A Very Limited Geography

[_Morley]

The National Geographic has a pretty good (very basic) primer on the science behind this stuff:

https://genographic.nationalgeographic. ... atlas.html

[Guest]

You seem to assume that if Asian similarities then Asian origin. That’s not clear cut at all for starters.

Ugo Perego is an LDS scientist and he has openly admitted that the A, B, C D and X lineages found in American Indians have been in the Americas for over 15,000 years and are not derived from Israel. How about you read your own LDS apologetics. http://www.fairlds.org/Book_of_Mormon/B ... d_DNA.html

The assumptions you describe above are not mine. They may be the assumptions of Thomas Murphy but why pin them on me? I have never demanded that we must find the CMH in the Americas. Any Semitic DNA would do.

But it was a good example of making an assumption about what we should expect to see among modern Native Americans if the Book of Mormon story is true. Either way, you simply can’t assume you would know what to expect, just like Murphy.

You accuse me of making assumptions someone else makes and then don't have the decency to apologize for your error.

Shoot, we’re going to be going back and forth about stuff like this forever.

Um no mate. This is where it ends with you.

[_Simon Belmont]

Um no mate. This is where it ends.

Wait... you begin a thread, then chicken out when some valid points are brought up in opposition to yours?

[_Baker]

Um no mate. This is where it ends.

Wait... you begin a thread, then chicken out when some valid points are brought up in opposition to yours?

Where?

[_Simon Belmont]

Where?

Where what? Why is Dr. Southerton retreating in light of stemelbow's arguments?


Edited to add proper title.

[_Kishkumen]

Wait... you begin a thread, then chicken out when some valid points are brought up in opposition to yours?

Where?

Yeah. Indeed. More Mopologetic games and Simon B wants to make it seem like the rational participant turned tail and fled. Rather, Simon S got tired of talking to bad Mopologetic A.I. software.

[_Simon Belmont]

Yeah. Indeed. More Mopologetic games and Simon B wants to make it seem like the rational participant turned tail and fled. Rather, Simon S got tired of talking to bad Mopologetic A.I. software.

Stemelbow is A.I. software, too?

Wow! Is everyone you don't agree with A.I. software?

Do you live in a world of robots, where you are the only human?

[_Joseph]

Even Red Green's wierd nephew Harold and two rolls of Duct Tape can't rescue the book or Mormon.

[_Baker]

Where?

Where what? Why is Southerton retreating in light of stemelbow's arguments?

I can only assume because Stem hasn't properly considered the very sources he is pointing to and the degree to which they do not, in fact, contradict anything that Simon has asserted.

[_Kishkumen]

Stemelbow is A.I. software, too?

Wow! Is everyone you don't agree with A.I. software?

Do you live in a world of robots, where you are the only human?

I just assume, for the sake of sparing the feelings of people that I otherwise like, that you guys just flip a switch and have your cheapo Mopologetic software post for you at certain points. I would hate to think that you guys actually believe the garbage you are spouting at those times. So really, it is all about how much I otherwise like you fellows.