Question for Dr. Peterson about his Islamic studies and work

The catch-all forum for general topics and debates. Minimal moderation. Rated PG to PG-13.
_Daniel Peterson
_Emeritus
Posts: 7173
Joined: Thu Jul 05, 2007 6:56 pm

Re: Question for Dr. Peterson about his Islamic studies and

Post by _Daniel Peterson »

The preferred spelling among modern English-speaking Islamicists is Qur’an -- ideally with a macron over the a -- reflecting the term's origin in the verb qara’a ("to read," "to recite"). The preferred spelling of the Prophet's name is Muhammad, ideally with a dot under the h.

Dr. Shades wrote:How closely wedded to the Qur'An / Koran (however it's spelled) is Sharia law? Can one believe in the former and reject the latter, sort of like how Christ accepted the Old Testament but rejected "the traditions of the Elders?"

Shari‘a law was developed in its essence over the two or three centuries following the death of Muhammad. It relies to some extent on the Qur’an, but to a far greater degree on the so-called hadith -- traditions about the sayings and actions of Muhammad and the earliest Muslim community.

In my opinion (and not mine alone) the quasi-canonical hadith collections are heavily larded with spurious traditions, created for partisan ideological purposes by competing Muslim factions and reflective not so much of Muhammad and his time as they are of the imperial period that followed.

Boaz & Lidia wrote:Do you believe Allah is a God like you believe Elohim is a God?

Allah is simply the Arabic equivalent of the English word God. It's the word used in Arabic translations of the Bible, and, for that matter, in the Arabic translation of the Book of Mormon, the Articles of Faith, and so forth. It's used by Arabic-speaking Christians and Jews, as well as by Muslims.

And, in fact, it's cognate with the Hebrew word Elohim -- which is especially obvious when you remove the sound masculine plural ending from Elohim, thus yielding Eloh, and when you realize that Allah is simply a contraction of the words al-ilah, which mean "the god." (Arabic script has no equivalent of capitalization.)

Boaz & Lidia wrote:Do you believe Islam is TRUE?

It's partially true.
_solomarineris
_Emeritus
Posts: 1207
Joined: Mon Jun 25, 2007 1:51 am

Re: Question for Dr. Peterson about his Islamic studies and

Post by _solomarineris »

Daniel Peterson wrote:
Boaz & Lidia wrote:Do you believe Islam is TRUE?

It's partially true.


Well,
You give Islam, more credit than it deserves.
Since you absolutely & positively know Mormonism only true creed for sure.
But, we all have our ulterior motives.
Kissing Islam & Arab ass gives you some pseudo-credibility....
What was again your book's title again?
"Mohammed Prophet of God"?
I thought there was onlyone "Prophet of the God"
Wasn't that Joseph Smith?
Who married 10+ married women?
Dude.... Your favored Prophets have some interesting similarities...
_Boaz & Lidia
_Emeritus
Posts: 1416
Joined: Mon Jan 21, 2008 8:31 am

Re: Question for Dr. Peterson about his Islamic studies and

Post by _Boaz & Lidia »

solomarineris wrote:
Daniel Peterson wrote:
Boaz & Lidia wrote:Do you believe Islam is TRUE?

It's partially true.


Well,
You give Islam, more credit than it deserves.
Since you absolutely & positively know Mormonism only true creed for sure.
But, we all have our ulterior motives.
Kissing Islam & Arab ass gives you some pseudo-credibility....
What was again your book's title again?
"Mohammed Prophet of God"?
I thought there was onlyone "Prophet of the God"
Wasn't that Joseph Smith?
Who married 10+ married women?
Dude.... Your favored Prophets have some interesting similarities...
Dr. Peterson can you confirm this?

The parts of Islam theology that you consider "true", have parallels in Mormonism theology?
_Ray A

Post by _Ray A »

I think Mormonism is partially true.
_Boaz & Lidia
_Emeritus
Posts: 1416
Joined: Mon Jan 21, 2008 8:31 am

Post by _Boaz & Lidia »

Ray A wrote:I think Mormonism is partially true.
But, it leaves you unconvinced that you should reconsider your desire to sin?


;)
_Ray A

Post by _Ray A »

Boaz & Lidia wrote:
Ray A wrote:I think Mormonism is partially true.
But, it leaves you unconvinced that you should reconsider your desire to sin?


;)


Totally. If it was fully true, I would be putting aside money for tithing, and enduring Johnny Lingo films.
_Daniel Peterson
_Emeritus
Posts: 7173
Joined: Thu Jul 05, 2007 6:56 pm

Post by _Daniel Peterson »

Ray A wrote:Totally. If it was fully true, I would be putting aside money for tithing, and enduring Johnny Lingo films.

I believe it to be fully true, but I can't and won't endure Johnny Lingo.

I can see why a person would consider leaving the Church if he really thought that liking Johnny Lingo was required of active members.

How you must have suffered!
_Ray A

Post by _Ray A »

Daniel Peterson wrote:I believe it to be fully true, but I can't and won't endure Johnny Lingo.

I can see why a person would consider leaving the Church if he really thought that liking Johnny Lingo was required of active members.

How you must have suffered!


It was indeed awful. In fact, I think this may have been the final straw for me. Nothing in the FARMS Review persuaded me it was worth leaving the Church. But Johnny Lingo......? What greater evidence did I need?
_Boaz & Lidia
_Emeritus
Posts: 1416
Joined: Mon Jan 21, 2008 8:31 am

Post by _Boaz & Lidia »

Daniel Peterson wrote:
Ray A wrote:Totally. If it was fully true, I would be putting aside money for tithing, and enduring Johnny Lingo films.

I believe it to be fully true, but I can't and won't endure Johnny Lingo.

I can see why a person would consider leaving the Church if he really thought that liking Johnny Lingo was required of active members.

How you must have suffered!
Funny.

Now then, will you respond to my request?
The parts of Islam theology that you consider "true", have parallels in Mormonism theology?
If yes, would you mind listing them?
_Daniel Peterson
_Emeritus
Posts: 7173
Joined: Thu Jul 05, 2007 6:56 pm

Post by _Daniel Peterson »

Boaz & Lidia wrote:If yes, would you mind listing them?

For you? Yeah, I would.

There are lots of them.
Post Reply