soooo boring now I don't even bother.

[_Stormy Waters]

Out of curiosity, are the following people allowed to post on MDD? Might any of these be recruited assuming they were willing to even go to MDD?

...

Have all those people been banned?

I know some of them have.

The only reason I can think of to post on MDDB is the hope to engage some of the 'top tier' apologists. I tried posting on MDDB, and it was just frustrating. Pahoran and others get to be dicks, and if you respond in kind your comment is removed and you're banned from the thread/board. I just don't think it's possible to have a even handed board when it's moderated and run by apologists.

[_MCB]

Perhaps their top-tier, being relatively level-headed, intelligent, knowledgeable, and rational, are being protected from apostasy by the rabble. They are just protecting their own. Some of our dearest friends here are incipient or closet apostates. And some of those best, only visit occasionally, like Ben McGuire.