Pokatator wrote:
In your argument against horny toadism I can see a point in that direction, Joe married married women and then turned them back to their husbands. The reasons for that could be many. Maybe they weren't a good lay. Maybe they weren't as pretty. Maybe he was afraid of the husbands but brave enough to lay with them at least once and taste the goods. I don't know the real reasons.
But I do know that no matter which way you look at this practice of polygamy and Joe's use of if it has every look of sinfulness and if that is horny toadism then it is horny toadism. I can take that stance. The stance I can't take is that all of this behavior is from God. There is no way that God sanctioned all this behavior. God, man, common sense, Mormon or Catholic knows what marriage is and what adultery is. This all makes more sense to claim this came from Satan masquerading as an "Angel of Light" than to say it comes from God.
Horny toadism was a term for the critics who were claiming that Joseph Smith was lustful and a sexaholic. It implies a horny toadism. I just don't see it that way. He married many women during a two year period before his death. Why? Because he got horny?? I don't think so. He obviously thought that this was something that was required by him to do. I see no evidence that he was excited by polygamy. I see just the opposite. I see no silava coming from his mouth as he went about marrying women as his plural wives. But I do see a man in a hurry. Why? What was driving him to do what he did? Did he have a suicide wish? Did he get the antsy pantsies?? He knew the problems that it would cause Emma. And we have section 132 in the D&C which is a look into God's mind or if a critic, Joseph Smith's mind.
But something was driving him forward.