I have some background in the film industry which informs my opinion but I can understand how it would seem innocent enough to hire a full scale production company to produce these videos.
I suppose they could simply be capitalizing on the naïveté of Dan not knowing the typical cost of similar videos made for putting on YouTube.
Good point. Earlier I said "Red Brick brings a cachet to his efforts that wouldn't be as rewarding if he defended BY against criticism by less expensive means." In light of your point, it seems reasonable to add "Red Brick brings a cachet that to many is far outweighed by the unreasonableness of the cost." it makes one wonder what the donors think.
Long ago when this topic first was discussed here, i recall checking and BYU's religion dept had a full set of videos about Brigham Young in their video library that were used in teaching church history. Based on the production notes they clearly didn't cost as much to make as Peterson's. Peterson seems to be wanting to answer different questions, which is great, but again, why at such outrageous cost?
Great points.
Mormon art isn’t really a thing. The architecture of most of their temple is bland and uninspiring. Most of the LDS videos in the ward library are very tacky. I think Dan’s idea to raise the bar in Mormon Cinema with Witnesses and Six Days in August at least made some sense.
With Becoming Brigham it’s just more painfully obvious that the lavish production costs and quantity of videos is supposed to make up for the lack of substance. These are still just dressed up ward video library flicks.
Speaking of the gratuitous spending of donated money...
.. We filmed beside the famous pond where Elder Wilford Woodruff — one of the greatest missionaries of this dispensation, a member of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles and ultimately the fourth president of the Church — baptized many of his Herefordshire converts. Unfortunately, the pond was empty today, coming as we did at the end of an exceptionally dry English summer. I’ve never before seen it completely without water....
Seems like something the location scouts should have verified, given how much the Interpreter is paying Red Brick.
Speaking of the gratuitous spending of donated money...
.. We filmed beside the famous pond where Elder Wilford Woodruff — one of the greatest missionaries of this dispensation, a member of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles and ultimately the fourth president of the Church — baptized many of his Herefordshire converts. Unfortunately, the pond was empty today, coming as we did at the end of an exceptionally dry English summer. I’ve never before seen it completely without water....
Seems like something the location scouts should have verified, given how much the Interpreter is paying Red Brick.
Speaking of the gratuitous spending of donated money....
.. We filmed beside the famous pond where Elder Wilford Woodruff — one of the greatest missionaries of this dispensation, a member of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles and ultimately the fourth president of the Church — baptized many of his Herefordshire converts. Unfortunately, the pond was empty today, coming as we did at the end of an exceptionally dry English summer. I’ve never before seen it completely without water....
Seems like something the location scouts should have verified, given how much the Interpreter is paying Red Brick.
One wonders why he didn’t remote view the location prior to booking the flights…
This is an image of said pond…
Given that the site is owned by the church, a quick phone call might have established its condition ahead of time. It’s like Red Brick do zero preparation for these trips. And now it’s declared that a local, the much vaunted Peter Fagg travel guide extraordinaire now getting his snout in the Interpreter trough on this trip. What does Peter do that Peterson or Red Brick could not have done themselves? Couldn’t Peter have just filmed some stock footage of the various locations so that Red Brick and Peterson, and his two on-screen stooges, and all their wives and all their equipment, didn’t need to leave Utah, saving tens and tens of thousands of dollars? Peterson via his Red Brick money front, is highly profligate with other people’s money. Less so with his own.
Premise 1. Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable.
Premise 2. The best evidence for the Book of Mormon is eyewitness testimony.
Conclusion. Therefore, the best evidence for the Book of Mormon is notoriously unreliable.
Seems like something the location scouts should have verified, given how much the Interpreter is paying Red Brick.
One wonders why he didn’t remote view the location prior to booking the flights…
This is an image of said pond…
Given that the site is owned by the church, a quick phone call might have established its condition ahead of time. It’s like Red Brick do zero preparation for these trips...
Especially since the site is lds owned. Wouldn't the lds church require permission to film there? Or wouldn't the location scout at least have checked? Surely they would have been told there's no water in it. Why didn't the famous tour guide they planned to hire tell them? Surely he would have known, given its his job to guide people around there. This is looking worse and worse. DCP says he and Red Brick together came to the determination that this trip was absolutely necessary. Why not pick a time when the necessary filming locations were available and in good shape?
I’d go as far as to say that Peterson and Red Brick have gone out of their way to make this trip as expensive to donors as they could without quite blowing the cover of it being a filming trip. There are many ways they could have achieved similar filming results for significantly less cost. I can’t think of many ways that they could have made it more costly than how they have chosen to do it.
Premise 1. Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable.
Premise 2. The best evidence for the Book of Mormon is eyewitness testimony.
Conclusion. Therefore, the best evidence for the Book of Mormon is notoriously unreliable.