Banned from MADB

The catch-all forum for general topics and debates. Minimal moderation. Rated PG to PG-13.
Post Reply
_antishock8
_Emeritus
Posts: 2425
Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2008 2:02 am

Re: Banned from MADB

Post by _antishock8 »

John Larsen wrote:
cinepro wrote:So who are the notable critics who still post at MA&D? It's been a while since I've been there. Tarski, John Larsen...?


Joseph Smith Mill, TAK, Mighty Curelom, ...

There are also the EV poster like Hoops22 and Mudcat who have been around a while.


How is it that TAK hasn't been banned?? He's a blunt guy, AND given his interactions with the Fat Man on this forum... I'm sure he'd be gone.
You can’t trust adults to tell you the truth.

Scream the lie, whisper the retraction.- The Left
_John Larsen
_Emeritus
Posts: 1895
Joined: Fri Jan 12, 2007 7:16 pm

Re: Banned from MADB

Post by _John Larsen »

antishock8 wrote:
John Larsen wrote:
As I said in my long post above. I agreed with Peterson. I think his assessment was right on. I think he could post the cure for cancer here and he would still be lit up.


I respectfully disagree. It's when he says he's going to post the cure for cancer, but instead he explains he's too busy to do it, isn't interested in sharing it, is working on it and will post his cure on another more worthy forum, insults everyone that takes umbrage with his lack of forthrightness, makes critical threads about Mormonism about himself (every single time), obfuscates, ad homs, red herrings... On and on...

I'm sorry some of you feel the sting of his loss, but I don't reeeeeally see what he added outside of an entertainment value. Is that what you miss?


I really don't care if he posts here or not. He was just phoning it in--on both boards. I don't like the endless personal attacks against him, they were juvenile and just feed his distorted world view.
_Mike Reed
_Emeritus
Posts: 983
Joined: Fri Mar 23, 2007 7:28 pm

Re: Banned from MADB

Post by _Mike Reed »

cinepro wrote:So who are the notable critics who still post at MA&D? It's been a while since I've been there. Tarski, John Larsen...?

Probably not notable, but I still have my posting privileges. I haven’t been using them very much lately, however.
_marg

Re: Banned from MADB

Post by _marg »

John Larsen wrote:

I really don't care if he posts here or not. He was just phoning it in--on both boards. I don't like the endless personal attacks against him, they were juvenile and just feed his distorted world view.


I tried to ignore the guy as much as possible but he'd jump into threads I was in, and totally unprovoked by me would write nasty remarks. He did that here, he did that in my brief time on the old MAD board. He literally followed me around the board, just to write sarcastic comments. He clearly is not all that nice an individual. And of course there's that evidence that he takes it upon himself to interfere in people's private lives totally uncalled for, all because he thinks he's doing it for the good of the church.

So while may have received personal attacks on this board, I generally didn't follow his posts or those who posted to him, in my opinion he likely deserved it.
_John Larsen
_Emeritus
Posts: 1895
Joined: Fri Jan 12, 2007 7:16 pm

Re: Banned from MADB

Post by _John Larsen »

Runtu wrote:
Yeah, forgot about them. Joseph Smith Mill has always been one of my favorites.

I Forgot about Scottie, too.
_Jason Bourne
_Emeritus
Posts: 9207
Joined: Sun Oct 29, 2006 8:00 pm

Re: Banned from MADB

Post by _Jason Bourne »


That was my sense of things when I read Dude had been banned. I suspect DCP has something to do with it. It's a way for him to lash back at those who also post here.


Really? Any evidence or just unfounded supposition?
_marg

Re: Banned from MADB

Post by _marg »

Jason Bourne wrote:

That was my sense of things when I read Dude had been banned. I suspect DCP has something to do with it. It's a way for him to lash back at those who also post here.


Really? Any evidence or just unfounded supposition?



I don't think he named Dude, but I think he made it clear in personal communications with mods there that he disliked this board, the way he was treated, and as he mentioned in a post, catering to certain critics does nothing to help their cause.

If he can contact a parent in order to tattletale on a poster here, I wouldn't put it past him to attempt to manipulate mods to increase their harrassment of certain critics. My impression of DCP which is based on my dealings with him as well as observations of things he's said and done, is that he is a rather petty minded, even spiteful individual at times.
_JohnStuartMill
_Emeritus
Posts: 1630
Joined: Sun Dec 07, 2008 12:12 pm

Re: Banned from MADB

Post by _JohnStuartMill »

Runtu wrote:
John Larsen wrote:Joseph Smith Mill, TAK, Mighty Curelom, ...

There are also the EV poster like Hoops22 and Mudcat who have been around a while.


Yeah, forgot about them. Joseph Smith Mill has always been one of my favorites.

While I'm honored that quality posters such as you two put me on that list, I was banned from there as well. I can't really complain about my banning, though: I gave my roommate free reign to post something offensive, and he juxtaposed a picture of Hitler with one of Joseph Smith.

I let my roommate get me banned because I've been pretty busy at work, and didn't want to waste time on a board where the playing field is so far from level. Now that The Dude is gone as well, I hope this portends a flight of the more knowledgeable critics from that board. I say, let them sequester themselves into an incestuous echo chamber. They're losing the cultural battle, and by circling the wagons and marginalizing themselves from the broader culture, they're only accelerating that loss.
"You clearly haven't read [Dawkins'] book." -Kevin Graham, 11/04/09
_Jason Bourne
_Emeritus
Posts: 9207
Joined: Sun Oct 29, 2006 8:00 pm

Re: Banned from MADB

Post by _Jason Bourne »


If he can contact a parent in order to tattletale on a poster here, I wouldn't put it past him to attempt to manipulate mods to increase their harrassment of certain critics. My impression of DCP which is based on my dealings with him as well as observations of things he's said and done, is that he is a rather petty minded, even spiteful individual at times.


Interesting. My interactions with him lead me to the exact opposite conclusion about the man. And my interactions go beyond this board to personal discussion via email and real life encounters.
_marg

Re: Banned from MADB

Post by _marg »

Jason Bourne wrote:
Interesting. My interactions with him lead me to the exact opposite conclusion about the man. And my interactions go beyond this board to personal discussion via email and real life encounters.


Well since you both are like minded in the sense you belong to the same religious group that's hardly unexpected.
Post Reply