Rivendale wrote: ↑Wed Oct 28, 2026 5:35 pm
2nd Samuel 12, 11-12
This is not a command, but a prophecy that the event will happen. When the prophecy is fulfilled by David’s rebellious son Absolom, Absolom is not obeying any command from the LORD, but following the advice of his supporters.
The story does seem to imply that the LORD intended this mass rape to happen, at least according to Nathan. It’s portrayed as a divine punishment of David, and a painfully humiliating one; the suffering of David’s innocent concubines is ignored. Arguing in terms of what actually happened, beyond the story we have, is dubious because it’s not at all clear that any of it ever actually happened. Even just within the story, though, Absolom initially rebels because another of David’s sons rapes his sister, and David, the father of all three children, does nothing. Interpreting Absolom’s own later rapes as the LORD’s judgement on David is only what Nathan says. It makes more sense in the story as something Absolom did, because of previous failures by David. In that sense it’s a punishment of David, as well as a crime committed by Absolom against David’s wives. The LORD never commands anyone to do it, though.
The whole David saga is an ancient tragic novel whose plot arc is David’s corruption. That’s not an apologetic interpretation: just read it. David starts as this brave and pious shepherd boy, but King David’s last scene is literally him listing to his son Solomon all the people he promised not to kill, and telling Solomon to be sure to kill them as soon as he takes the throne. The famous turning point is David as king deliberately getting his loyal foreign soldier Uriah fragged so that David can take Uriah’s beautiful wife Bathsheba. The story is clear that the LORD is not okay with that.
Condemning a heroic king for abuse of power isn’t bad for ancient morality. Give the LORD, like the devil, his due.