Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

The catch-all forum for general topics and debates. Minimal moderation. Rated PG to PG-13.
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Limnor »

Gadianton wrote: ↑
Tue Sep 29, 2026 3:03 pm
As a Mormon scholar, you can feel your standing as an equal diminish behind that polite smile. This comes with a tinge of anger. That guy will stand before the Lord eventually and be punished for that smile. But it's just not good enough. You need revenge now. And really, the only turf that will satisfy without risk of jail is the intellectual domain, and so the intellectual complexity of the Book of Mormon in some way go beyond that guy's ability to grasp.
I can see this. It shows up in things like chiasmus, Nahom, Hebraisms, and etc. Like “the Book of Mormon contains chiasmus” becomes “Joseph couldn’t have written this,” and “NHM existed in Arabia” becomes “Nephi’s route has been archaeologically confirmed.” Maybe “overcompensation through obscure intellectualism” as an equalizing mechanism?
Kishkumen wrote: ↑
Tue Sep 29, 2026 4:05 pm
I think the big difference here is that very few people are ashamed to be seen watching "wholesome extreme violence," whereas they would feel embarrassed being seen watching sex. They watch plenty of sex or fantasize about sex even more than they watch the violence, but it is too embarrassing to be caught doing so--to be caught feeling aroused in public. So, they feel more comfortable pretending to be people who do not like watching or fantasizing about sex.

This is kinda like attitudes about PDA. Not everyone wants to be around people who can't control themselves sexually in public. Recently, I was visiting a museum when a couple that came in after me started making out throughout the tour. The museum was quiet, and you could hear them incessantly slobbering all over each other as they played grab ass. They were also very unattractive people. On the one hand, we can say that they are adults living in a free country, exercising their rights to do as they please. On the other hand, it was pretty nauseating.

Call me a prude: while I love sex and think it is healthy, I prefer that this healthy part of life be enjoyed out of the public eye, not out in public.
I think there may be another consideration here. I don’t like watching boxing, but I have no problem watching *Predator.” And I don’t particularly mind a rom-com with gratuitous T&A either, but I wouldn’t be comfortable in the situation you described. The difference for me is probably how close it feels to the real thing.
Marcus
God
Posts: 8297
Joined: Mon Oct 25, 2021 10:44 pm

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Marcus »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Tue Sep 29, 2026 10:36 pm
Kishkumen wrote: ↑
Tue Sep 29, 2026 4:05 pm
I think the big difference here is that very few people are ashamed to be seen watching "wholesome extreme violence," whereas they would feel embarrassed being seen watching sex. They watch plenty of sex or fantasize about sex even more than they watch the violence, but it is too embarrassing to be caught doing so--to be caught feeling aroused in public. So, they feel more comfortable pretending to be people who do not like watching or fantasizing about sex.

This is kinda like attitudes about PDA. Not everyone wants to be around people who can't control themselves sexually in public. Recently, I was visiting a museum when a couple that came in after me started making out throughout the tour. The museum was quiet, and you could hear them incessantly slobbering all over each other as they played grab ass. They were also very unattractive people. On the one hand, we can say that they are adults living in a free country, exercising their rights to do as they please. On the other hand, it was pretty nauseating.

Call me a prude: while I love sex and think it is healthy, I prefer that this healthy part of life be enjoyed out of the public eye, not out in public.
I think there may be another consideration here. I don’t like watching boxing, but I have no problem watching *Predator.” And I don’t particularly mind a rom-com with gratuitous T&A either, but I wouldn’t be comfortable in the situation you described. The difference for me is probably how close it feels to the real thing.
I'm with you there, on your boxing v Predator comparison. I love sci fi, and movies like the Alien and Predator series are favorites.

BUT, I canNOT watch war movies like Saving Private Ryan, etc. I am overwhelmed with the human impact and loss.

I love Kenneth Branaugh's movies where he is Hercule Poirot, but one starts with a realistic war sequence and while i have rewatched his movies multiple times, I skip that beginning every time. It's just more than I can take.

Speaking of Predator, did you see Prey and Badlands? Two very worthy additions to the genre, IMHO.
User avatar
Gadianton
God
Posts: 6916
Joined: Sun Oct 25, 2020 11:56 pm
Location: Elsewhere

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Gadianton »

It's a bit of a vicious circle. Gratuitous N exists in movies literally to incite males into watching them for gratification at some level or another, and this is made possible by religious conservative culture of which Mormonism is a part, which keeps such things forbidden. If it weren't culturally forbidden, it wouldn't incite. There would be no reason to make it. The Reverend made some salient points. Mormonism is not a leading light, they have followed conservative Christian culture for the most part when it comes to anything that could be considered an indulgence. They go off the deep end to show themselves as leading the way in prudishnessness and self-abasement.

Mormonism's positions on sexuality are in lock step with the evangelical community, to a point.

Prepare to have your minds blown, because there is an important difference, which very few people appreciate. Consider that while I've never been a Christian per se, I have had (back in the day of course. as I am now married and a sagely elderly gentleman with no appetites) more born again Christian girlfriends than Mormon girlfriends, so I know a bit about their angle.

Joseph Smith rejected the Song of Solomon as uninspired writing because he was such a hypocritical prude that he couldn't imagine the Lord authoring risque material. I came to learn that this is a uniquely Mormon position. Think about it, Mormons are looking for flaws in the Bible and ways to diminish it. Christians just assume the Bible back to front is equal word-of-God and look for the positive. I can't remember her exact words, but I was told that the Song of Solomon was a ??? for husbands and wives. So at some point, in Christianity, sexuality is permitted wherein with Mormonism, it's really forbidden to the point of SLC sending letters to wards to micromanage the sex lives of endowed couples. Sensuality in any way is scripturally speaking, offensive and trash, and when that time comes, in marriage, it's best to embrace it as a sacrifice lest one be found of impure thinking at the last day and smitten. Christians seem to have more reason to believe sensuality has a real place, given that it's Biblical.
"...gain control of land that FARMS owned..." -- Bill Hamblin
"Why did FARMS own land to begin with?" -- Me
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Limnor »

Marcus wrote: ↑
Tue Sep 29, 2026 11:18 pm
BUT, I canNOT watch war movies like Saving Private Ryan, etc. I am overwhelmed with the human impact and loss.

I love Kenneth Branaugh's movies where he is Hercule Poirot, but one starts with a realistic war sequence and while i have rewatched his movies multiple times, I skip that beginning every time. It's just more than I can take.

Speaking of Predator, did you see Prey and Badlands? Two very worthy additions to the genre, IMHO.
Branagh in Henry V is a favorite of mine, though it’s more the inspirational “band of brothers” speech that gets it done for me than anything else. Michael Caine and Stanley Baker in “Zulu” are all time favorites as well, but the violence in that movie seems much more detached than more contemporary films.

I liked the direction “Prey” took the series, but I’ve not seen “Badlands.”

The chaos and nervousness, the remarkable self control and need to hide his feelings from his troops that Tom Hanks portrayed in “Saving Private Ryan” was well done and really hit home for me, but I do tend to think of the art form as a portrayal of reality more so than the reality itself. Stanley Baker had the same effect in a similar performance of depicting courage under fire, from my perspective.
Gadianton wrote: ↑
Wed Sep 30, 2026 1:45 am
religious conservative culture of which Mormonism is a part, which keeps such things forbidden. If it weren't culturally forbidden, it wouldn't incite.

-snip-

They go off the deep end to show themselves as leading the way in prudishnessness and self-abasement.
I tend to think of those who “show themselves as leading the way” at least in terms of portraying themselves as super pure, as “outside the cup” believers.

In my understanding, Paul essentially echoes what you have said here: “If it weren't culturally forbidden, it wouldn't incite,” about “the law.” Not precisely, but I think the underlying thought is similar.

It’s harder to be honest with yourself and “be” yourself when there is pressure to show an outward righteousness. I think there is pressure to perform—sincerely no pun intended, I mean to show an outward performance of righteousness—across many different faith traditions.
User avatar
The Before
Sunbeam
Posts: 79
Joined: Sat Aug 08, 2026 2:11 am

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by The Before »

malkie wrote: ↑
Tue Sep 29, 2026 3:25 am
I sent you a PM - private message - I believe PM is a commonly understood internet expression. It's the modern equivalent of speaking to someone privately rather than in public, and may be regarded as more friendly than openly pointing out an issue.
Eureka. Well, get with the times old one, because it’s actually referred to as a DM on modern platforms (present turn-of-the-century technology acknowledged).

But to your request, perhaps I should have simply PM’d Tom. Mayhaps, also, members here who complain about “Mop-ologists” should simply “PM” those individuals, or, as I’ve suggested before, ring them on the ancient technology of the telephone.

But, no more thread-crapping! Bring back the gratuitous violence and nudity! I am sorry for the interruption.
"Life never gives us what we want at the moment that we consider appropriate. Adventures do occur, but not punctually." - EMF
Marcus
God
Posts: 8297
Joined: Mon Oct 25, 2021 10:44 pm

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Marcus »

The Before wrote: ↑
Wed Sep 30, 2026 3:00 am
malkie wrote: ↑
Tue Sep 29, 2026 3:25 am
I sent you a PM - private message - I believe PM is a commonly understood internet expression. It's the modern equivalent of speaking to someone privately rather than in public, and may be regarded as more friendly than openly pointing out an issue.
Eureka. Well, get with the times old one, because it’s actually referred to as a DM on modern platforms (present turn-of-the-century technology acknowledged).
And yet you asked what a PM was.
But to your request, perhaps I should have simply PM’d Tom. Mayhaps, also, members here who complain about “Mop-ologists” should simply “PM” those individuals, or, as I’ve suggested before, ring them on the ancient technology of the telephone.
You're sounding more and more like Sledge.
Limnor wrote: ↑
Wed Sep 30, 2026 2:29 am
...The chaos and nervousness, the remarkable self control and need to hide his feelings from his troops that Tom Hanks portrayed in “Saving Private Ryan” was well done and really hit home for me, but I do tend to think of the art form as a portrayal of reality more so than the reality itself.
Of course. And the portrayal of reality is still heart-wrenching. We just went through the 25th anniversary of 9/11 here in the tri-states, and while I can't watch fictional war movies, I steel myself to watch the real life memorials, out of respect for the people I know who are still impacted by this. It still brings everyone I know here to tears when the day is discussed. Still.

Back to the topic: Peterson's opinion about violence seems very convenient.
User avatar
Everybody Wang Chung
God
Posts: 3957
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 1:52 am

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Everybody Wang Chung »

Nothing screams efficient problem solving quite like flying 14 people to Manchester, England for a week just to check the water level in person, instead of making a 30 second phone call.
"I'm on paid sabbatical from BYU in exchange for my promise to use this time to finish two books."

Daniel C. Peterson, 2014
yellowstone123
Holy Ghost
Posts: 884
Joined: Sat Apr 15, 2023 1:55 am
Location: Milky Way Galaxy

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by yellowstone123 »

Doctor CamNC4Me wrote: ↑
Mon Sep 28, 2026 1:55 pm
Image
Is this not Saint Sebastian, revealing the awful grace of God (see Aeschylus, Agamemnon) — or, in more modern times, Sebastian Flyte in Evelyn Waugh’s Brideshead Revisited (Et in Arcadia ego) — or, for others, My Enemy Is My Guest: Jesus and Violence in Luke, by J. Massyngbaerde Ford? And finally, is this not Doc, stirring the pot he would call black, posting a picture of harm — religious trauma — dealt by pious religious figures in the name of goodness, in the name of God?
Three things cannot be long hidden: the sun, the moon, and the truth.

— Buddha
Marcus
God
Posts: 8297
Joined: Mon Oct 25, 2021 10:44 pm

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by Marcus »

yellowstone, are you okay? This post seems extremely out of character for you!!
yellowstone123
Holy Ghost
Posts: 884
Joined: Sat Apr 15, 2023 1:55 am
Location: Milky Way Galaxy

Re: Mopologetics and the Appeal of "wholesome extreme violence"

Post by yellowstone123 »

Marcus wrote: ↑
Sat Oct 03, 2026 1:47 am
yellowstone, are you okay? This post seems extremely out of character for you!!
I am doing fine, Marcus, thank you. A painting brought back some painful memories. It happens. My gift at age 20 was Borderline Personality Disorder. My emotions become very intense at times. It's just something I deal with, but not alone; the people I meet with during the month, along with daily 12-step meetings, help tremendously. I appreciate the concern.
Three things cannot be long hidden: the sun, the moon, and the truth.

— Buddha
Post Reply