Shulem wrote: ↑Wed Nov 13, 2024 3:17 pm
Seriously, I hope readers will begin to understand or accept the idea that Joseph Smith really was living out his imagination as fictional characters he invented in the pages of the Book of Mormon.
I've been reading the texts that Palmyra residents had said Joseph was reading before 1830. Of course there's the KJV, the heaviest influence on the Book of Mormon. The other is Arabian Nights. There's a tendency for historians today to equate the Arabian Nights collection with the Sinbad/Aladdin stories, which were added later, and then dismiss the entire collection as fanciful stories for children. But if you read the text, as Joseph would have had it "for a library" (according to Palmyra resident Philetus Spear), there's quite a lot of information to mine. Arabian Nights is after all a collection of various authentic stories taken from Arabic, Persian, Indian, Egyptian and Syriac histories dating back to at least the 10th century AD. And, if Joseph had
this translation, which was one of the most popular at that time, he would have picked up a lot more through the notes provided by the translator Jonathan Scott. Notice the last part of the title: "Also, an introduction and notes, illustrative of the religion, manners and customs, of the Mahummedans".
Give it a read. From that introduction alone Joseph could have encountered the following ideas:
1. Lost antediluvian scriptures written by Adam, Seth, and Enoch and also a post-flood set to Abraham:
"The Muslims are taught in the Koran that God has made revelations of his will to various prophets in writing, all of which it is requisite to believe. The whole of the sacred books are said to be one hundred and four, of which ten were given to Adam, fifty to Seth, thirty to Idris or Enoch, ten to Abraham, and the other four, being the Pentateuch, the Psalms, the Gospel, and the Koran, were delivered to Moses, David, Jesus Christ, and Muhammad, whose revelation being the seal of prophecy and mission, no other dispensation will be made. All the divine books, except the four last, the Muslims believe to be entirely lost."
2. Antediluvian ministering angels that believe in the dispensation of Moses and fly from one end of the earth to another:
"The Muhammadan tradition respecting genii corresponds with that of the Jews concerning a sort of dæmons named Shiddeem, whom some of the rabbins fancy to have been begotten by two angels, named Aza and Azael, on Naamah, daughter of Lamech, before the flood; and they say that these spirits, like the ministration angels, have wings, fly from one end of the world to the other, and have a knowledge of futurity, but are not immortal. They affirm, also, that some of them believe in the dispensation of Moses, and that others are infidels and reprobate."
3. References to fallen angels and giants:
"The ancient Persians affirmed, and by most oriental nations it is credited, that these genii inhabited the world before the creation of Adam, but falling at length into general corruption, they were driven into the mountainous region of Caucasus, where they were finally reduced by Tahmuras, one of the ancient kings of Persia. These beings are of various denominations. Some are termed Genii, others Peries, some Deo, Dio, or Giants, others Ghole, Tucween, &c. &c. and have various offices and qualities assigned them in the fabulous legends and heroic poems and romances of the East, of which, as well as of the 1001 Nights, they form the most considerable part of the machinery."
4. Teachings of Jews on an impermanent "hell" and the release that comes through the intercession of prophets:
"The Muhammadans believe in a general resurrection and a future judgment, at which man will be doomed to happiness or misery according to his faith and actions in this life; but that the punishment of the Muslims will not be everlasting, as, after having expiated their sins by long sufferings, they will be released from hell and admitted into Paradise. According to a tradition said to have been delivered from Muhammad, the period of torment will not be less than nine hundred years in any case, nor extend beyond seven thousand. The magicians and the Jews, from whom Muhammad probably borrowed the doctrine, believed, that after a long purgatory sinners would be released from torment at the intercession of their law-givers and prophets."
In addition, Joseph could have picked up his different toponyms like Cumorah and Comron. Although I now believe its more likely that Joseph latched on to those toponyms as they were also found in Charles Anthon's Classical Dictionary. That discussion is a whole thread of its own.
So I think you're right. I think in the earliest ideations of the narratives, Joseph was writing himself into an Arabian Nights/Captain Kidd style oriental treasure hunting yarn, and that narrative shifted following the meetings with Bradish, Mitchill and Anthon* to become a golden American Egyptian record pulled from Cumorah.
*Anthon said in a letter to the secretary of the United States Exploring Expedition that his favorite theory with regard to the peopling of the Americas assumed that burial mounds in North America were constructed by Egyptian Indians who sailed across the Pacific
before the arrival of the Native Americans from the land bridge. That discussion is also a whole thread of its own