Ambiguous End-of-life Mormon ethics and Bishop roulette

The catch-all forum for general topics and debates. Minimal moderation. Rated PG to PG-13.
Post Reply
drumdude
God
Posts: 8173
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 5:29 am

Ambiguous End-of-life Mormon ethics and Bishop roulette

Post by drumdude »

Over at an LDS apologist’s blog, a regular stream of “near death experience” posts try to push the idea that the spirit world really exists and is unexplainable by atheists. While that is an open question, it seems like the way it’s applied to Mormon theology is more than a little messy.

Someone in a Mormon family shared two different experiences with two different bishops.

Bishop 1:
A few years ago, my grandpa went in for surgery and suffered a bad reaction to general anesthesia and never woke up again. The doctors think he had some kind of stroke when they tried to bring him out of the anesthesia. After two days, they were able to determine that he was clinically brain dead and approached my dad/uncles/aunts about removing life support. My parents consulted with their bishop who told them that it was ok because “his spirit had already left the body”.
Bishop 2:
Contrast this with the situation of a friend whose mother was in a bad accident and had a severe brain injury but their brain was still functioning but too damaged to let them exit a persistent vegetative state. The church was very against them removing life support even thought that woman had left strict instructions that she did not want prolonged life saving measures if she was ever in that state. Her bishop insisted that because her spirit was still in her body that they couldn’t “force it out by letting her die by euthanasia” and generally made life difficult for them as they removed her feeding tube and followed her final wishes.
The second bishop may well be an avid reader of the Aforementioned Mormon apologist.

A doctor who works in the Utah area chimed in:
Doctor who works in Mordor here. I have these discussions with patients and their families every day. Preserving life unnaturally (ie keeping people alive artificially with ventilators or artificial feeds) is NOT a tenet of the Mormon religion. Even though a lot of Mormons think it is. This bishop was going rogue and should have kept his weird opinion to himself
https://www.reddit.com/r/exmormon/comme ... _confused/

Given the fact Mormon theology is so nebulous and ill defined, it’s not surprising that Mormons are confused on their own official beliefs. So much so that it actually results in extended suffering on a regular basis, where Mormons who have expressed their wishes are overridden by misinformed bishops.

This seems like an important area for bishops to be more well trained in.
User avatar
Dr. Shades
Founder and Visionary
Posts: 3287
Joined: Mon Oct 26, 2020 2:48 pm

Re: Ambiguous End-of-life Mormon ethics and Bishop roulette

Post by Dr. Shades »

drumdude wrote: ↑
Mon Sep 21, 2026 11:49 pm
This seems like an important area for bishops to be more well trained in.
Better yet, it’s an important area for the general membership to be adults and make their own adult decisions rather than outsource their brains by running to the bishop for every damned thing.
.
"When the Mormon God requires a PR crisis to act moral, we've clearly outgrown him."

--Everybody Wang Chung, 06-01-2026
User avatar
Equality
Priest
Posts: 316
Joined: Wed Dec 23, 2020 4:41 pm

Re: Ambiguous End-of-life Mormon ethics and Bishop roulette

Post by Equality »

I don't know if it has changed in the last 16 years, but I have a copy of the Handbook 1: Stake Presidents and Bishops 2010 and it seems pretty clear to me that the Bishop who was shaming the family into keeping their family member on artificial life support was going against church policy

Page 163, Section 17.2.8 Prolonging Life
When severe illness strikes, members should exercise faith in the Lord and seek competent medical assistance. However, when dying becomes inevitable, it should be seen as a blessing and a purposeful part of eternal existence. Members should not feel obligated to extend mortal life by means that are unreasonable. These judgments are best made by family members after receiving wise and competent medical advice and seeking divine guidance through fasting and prayer. Leaders offer special concern and blessings to those who are deciding whether or not to remove life support for a family member.
(emphasis added)
"They're eating the dogs! . . . They're eating the cats!"
"I love the inflation"
"Let [Iran] take out Los Angeles. Let them take out San Diego"
"I want to thank President Putin"
"Praise be to Allah"
--Donald Trump
huckelberry
God
Posts: 4129
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 3:48 pm

Re: Ambiguous End-of-life Mormon ethics and Bishop roulette

Post by huckelberry »

Dr. Shades wrote: ↑
Tue Sep 22, 2026 1:29 am
drumdude wrote: ↑
Mon Sep 21, 2026 11:49 pm
This seems like an important area for bishops to be more well trained in.
Better yet, it’s an important area for the general membership to be adults and make their own adult decisions rather than outsource their brains by running to the bishop for every damned thing.
I think shades is not only correct but importantly so.
User avatar
Dr LOD
Nursery
Posts: 31
Joined: Mon Nov 16, 2020 9:42 pm

Re: Ambiguous End-of-life Mormon ethics and Bishop roulette

Post by Dr LOD »

I’ve actually had this happen in practice. A stake president tried to push a family to continue heroic care despite clear evidence that the patient did not want it. I reminded him that the decision belonged to the patient and family, not him. Things got heated, and he threatened to escalate, so I told him he was welcome to, and to keep in mind that his chain of command was a lot stricter than mine. He filed a hospital complaint that went nowhere. I made a call, and a friend of mine who is a GA Seventy contacted the Area Presidency. The stake president then had a corrective conversation with them.
Actual physician. Degree in genetics. Amateur Mormonologist. Pipe strictly decorative. Opinions frequently off-label and not evaluated by the FDA, the SCMC, or FAIR.
Post Reply