I doubt he realizes how revealing his response is.
John Dehlin joins Mormonism LIVE to give the other side
- Limnor
- God
- Posts: 2014
- Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am
-
MG 2.0
- God
- Posts: 8847
- Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2021 4:45 pm
-
Marcus
- God
- Posts: 8297
- Joined: Mon Oct 25, 2021 10:44 pm
-
MG 2.0
- God
- Posts: 8847
- Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2021 4:45 pm
-
yellowstone123
- Holy Ghost
- Posts: 884
- Joined: Sat Apr 15, 2023 1:55 am
- Location: Milky Way Galaxy
Re: John Dehlin joins Mormonism LIVE to give the other side
Rome and how things change.Physics Guy wrote: ↑Sat Oct 03, 2026 11:03 amThis reminded me of a favorite book’s final line, which was a Latin quotation, and in checking my understanding of the Latin before posting about it, I found stuff about it on Wikipedia that I didn’t know.Doctor CamNC4Me wrote: ↑Sat Oct 03, 2026 12:26 amEven now, it still feels like a shame to see what was once something unique and kind of beautiful turn into a soulless entity.
The line was from a long poem by a 12th century monk, protesting the corrupt society of his time. Along with the preceding line, which my favorite book did not quote, the verses probably read:Bernard of Cluny wrote:Nunc ubi Regulus aut ubi Romulus aut ubi Remus?
Stat Roma pristina nomine, nomina nuda tenemus.So the original was explicitly about a particular state or society, Rome.Where now are Regulus, Romulus, Remus?
The old Rome remains in name only; we hold on to bare names.
According to Wikipedia, Bernard’s text survives in somewhat differently copied versions, and in one, the word “Roma” (Rome) is replaced with “Rosa” (rose). That version’s second line, separated from the previous line referring to three figures from Roman legend, gave Umberto Eco his title for The Name of the Rose. Since the book was set in a late medieval monastery, and narrated by a monk, ending it with a real medieval monk’s Latin verse was effective.
That last line in Latin is the only place in the book that directly mentions the titular “name of the rose”. The theme of something once lovely having been lost, leaving only words without meaning, runs throughout the whole book, however. It might initially refer to wisdom from Classical times that had been lost by the Middle Ages even though monks copied books in their libraries, but over the book the theme seems to expand to include the humane religious revival of Francis of Assisi that had become just another vehicle of political power. When great ideas are abandoned, their names tend to be kept, and even used to oppose the original ideas themselves.
The “Rose” reading makes the line more universal and symbolic, embracing any examples of names and ideas persisting as empty ghosts after their original meaning is gone. The more likely original version referring to Rome may be more specifically relevant nowadays, though, when a lot of civic or national ideals seem to be ghostly like that.
The very fact that people have been noticing and lamenting this pattern since at least the twelfth century offers some hope, however. Good new ideas have grown up many times long after Rome. If those roses have faded again in their turn, turning into mere names, perhaps we can also plant new roses once more.
When the Tabernacle Choir at Temple Square sings “Lo, How a Rose E’er Blooming,” I think of the plain and precious things left out of the song.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kU-E46o0sp0
661K views.
The video description notes the harmonization by Michael Praetorius. The English words are Theodore Baker’s 1894 translation.
The hymn was originally “Es ist ein Ros entsprungen,” a Marian hymn sung by German Catholics. The earliest printed text is in the Speyer hymnal (Alte Catholische Geistliche Kirchengesäng), published in Cologne in 1599. The second stanza names Mary as the rose, and Jesus as the little flower.
In 1609 the German Lutheran composer Michael Praetorius published a four-part setting in Musae Sioniae and altered that stanza so that Jesus is the rose. Mary remains, but only as the pure maid who brought him.
Late 16th century, sung by German Catholics:
Das Röslein, das ich meine,
davon Isaias sagt,
ist Maria die reine,
die uns das Blümlein bracht.
Aus Gottes ew’gem Rat
hat sie ein Kind geboren
und blieb ein reine Magd.
The little rose that I mean,
of which Isaiah spoke,
is Mary the pure one,
who brought us the little flower.
By God’s eternal counsel
she has borne a child
and remained a pure maid.
Changed by Michael Praetorius, 1609:
Das Röslein, das ich meine,
davon Isaias sagt,
hat uns gebracht alleine
Marie, die reine Magd.
Aus Gottes ew’gem Rat
hat sie ein Kind geboren
wohl zu der halben Nacht.
The little rose that I mean,
of which Isaiah spoke,
Mary, the pure maid,
has brought to us alone.
By God’s eternal counsel
she has borne a child,
well at the midnight hour.
But when I see the name Michael Praetorius, the Latinized surname of Michael Schultheiss, I think of Sebastian, the 3rd-century Roman military officer of the Praetorian Guard—when his conversion to Christianity was discovered, his comrades used him for target practice—who was later canonized by the Catholic Church as Saint Sebastian.
Then there is Romans 8:28 (“all things work together for good”).
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CaROl1j-xBY
13M views
Three things cannot be long hidden: the sun, the moon, and the truth.
— Buddha
— Buddha