Was Mormonism basically the thing the American West had to define itself against?

The catch-all forum for general topics and debates. Minimal moderation. Rated PG to PG-13.
User avatar
The Before
Sunbeam
Posts: 79
Joined: Sat Aug 08, 2026 2:11 am

Re: Was Mormonism basically the thing the American West had to define itself against?

Post by The Before »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Sun Sep 27, 2026 2:59 am
I see. So after all that, the scholarly insight is essentially “people notice rules more when somebody breaks them.”?

That’s not a particularly stunning insight.
If that’s what you got out of it, that’s fine. Anyone can reduce a complex subject into absurdity, watch:

Quantum mechanics: invisible stuff acting in unexpected ways.

I’m looking for real discussion here.

The interesting question is which rules get defended, how they get defended, and what other ideas get bundled into that defense. In the Mormon case, plural marriage became entangled with arguments about citizenship, republican government, women’s status, religious liberty, federal power, and what counted as acceptably American.

So the point isn’t merely that rule-breaking makes rules visible. It’s that boundary disputes can reveal the architecture connecting several norms at once.
"Life never gives us what we want at the moment that we consider appropriate. Adventures do occur, but not punctually." - EMF
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: Was Mormonism basically the thing the American West had to define itself against?

Post by Limnor »

The Before wrote: ↑
Sun Sep 27, 2026 2:30 pm
If that’s what you got out of it, that’s fine.
I’m just hard-pressed to find myself saying “I’m not Mormon, therefore I’m American.”

Maybe if you provided evidence in which a unique bit of American-ness was formed due to Mormon influence, or some issue that was not already a norm that Mormonism distinctly shaped?

Otherwise, it still seems to me that Mormonism was just judged against norms that already existed.
User avatar
The Before
Sunbeam
Posts: 79
Joined: Sat Aug 08, 2026 2:11 am

Re: Was Mormonism basically the thing the American West had to define itself against?

Post by The Before »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Sun Sep 27, 2026 3:03 pm
The Before wrote: ↑
Sun Sep 27, 2026 2:30 pm
If that’s what you got out of it, that’s fine.
I’m just hard-pressed to find myself saying “I’m not Mormon, therefore I’m American.”

Maybe if you provided evidence in which a unique bit of American-ness was formed due to Mormon influence, or some issue that was not already a norm that Mormonism distinctly shaped?

Otherwise, it still seems to me that Mormonism was just judged against norms that already existed.
Well, I think you’re now asking me to prove a stronger claim than I’m making. I’m not arguing that Americans literally thought, “I am not Mormon, therefore I am American,” or that Mormonism uniquely invented some norm ex nihilo.

My point is about boundary formation, not invention. A norm can already exist and still become more sharply articulated, legally enforced, and culturally loaded when a conspicuous group violates it.

In the Mormon case, plural marriage, concentrated ecclesiastical authority, and the territorial church-state problem became occasions for Americans to argue about what counted as legitimate marriage, legitimate religion, legitimate political authority, and ultimately legitimate Americanness.

So yes, Mormonism was judged against existing norms. But the act of judging it was not culturally neutral. It helped specify where those norms ended, which differences could be tolerated, and which had to be surrendered before Mormonism could be treated as fully compatible with American civic life.

If your standard is that Mormonism must have created a uniquely American norm that otherwise would never have existed, then no, that isn’t my thesis.
"Life never gives us what we want at the moment that we consider appropriate. Adventures do occur, but not punctually." - EMF
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: Was Mormonism basically the thing the American West had to define itself against?

Post by Limnor »

The Before wrote: ↑
Sun Sep 27, 2026 3:13 pm
Limnor wrote: ↑
Sun Sep 27, 2026 3:03 pm
I’m just hard-pressed to find myself saying “I’m not Mormon, therefore I’m American.”

Maybe if you provided evidence in which a unique bit of American-ness was formed due to Mormon influence, or some issue that was not already a norm that Mormonism distinctly shaped?

Otherwise, it still seems to me that Mormonism was just judged against norms that already existed.
Well, I think you’re now asking me to prove a stronger claim than I’m making. I’m not arguing that Americans literally thought, “I am not Mormon, therefore I am American,” or that Mormonism uniquely invented some norm ex nihilo.

My point is about boundary formation, not invention. A norm can already exist and still become more sharply articulated, legally enforced, and culturally loaded when a conspicuous group violates it.

In the Mormon case, plural marriage, concentrated ecclesiastical authority, and the territorial church-state problem became occasions for Americans to argue about what counted as legitimate marriage, legitimate religion, legitimate political authority, and ultimately legitimate Americanness.

So yes, Mormonism was judged against existing norms. But the act of judging it was not culturally neutral. It helped specify where those norms ended, which differences could be tolerated, and which had to be surrendered before Mormonism could be treated as fully compatible with American civic life.

If your standard is that Mormonism must have created a uniquely American norm that otherwise would never have existed, then no, that isn’t my thesis.
This is why I think your thesis boils down to “people notice rules more when somebody breaks them” without all the extra words.
User avatar
The Before
Sunbeam
Posts: 79
Joined: Sat Aug 08, 2026 2:11 am

Re: Was Mormonism basically the thing the American West had to define itself against?

Post by The Before »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Sun Sep 27, 2026 3:24 pm
This is why I think your thesis boils down to “people notice rules more when somebody breaks them” without all the extra words.
That’s like saying that all of 20th century American literature boils down to: A person has feelings in a rapidly changing country and handles them badly.

It’s absurd.
"Life never gives us what we want at the moment that we consider appropriate. Adventures do occur, but not punctually." - EMF
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: Was Mormonism basically the thing the American West had to define itself against?

Post by Limnor »

The Before wrote: ↑
Sun Sep 27, 2026 7:51 pm
Limnor wrote: ↑
Sun Sep 27, 2026 3:24 pm
This is why I think your thesis boils down to “people notice rules more when somebody breaks them” without all the extra words.
That’s like saying that all of 20th century American literature boils down to: A person has feelings in a rapidly changing country and handles them badly.

It’s absurd.
I’m not reducing “all of Mormonism in American history” to one sentence. I’m reducing what you are describing.

Is there something more to your thesis, like some way Mormonism actually shaped American normalcy rather than just making existing boundaries more visible? that's what I’ve been asking for.
User avatar
Physics Guy
God
Posts: 2353
Joined: Tue Oct 27, 2020 7:40 am
Location: on the battlefield of life

Re: Was Mormonism basically the thing the American West had to define itself against?

Post by Physics Guy »

How big a blip did Mormonism really make on the cultural radar screen of 19th-century America? Unless people all over talked and thought about Mormons a lot more than I imagine they did, it seems perverse to speak of Mormon divergences shaping non-Mormon norms, or even reinforcing them.

I mean, think of theft instead of polygamy. I reckon most 19th-century Americans thought that stealing was wrong. They also knew about famous criminals who robbed people, and told stories about legendary outlaws. To what extent did banditry become unacceptable because people contrasted themselves with the bandits about which they heard stories, and to what extent did the bandit stories only circulate because banditry was unacceptable?

I think it was pretty much entirely one way. I don’t think bandits defined the boundary. I think the boundary was there and they were clearly outside it.

And I think polygamy and theocracy were like theft in that way, as things that most Americans already opposed. The fact that Mormons violated those norms brought attention to Mormons. I don’t think the tail wagged the dog.
Philosophical pirates think, therefore they Arrr!
User avatar
Kishkumen
God
Posts: 10505
Joined: Tue Oct 27, 2020 2:37 pm
Location: Cassius University
Contact:

Re: Was Mormonism basically the thing the American West had to define itself against?

Post by Kishkumen »

The Before wrote: ↑
Fri Sep 25, 2026 10:21 pm
No, not mere tropes. They were real historical features. My point is that literature and popular culture can take real features like polygamy and theocratic governance and make them do extra symbolic work. They become shorthand for “Mormon difference” or “un-American-ness,” often in ways that flatten complexity. So I’m less interested in whether polygamy existed than in what writers made polygamy mean.
Polygamy and theocracy were so fundamentally different from the dominant family culture and political ideals of the United States in the 19th century and thereafter that I can't help but think that they would always have been made to mean "Un-American" in some form or another. 19th-century Mormonism was too different, and the federal government brought the LDS Church into line. I believe that realignment was, in the end, for the best. Polygamy is a disastrous social system, just as theocracy is a disastrous political system. Mormon Fundamentalist communities give us a fair idea of how poorly these institutions function.
"He disturbs the laws of his country, he forces himself upon women, and he puts men to death without trial.” ~Otanes on the monarch, Herodotus Histories 3.80.
User avatar
The Before
Sunbeam
Posts: 79
Joined: Sat Aug 08, 2026 2:11 am

Re: Was Mormonism basically the thing the American West had to define itself against?

Post by The Before »

Kishkumen wrote: ↑
Tue Sep 29, 2026 3:36 pm
The Before wrote: ↑
Fri Sep 25, 2026 10:21 pm
No, not mere tropes. They were real historical features. My point is that literature and popular culture can take real features like polygamy and theocratic governance and make them do extra symbolic work. They become shorthand for “Mormon difference” or “un-American-ness,” often in ways that flatten complexity. So I’m less interested in whether polygamy existed than in what writers made polygamy mean.
Polygamy and theocracy were so fundamentally different from the dominant family culture and political ideals of the United States in the 19th century and thereafter that I can't help but think that they would always have been made to mean "Un-American" in some form or another. 19th-century Mormonism was too different, and the federal government brought the LDS Church into line. I believe that realignment was, in the end, for the best. Polygamy is a disastrous social system, just as theocracy is a disastrous political system. Mormon Fundamentalist communities give us a fair idea of how poorly these institutions function.
Yes, and thank you for engaging. I think this gets much closer to what I’ve been trying to articulate. I’m not arguing that polygamy and theocracy were merely inventions imposed on Mormons by hostile outsiders. They were real and profound departures from dominant American family and political norms.

What interests me is what happened when those differences became politically intolerable. The federal response did more than eliminate particular practices; it effectively established conditions under which Mormonism could become fully legible as American. In that sense, the conflict tells us something about both sides: what nineteenth-century Mormonism was, and what the United States was willing to recognize as compatible with citizenship, republican government, marriage, and religious liberty.

I also think your phrase “made to mean ‘Un-American’” is important. The practices were genuinely different, but the meaning assigned to that difference is still historically interesting. Difference does not interpret itself.

Where I might hesitate is with the word “always.” It seems worth asking whether polygamy and theocracy were inevitably destined to signify “Un-American,” or whether that particular meaning emerged from the political and cultural assumptions of nineteenth-century America. That distinction is probably where I find the subject most interesting.

And I agree, the federal government stepping in was a good thing.
"Life never gives us what we want at the moment that we consider appropriate. Adventures do occur, but not punctually." - EMF
User avatar
Kishkumen
God
Posts: 10505
Joined: Tue Oct 27, 2020 2:37 pm
Location: Cassius University
Contact:

Re: Was Mormonism basically the thing the American West had to define itself against?

Post by Kishkumen »

The Before wrote: ↑
Wed Sep 30, 2026 3:06 am
Where I might hesitate is with the word “always.” It seems worth asking whether polygamy and theocracy were inevitably destined to signify “Un-American,” or whether that particular meaning emerged from the political and cultural assumptions of nineteenth-century America. That distinction is probably where I find the subject most interesting.

And I agree, the federal government stepping in was a good thing.
Unless we are changing the variables in ways that contradict historical reality, polygamy and theocracy were always going to be a problem for a predominantly Enlightenment-tinged Protestant culture.
"He disturbs the laws of his country, he forces himself upon women, and he puts men to death without trial.” ~Otanes on the monarch, Herodotus Histories 3.80.
Post Reply