Shulem wrote:Because he knows the Explanations of Facsimile No. 3 which were tendered by the so-called revelations/translations of Joseph Smith are nothing but lies. Modern Egyptology through art and science has proven that. Thews is perfectly safe in knowing Joseph Smith has been proven a false prophet.
I'm not
entirely familiar with what Joseph Smith claimed about Facsimile Number 3. The argument seems to be that Smith said it represented some things and modern Egyptologists now say it represents entirely different things. Does that mean Smith was wrong, or is it possible the facsimile might have more than one meaning? It wouldn't be the first time theologians postulated a statement in scripture had more than one meaning.
And even if we
could know conclusively that Facsimile Number 3 had one and only one meaning, would the fact that Smith therefore made a mistake make him a false prophet? Does one become a false prophet the first time one makes a single mistake?
I guess I don't look at prophets that way. I consider someone a prophet if
God wants me to consider him a prophet. I see no reason to believe God rejects someone as being His spokesman to the world at the very moment that someone makes her/his first mistake. Rather God was clearly aware of the likelihood that that someone might make mistakes at the moment God
chose that someone, but was still certain that someone was the best choice to take God's message to the world.
Shulem wrote:Perhaps KevinSims-boy would like to use science to prove the Explanations of Facisimile No. 3 are true and correct? Good luck. You need it.
To be perfectly honest, I have no
desire "to use science to prove the" mentioned explanations, even if I
did have any idea how to prove them that way, which I don't. My emphasis has always been, if we go on the assumption that there
is a good God in control of the universe, then does it make sense to conclude that that God chose Joseph Smith as His spokesman to the world? I think it does, Smith's explanations of Facsimile Number 3 notwithstanding.