Interpreter's Peer Review Process, Revisited

The catch-all forum for general topics and debates. Minimal moderation. Rated PG to PG-13.
User avatar
Doctor Scratch
B.H. Roberts Chair of Mopologetic Studies
Posts: 1788
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 7:24 pm
Location: Cassius University

Interpreter's Peer Review Process, Revisited

Post by Doctor Scratch »

Quite an intriguing post over at "SeN" today, delving once again to the ever-fascinating topic of the Mopologists' "peer review" process and the legitimacy thereof. The Afore writes:
Certain critics of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and of me and all my works (and therefore, accordingly, critics of the Interpreter Foundation, which is far and away not merely a work of mine), like to mock and deride the Interpreter Foundation’s peer and, when feeling especially exuberant, to deny that such a process exists at all.

It does exist, of course. And it’s quite solid; we reject a not insubstantial proportion of the manuscripts that are submitted to us. From the beginning, we who launched the Interpreter Foundation — mostly affiliated with higher education — modeled its review and publication procedures on those with which we were familiar from our own work in academia.
"[M]odeled" does not necessarily grant it legitimacy, of course. The issue critics have always had is not that the Mopologists don't "jump through the hoops": for my part, I 100% believe that the articles are reviewed by Wyatt and the other editors, and that the articles (er, ahem, "blog posts"?) are then sent out to other readers, who evaluate them and provide feedback. I don't doubt that that's the case. The problem is that the articles are obviously being reviewed by a cadre of "Yes Men" who are really just reviewing them to see whether or not they toe the line vis-a-vis Mopologetic orthodoxy. And I mean seriously: who is going to "peer review" something like Greg Smith's hit piece on Rodney Meldrum? Or Wyatt's own tirade against the Tanners? Does that sort of thing really need to be carefully scrutinized for its academic "impact"? If the Afore is truly being serious about attempting to emulate what happens in mainstream academia, then how come Interpreter's publications seem so very, very different from mainstream academia's output? I once asked the Afore where I should look--amongst legit, peer-reviewed publications--for the sort of hit pieces that FARMS used to routinely published, and he did an about-face and said, "Oh, well, actually, we don't want it to be like an *actual* peer reviewed publication; instead, we're aiming for something more polemical, a la The National Review."

Rather hilariously, in the "SeN" entry, there is an extended message from Bro. Wyatt in which he inadvertently throws some fellow LDS publications under the bus, but this was the tidbit that caught my attention:
The primary person I was talking to from Religious Educator was Becky Isom Call. She needed a bit of education as to who the main audience for Interpreter is, which I was happy to provide. I thought it odd that she didn’t already know, as she said that she had, at one time, worked at the Maxwell Institute.
LOL!!! What, you mean she's unfamiliar with the small audience of angry fans of Mopologetics who are tuning in for the "smackdowns"? *Of course* she doesn't understand how there would be any audience for the crap they produce. And how funny that the Mopologists' role at the Maxwell Institute seems to be ever-fading off into the dustbin of memory. Anyways, Wyatt tosses them under the bus by relating the fact that they are apparently giving up on the practice of checking up on every source. Not Interpreter, though!
Wyatt wrote:Just so you know, I have no plans for us to abandon source checking. Perhaps it is not the case with these other journals, but we have critics who would pounce if they thought that we didn’t check sources. Why give those critics the poison to pour into the well from which we hope others will drink?
Well, I think we have to acknowledge a bit of disingenuousness here. When the vast majority of sources are just other Mopologetic publications that the editors and reviewers have already read (or have themselves written), then "checking them" becomes a fairly easy and rote exercise. So the situations really aren't that comparable.

In any case, we get the usual sign-off at "SeN," asking for money while downplaying the arguably dubious ways that the donations are spent:
We are, overwhelmingly, a volunteer organization. (Our leadership, for example, draws no pay.) But we do have unavoidable expenses and, as with prices everywhere else, those expenses are increasing.
Oh, I'm sure! If "Becoming Brigham" is going to keep filming overseas, then, yeah: a lot of funds are going to be needed to cover all those expenses. Lunches of mushroom Swiss burgers and onion rings aren't fee, after all.
"If, while hoping that everybody else will be honest and so forth, I can personally prosper through unethical and immoral acts without being detected and without risk, why should I not?." --Daniel Peterson, 6/4/14
drumdude
God
Posts: 8173
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 5:29 am

Re: Interpreter's Peer Review Process, Revisited

Post by drumdude »

You could easily imagine a flat earth journal similar to Interpreter which is also peer reviewed. Peer review by other flat earth scholars wouldn’t lend the flat earth movement any credibility beyond the flat earth community.

Similarly with Interpreter, peer review doesn’t mean much. If Gee’s articles were submitted to non-Mormon Egyptologists for actual peer review, then they might actually have a claim to be producing real scholarship.

Of course every non-Mormon scholar is completely unimpressed by the Potemkin scholarship that goes on, even with peer review, over at Interpreter…

Dan frequently confuses quantity with quality, and in this case confuses peer review with scholarly rigor and honesty. Nothing that we haven’t seen before .
Last edited by drumdude on Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:23 pm, edited 1 time in total.
I Have Questions
God
Posts: 4581
Joined: Tue May 23, 2023 9:09 am

Re: Interpreter's Peer Review Process, Revisited

Post by I Have Questions »

Wyatt wrote:I had no indication from Derek that Maxwell will be putting any of the older FARMS materials back online that they previously pulled.
Lol!

I wonder if they do plagiarism checks…
Doctor Scratch wrote: ↑
Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:13 pm
Rather hilariously, in the "SeN" entry, there is an extended message from Bro. Wyatt in which he inadvertently throws some fellow LDS publications under the bus, but this was the tidbit that caught my attention:
The primary person I was talking to from Religious Educator was Becky Isom Call. She needed a bit of education as to who the main audience for Interpreter is, which I was happy to provide. I thought it odd that she didn’t already know, as she said that she had, at one time, worked at the Maxwell Institute.
LOL!!! What, you mean she's unfamiliar with the small audience of angry fans of Mopologetics who are tuning in for the "smackdowns"? *Of course* she doesn't understand how there would be any audience for the crap they produce. And how funny that the Mopologists' role at the Maxwell Institute seems to be ever-fading off into the dustbin of memory. Anyways, Wyatt tosses them under the bus by relating the fact that they are apparently giving up on the practice of checking up on every source. Not Interpreter, though!
It would be interesting to hear Becky’s version of that interaction, and how she feels about being used as a bad example in Wyatt’s snivelling effort to curry favour with the Interpreter grown ups.
Premise 1. Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable.
Premise 2. The best evidence for the Book of Mormon is eyewitness testimony.
Conclusion. Therefore, the best evidence for the Book of Mormon is notoriously unreliable.
User avatar
Tom
God
Posts: 1190
Joined: Mon Oct 26, 2020 3:41 pm
Location: Sego, Utah
Contact:

Re: Interpreter's Peer Review Process, Revisited

Post by Tom »

Doctor Scratch wrote: ↑
Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:13 pm
Quite an intriguing post over at "SeN" today, delving once again to the ever-fascinating topic of the Mopologists' "peer review" process and the legitimacy thereof. The Afore writes:
Certain critics of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and of me and all my works (and therefore, accordingly, critics of the Interpreter Foundation, which is far and away not merely a work of mine), like to mock and deride the Interpreter Foundation’s peer [sic] and, when feeling especially exuberant, to deny that such a process exists at all.
I believe Dr. Peterson omitted a few words above.
Doctor Scratch wrote:Rather hilariously, in the "SeN" entry, there is an extended message from Bro. Wyatt in which he inadvertently throws some fellow LDS publications under the bus, but this was the tidbit that caught my attention:
I am surprised that Dr. Peterson reposted this part of Wyatt’s email. There’s no need to share his disparaging assessment of Call with the world. I hope that Dr. Peterson will redact the email.

What qualifies Interpreter for inclusion in BYU’s ScholarsArchive? The website states that “ScholarsArchive is Brigham Young University’s institutional repository for the scholarly and creative content produced by the University. ScholarsArchive makes research, publications, data, and journals produced by BYU faculty and students available to a global research audience.”
Wyatt wrote: Just so you know, I have no plans for us to abandon source checking. Perhaps it is not the case with these other journals, but we have critics who would pounce if they thought that we didn’t check sources. Why give those critics the poison to pour into the well from which we hope others will drink?
Does Interpreter check sources? Years ago I checked sources in some of its published articles. I found problems. Perhaps Interpreter staff do a better job now.
“We live by faith, not by sight” (2 For. 5:7 NIV).
User avatar
Gadianton
God
Posts: 6916
Joined: Sun Oct 25, 2020 11:56 pm
Location: Elsewhere

Re: Interpreter's Peer Review Process, Revisited

Post by Gadianton »

Wait a second, so now they're "outing" and holding up for criticism and ridicule, admin assistants and general school staff members who don't give them the answers they want to hear? Fellow Latter-Day Saints?
"...gain control of land that FARMS owned..." -- Bill Hamblin
"Why did FARMS own land to begin with?" -- Me
Philo Sofee
God
Posts: 6145
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 1:18 am

Re: Interpreter's Peer Review Process, Revisited

Post by Philo Sofee »

Gadianton wrote: ↑
Thu Nov 12, 2026 4:29 am
Wait a second, so now they're "outing" and holding up for criticism and ridicule, admin assistants and general school staff members who don't give them the answers they want to hear? Fellow Latter-Day Saints?
Well... I mean... you know, after the midterms, everyone is up for grabs......
I Have Questions
God
Posts: 4581
Joined: Tue May 23, 2023 9:09 am

Re: Interpreter's Peer Review Process, Revisited

Post by I Have Questions »

Philo Sofee wrote: ↑
Thu Nov 12, 2026 4:59 am
Gadianton wrote: ↑
Thu Nov 12, 2026 4:29 am
Wait a second, so now they're "outing" and holding up for criticism and ridicule, admin assistants and general school staff members who don't give them the answers they want to hear? Fellow Latter-Day Saints?
Well... I mean... you know, after the midterms, everyone is up for grabs......
Wyatt gave Peterson permission to share his private belittling of Becky Isom Call. I think the lesson is perhaps to avoid conversations with Wyatt. I would very much like to hear her side of the story.
Premise 1. Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable.
Premise 2. The best evidence for the Book of Mormon is eyewitness testimony.
Conclusion. Therefore, the best evidence for the Book of Mormon is notoriously unreliable.
User avatar
Tom
God
Posts: 1190
Joined: Mon Oct 26, 2020 3:41 pm
Location: Sego, Utah
Contact:

Re: Interpreter's Peer Review Process, Revisited

Post by Tom »

I see that Dr. Peterson attempted to redact her name. For some reason, though, he left in one instance of her name. I’m flabbergasted.
“We live by faith, not by sight” (2 For. 5:7 NIV).
User avatar
Physics Guy
God
Posts: 2353
Joined: Tue Oct 27, 2020 7:40 am
Location: on the battlefield of life

Re: Interpreter's Peer Review Process, Revisited

Post by Physics Guy »

The comparison with the peer review of a flat Earth journal is exactly on target. Peer review does just mean review by other people in the field; it doesn’t say anything about whether the peers are competent in any objective sense. Marcus made the point well by introducing the term “playground peer review”: peer review is only as good as the peers. In a discipline with objectively established standards, it’s the most rigorous available test. In a crackpot discipline, it’s a worthless criterion.
Philosophical pirates think, therefore they Arrr!
Philo Sofee
God
Posts: 6145
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 1:18 am

Re: Interpreter's Peer Review Process, Revisited

Post by Philo Sofee »

Physics Guy wrote: ↑
Thu Nov 12, 2026 10:45 pm
The comparison with the peer review of a flat Earth journal is exactly on target. Peer review does just mean review by other people in the field; it doesn’t say anything about whether the peers are competent in any objective sense. Marcus made the point well by introducing the term “playground peer review”: peer review is only as good as the peers. In a discipline with objectively established standards, it’s the most rigorous available test. In a crackpot discipline, it’s a worthless criterion.
I am in the process of reviewing their entire BYU Studies edition on the book of Abraham. I can tell by the footnotes alone it is peer reviewed by believers. They are doing inbred scholarship references to ONLY THEMSELVES to make points for authenticity. They have literally no interest at all in understanding. Theirs is purely a motivated reasoning going on with that book. They began with the conclusion and only amass things that make that conclusion true. It is not scholarship. So Marcus's concept of playground peer review made me chuckle. That is what it is. There actually OUGHT to be a non-LDS, non-interested Egyptologist peer reviewing their materials. Their analysis of the papyri and the Alphabet and Grammar is almost laughably wrong and wrong headed. But that is because the ghost of Nibley past haunts their brains and they cannot shake his warped interpretations because he was so smart. But being smart has nothing to be with being accurate. The evidence is entirely against them on every level. John Gee's hopelessly muddled thinking that W. W. Phelps is the one who translated the papyri and Joseph Smith consulted him is truly the single most ridiculous thing I have ever seen him write. I thought his misidentifying the woman on the Greek Magical Papyri lion couch was bad, but this is worse. The poor guy. His testimony imprisons him to lie and warp the evidence. But Bayes reasoning is saving me from being sucked into his mental gymnastics. I am seriously grateful for that.
Post Reply