Physics Guy wrote:Oo, those falafel eaters.
Seriously, though, I do seem to recall JLHPROF affirming, sometime last year on these boards, that he would definitely stone a helpless person to death if he felt that God had commanded it. My religion won't let me tolerate that as a legitimate religious viewpoint. I can accept that killing might be right under certain circumstances but a feeling that God has commanded it is not one of them.
While Nephi was merely "prompted" to kill Laban, I'd never heard of anyone saying you could get personal revelation to kill. However, the prophet is a different story. There is no standing moral dilemma that I'm aware of in the Church where we need to be ready one day to know when it is or isn't right to kill. However, as a point of instruction staking out the authority of the prophet, as a thought experiment, it is conventional wisdom that if the prophet were to command you to kill someone, then you should do it. But a prophets are fallible, right? Yes, they are, and as my Book of Mormon teacher at BYU taught us -- and he had a Phd in theology from Harvard no less and significantly more fun-loving and liberal than his peers such as Benson's son -- then you perform the killing anyway and you will be blessed for it.
My religion won't let me tolerate that as a legitimate religious viewpoint
And that is a very good thing, however, my only criticism would be that, it must be nice that you happened to be born into a broad tradition where the Bible is the only authority rather than the local minister vs. a church where the prophet and the Brethren of a worldwide corporation are the final authority. If your modern sensibilities tell you that your minister is way behind the times, you can just leave, go across the street and start up your own church and say that the other guy wasn't following the Bible. But that flexibility works both ways, and if we are to fairly compare bible-based Christianity to Mormonism, I think we need to count both hits and misses. I don't know how much Westboro baptist and others like it would bring down the average, but I think a fair comparison would need to take into account all denominations that bill themselves as bound by the Bible as final authority.