Interpreter's Peer Review Process, Revisited

The catch-all forum for general topics and debates. Minimal moderation. Rated PG to PG-13.
User avatar
Kishkumen
God
Posts: 10503
Joined: Tue Oct 27, 2020 2:37 pm
Location: Cassius University
Contact:

Re: Interpreter's Peer Review Process, Revisited

Post by Kishkumen »

I trust that their peer review works fine within the parameters of belief in God and the Restoration, on the one hand, and loyalty and obedience to LDS leadership, on the other. The other requisite quality is fit with the general views of the apologists. No Heartlanders need apply.
"He disturbs the laws of his country, he forces himself upon women, and he puts men to death without trial.” ~Otanes on the monarch, Herodotus Histories 3.80.
I Have Questions
God
Posts: 4582
Joined: Tue May 23, 2023 9:09 am

Re: Interpreter's Peer Review Process, Revisited

Post by I Have Questions »

Tom wrote: ↑
Thu Nov 12, 2026 10:33 pm
I see that Dr. Peterson attempted to redact her name. For some reason, though, he left in one instance of her name. I’m flabbergasted.
I find it interesting that he didn’t think publishing her details and Wyatt’s version of events before we drew it’s problematic nature to his attention. Is the guy not capable of thinking for himself, or does he not understand what is and what isn’t acceptable to post? Does he not think about what he’s putting out? And how clumsy is the redaction?
The primary person I was talking to from Religious Educator was [NNNNNN]. She needed a bit of education as to who the main audience for Interpreter is, which I was happy to provide. I thought it odd that she didn’t already know, as she said that she had, at one time, worked at the Maxwell Institute.
He’s removed the name (although using a series of N’s to do so is bizarre - surely ‘name redacted’ would have been more professional) but left in the smug self aggrandisement by the grovelling Wyatt. The paragraph has nothing to do with Interpreter’s so-called peer review process, and everything to do with claiming superiority by belittling someone else behind their back. Did Peterson have Becky’s permission to publish the details of a private conversation she’d had? It’s very very childish, and totally unprofessional.
Premise 1. Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable.
Premise 2. The best evidence for the Book of Mormon is eyewitness testimony.
Conclusion. Therefore, the best evidence for the Book of Mormon is notoriously unreliable.
Marcus
God
Posts: 8297
Joined: Mon Oct 25, 2021 10:44 pm

Re: Interpreter's Peer Review Process, Revisited

Post by Marcus »

Kish wrote:I trust that their peer review works fine within the parameters of belief in God and the Restoration, on the one hand, and loyalty and obedience to LDS leadership, on the other...
I find this deeply problematic, and i am aware kishkumen will take offense at my voicing my disagreement, so i apologize in advance for causing him discomfort.

The issues I have with their peer review involve bad reasoning, clearly incorrect use of mathematical and statistical concepts, misleading, circular, and or borderline dishonest reasoning in the use of references to support points, among others.

Invoking "parameters of belief," "loyalty" and "obedience" to excuse this level of bad thinking in what is openly touted as an academically rigorous journal is incomprehensible to me. In my opinion, within those parameters is exactly when one should maintain the most integrity and honesty possible about the facts and concepts being considered and the manner in which the arguments being made. 'Lying for the lord' has no place here. I don't think it has a place anywhere, hence my non-lds position, but even from within holding a position like the above about a Journal purporting to publish scholarship would be excruciatingly intolerable. Playground peer review, indeed.
...The other requisite quality is fit with the general views of the apologists. No Heartlanders need apply.
Sarcasm, I hope? If so, I am hoping the first part was sarcasm also. (Hopefully my admittance of this unlikely interpretation gives Kish an artful way to disparage my post as naïve and prevents another Holy War from beginning. Fingers crossed.)
Philo Sofee wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 13, 2026 12:24 am
Physics Guy wrote: ↑
Thu Nov 12, 2026 10:45 pm
The comparison with the peer review of a flat Earth journal is exactly on target. Peer review does just mean review by other people in the field; it doesn’t say anything about whether the peers are competent in any objective sense. Marcus made the point well by introducing the term “playground peer review”: peer review is only as good as the peers. In a discipline with objectively established standards, it’s the most rigorous available test. In a crackpot discipline, it’s a worthless criterion.
I am in the process of reviewing their entire BYU Studies edition on the book of Abraham. I can tell by the footnotes alone it is peer reviewed by believers. They are doing inbred scholarship references to ONLY THEMSELVES to make points for authenticity. They have literally no interest at all in understanding...
That footnote problem in particular has always bothered me, thank you for expressing the issue so clearly. They end up with results completely outside the realm of known and accepted understanding.
...There actually OUGHT to be a non-LDS, non-interested Egyptologist peer reviewing their materials...
Yes. If they would at least acknowledge that they are taking an alternate view that the rest of the academic world finds completely insupportable it be far more honest, but they can't even do that. Their playground of peer review is hermetically sealed.
Last edited by Marcus on Fri Nov 13, 2026 5:43 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Rivendale
God
Posts: 2030
Joined: Tue Mar 16, 2021 5:21 pm

Re: Interpreter's Peer Review Process, Revisited

Post by Rivendale »

Kara Cooney was asked why Kerry Muhlestein struggles to be taken seriously and she said we don't allow revelation to be incorporated into our work.
I Have Questions
God
Posts: 4582
Joined: Tue May 23, 2023 9:09 am

Re: Interpreter's Peer Review Process, Revisited

Post by I Have Questions »

Rivendale wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 13, 2026 5:37 pm
Kara Cooney was asked why Kerry Muhlestein struggles to be taken seriously and she said we don't allow revelation to be incorporated into our work.
:lol:
Premise 1. Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable.
Premise 2. The best evidence for the Book of Mormon is eyewitness testimony.
Conclusion. Therefore, the best evidence for the Book of Mormon is notoriously unreliable.
Philo Sofee
God
Posts: 6145
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 1:18 am

Re: Interpreter's Peer Review Process, Revisited

Post by Philo Sofee »

Rivendale wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 13, 2026 5:37 pm
Kara Cooney was asked why Kerry Muhlestein struggles to be taken seriously and she said we don't allow revelation to be incorporated into our work.
Yes. It's not about Joseph SMith, it's about WHAT the EGYPTIAN HIEROGLYPHS say...... LDS scholarship ignores the Kirtland Egyptian Papers wishing to fob them off onto W W Phelps instead of grasping that it was Joseph Smith's project. That is utterly clearly stated in the Official History of the Church.
Post Reply