Brian Muraresku The Immortality Key
-
Philo Sofee
- God
- Posts: 6145
- Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 1:18 am
Brian Muraresku The Immortality Key
Did anything come of Muraresku's phenomenal book The Immortality Key? Has anyone heard anything else about Muraresku? Did he get his projects he was working on completed? This book really helped me see a new angle on all religion, and I hope he hasn't just let it drop out of sight. Although, I don't know if it changed anything fundamental about anything of religion that I have seen.
- Physics Guy
- God
- Posts: 2353
- Joined: Tue Oct 27, 2020 7:40 am
- Location: on the battlefield of life
Re: Brian Muraresku The Immortality Key
The Wikipedia summary of this book is that it speculates that early Christians used hallucinogenic Communion wine. If that’s the whole content then “the immortality key” as a title sounds like clickbait. Nobody ever got immortality from a hallucinogen.
The thesis seems conceivable but dubious. There’s clear evidence that early Christians were keen on glossolalia (ecstatic babbling, “speaking in tongues”), which is a weird psychological phenomenon but one that doesn’t need drugs. You can see and hear it any Sunday by walking into a Pentacostal church. Since evidence of routine glossolalia is so clear in the New Testament, though, it seems that common Eucharistic hallucinations would also have left more evidence than we have. And then there are all the practical issues. Somebody might have found a good fungus patch somewhere, sure, but I don’t think that distributing shrooms all over the Mediterranean could have been easy in ancient times.
If early Christians actually were doing shroom wine and yet somehow never wrote about it, it would be hard to find any other kind of evidence at this point. So I wouldn’t be surprised if this book has indeed simply sunk.
The thesis seems conceivable but dubious. There’s clear evidence that early Christians were keen on glossolalia (ecstatic babbling, “speaking in tongues”), which is a weird psychological phenomenon but one that doesn’t need drugs. You can see and hear it any Sunday by walking into a Pentacostal church. Since evidence of routine glossolalia is so clear in the New Testament, though, it seems that common Eucharistic hallucinations would also have left more evidence than we have. And then there are all the practical issues. Somebody might have found a good fungus patch somewhere, sure, but I don’t think that distributing shrooms all over the Mediterranean could have been easy in ancient times.
If early Christians actually were doing shroom wine and yet somehow never wrote about it, it would be hard to find any other kind of evidence at this point. So I wouldn’t be surprised if this book has indeed simply sunk.
Philosophical pirates think, therefore they Arrr!
-
huckelberry
- God
- Posts: 4129
- Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 3:48 pm
Re: Brian Muraresku The Immortality Key
I was wondering if there was an angle for discussion. Early Christianity was very bushy so some folks may have (I am sorely tempted to say wasted their time) Is the book as entertaining as Castenada? His fiction may be closer to experience. Flying is better than pretend death or more attractive. I am puzzled by people expecting the wide variety of religious experience to need drugs. Some experiences can be drug related but most are not.Physics Guy wrote: ↑Sun Nov 01, 2026 9:37 amThe Wikipedia summary of this book is that it speculates that early Christians used hallucinogenic Communion wine. If that’s the whole content then “the immortality key” as a title sounds like clickbait. Nobody ever got immortality from a hallucinogen.
The thesis seems conceivable but dubious. There’s clear evidence that early Christians were keen on glossolalia (ecstatic babbling, “speaking in tongues”), which is a weird psychological phenomenon but one that doesn’t need drugs. You can see and hear it any Sunday by walking into a Pentacostal church. Since evidence of routine glossolalia is so clear in the New Testament, though, it seems that common Eucharistic hallucinations would also have left more evidence than we have. And then there are all the practical issues. Somebody might have found a good fungus patch somewhere, sure, but I don’t think that distributing shrooms all over the Mediterranean could have been easy in ancient times.
If early Christians actually were doing shroom wine and yet somehow never wrote about it, it would be hard to find any other kind of evidence at this point. So I wouldn’t be surprised if this book has indeed simply sunk.
The positive experiences I had with psychedelics did not fit with any New Testament ideas. They had more to do with connection to universe and people here and now in a positive way. However such experience is malleable, shaped by ideas and current individual condition. Give a group a dose and there likely would be a variety of experiences hallucinations and directions.
Late sixties spread of ideas about LSD experience varied in many directions, different versions like mushrooms in the lawn.
- Kishkumen
- God
- Posts: 10504
- Joined: Tue Oct 27, 2020 2:37 pm
- Location: Cassius University
- Contact:
Re: Brian Muraresku The Immortality Key
I know Brian a bit. He and I work with the same archaeologist, and we have worked on some of the same initiatives. His book is pretty fun, in my opinion. The use of drugs in ancient religion is completely uncontroversial. The difficult thing is proving individual cases, when the evidence is slender and the texts can be interpreted in different ways. Our mutual archaeologist friend is also a chemist, and he tests ancient vessels to see exactly what their contents were. In this way, he is able to collect the elusive hard evidence of the use of "drugs" in ancient consumables. Brian is well aware that his work in the Immortality Key was more of a first serious foray into exploring possibilities, not in itself definitive proof of anything. Still, I learned quite a bit from reading it, and I consider its basic hypothesis generally sound and in some ways persuasive, though much work remains to be done.
Did Christians partake of hallucinogens in their sacraments or agape feasts? Probably some at some point did. After all, there were so many different types of Christians in the early centuries. To claim that none ever did anywhere would be silly (and I know no one here is claiming that). Which ones were and when is much tougher to figure out. We* are seeking to get a hold of vessels used for early Christian communion to find that evidence.
*We in the sense of the "Yale Ancient Pharmacology Program," in which I am a contributor, publishing articles and working on a book with its founder.
Did Christians partake of hallucinogens in their sacraments or agape feasts? Probably some at some point did. After all, there were so many different types of Christians in the early centuries. To claim that none ever did anywhere would be silly (and I know no one here is claiming that). Which ones were and when is much tougher to figure out. We* are seeking to get a hold of vessels used for early Christian communion to find that evidence.
*We in the sense of the "Yale Ancient Pharmacology Program," in which I am a contributor, publishing articles and working on a book with its founder.
"He disturbs the laws of his country, he forces himself upon women, and he puts men to death without trial.” ~Otanes on the monarch, Herodotus Histories 3.80.
- Physics Guy
- God
- Posts: 2353
- Joined: Tue Oct 27, 2020 7:40 am
- Location: on the battlefield of life
Re: Brian Muraresku The Immortality Key
Chemical analysis of residues in ancient vessels might indeed offer hard evidence at least of some usage, somewhere. If even a few positive samples turned up, after all this time, we’d have to suppose that the practice was not too uncommon, because it would be quite a fluke if really unusual ceremonial vessels happened to be among the very few that we found.
I’m not a chemistry guy (at least not yet) but I’d want to look hard at any claims that chemical analysis confirmed ancient religious hallucinogens. How stable are these compounds? Do they really survive in unambiguous form for millennia? If it’s a matter of detecting simpler compounds that could have been formed in the breakdown of likely hallucinogens, then the inference that the hallucinogens themselves would have been present originally could be speculative, even if the tests that showed the breakdown products were reliable, because perhaps the same breakdown products might have been formed in other ways, too.
The other question would be whether hallucinogens had any significant ceremonial or even doctrinal role, whether acknowledged or not, or whether they were just accidental contaminants. Some occur naturally. The ergot fungus, for example, infests grain and produces hallucinogenic (and poisonous) alkaloids. Ergotism has nasty symptoms besides hallucination, so I’d be surprised if people pursued it on purpose, but ancient people might well have been unwilling to throw away a lot of grain just because it had some funny black bits. I’m sure there could have been things besides ergot, but in general I imagine that it could be hard to distinguish, today, between ancient religious hallucinogens and unreliable ancient food safety.
I’m sure that historians and archaeologists think about issues like these, and about lots of other issues that don’t occur to me. I just think the rest of us should appreciate that issues like these are there, and not expect strong conclusions to be reached easily.
I’m not a chemistry guy (at least not yet) but I’d want to look hard at any claims that chemical analysis confirmed ancient religious hallucinogens. How stable are these compounds? Do they really survive in unambiguous form for millennia? If it’s a matter of detecting simpler compounds that could have been formed in the breakdown of likely hallucinogens, then the inference that the hallucinogens themselves would have been present originally could be speculative, even if the tests that showed the breakdown products were reliable, because perhaps the same breakdown products might have been formed in other ways, too.
The other question would be whether hallucinogens had any significant ceremonial or even doctrinal role, whether acknowledged or not, or whether they were just accidental contaminants. Some occur naturally. The ergot fungus, for example, infests grain and produces hallucinogenic (and poisonous) alkaloids. Ergotism has nasty symptoms besides hallucination, so I’d be surprised if people pursued it on purpose, but ancient people might well have been unwilling to throw away a lot of grain just because it had some funny black bits. I’m sure there could have been things besides ergot, but in general I imagine that it could be hard to distinguish, today, between ancient religious hallucinogens and unreliable ancient food safety.
I’m sure that historians and archaeologists think about issues like these, and about lots of other issues that don’t occur to me. I just think the rest of us should appreciate that issues like these are there, and not expect strong conclusions to be reached easily.
Philosophical pirates think, therefore they Arrr!
-
huckelberry
- God
- Posts: 4129
- Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 3:48 pm
Re: Brian Muraresku The Immortality Key
I remember a Dan McClellan presentation about residue of Hashish in alter time location in a temple in Israel.
"Smokes pot smokes pot everybody smokes pot" Beatles quote.
I remember Philo led a discussion about use of Aminita Muscaria, a widespreadly used hallucinogen. It is much more easily identified compared to psilocybin mushroom which I understand to be more pleasant and effective.
For Christian groups wine is reported to be what was used. I remember no record other sacramental. But there was a good deal of variety not all recorded or preserved.
The Book "Against Heresies" Irenaeus, lists more varieties of Christian odd paths than one might enjoy reading. I do not remember a drug using group but the author may have had limited knowledge on some groups and not have known.
"Smokes pot smokes pot everybody smokes pot" Beatles quote.
I remember Philo led a discussion about use of Aminita Muscaria, a widespreadly used hallucinogen. It is much more easily identified compared to psilocybin mushroom which I understand to be more pleasant and effective.
For Christian groups wine is reported to be what was used. I remember no record other sacramental. But there was a good deal of variety not all recorded or preserved.
The Book "Against Heresies" Irenaeus, lists more varieties of Christian odd paths than one might enjoy reading. I do not remember a drug using group but the author may have had limited knowledge on some groups and not have known.
- Kishkumen
- God
- Posts: 10504
- Joined: Tue Oct 27, 2020 2:37 pm
- Location: Cassius University
- Contact:
Re: Brian Muraresku The Immortality Key
Professor Koh of the Yale Peabody Museum did find opium in an alabastron that came from Egypt. That is one example of the fruits of his methods.Physics Guy wrote: ↑Thu Nov 05, 2026 8:41 amChemical analysis of residues in ancient vessels might indeed offer hard evidence at least of some usage, somewhere. If even a few positive samples turned up, after all this time, we’d have to suppose that the practice was not too uncommon, because it would be quite a fluke if really unusual ceremonial vessels happened to be among the very few that we found.
I’m not a chemistry guy (at least not yet) but I’d want to look hard at any claims that chemical analysis confirmed ancient religious hallucinogens. How stable are these compounds? Do they really survive in unambiguous form for millennia? If it’s a matter of detecting simpler compounds that could have been formed in the breakdown of likely hallucinogens, then the inference that the hallucinogens themselves would have been present originally could be speculative, even if the tests that showed the breakdown products were reliable, because perhaps the same breakdown products might have been formed in other ways, too.
The other question would be whether hallucinogens had any significant ceremonial or even doctrinal role, whether acknowledged or not, or whether they were just accidental contaminants. Some occur naturally. The ergot fungus, for example, infests grain and produces hallucinogenic (and poisonous) alkaloids. Ergotism has nasty symptoms besides hallucination, so I’d be surprised if people pursued it on purpose, but ancient people might well have been unwilling to throw away a lot of grain just because it had some funny black bits. I’m sure there could have been things besides ergot, but in general I imagine that it could be hard to distinguish, today, between ancient religious hallucinogens and unreliable ancient food safety.
I’m sure that historians and archaeologists think about issues like these, and about lots of other issues that don’t occur to me. I just think the rest of us should appreciate that issues like these are there, and not expect strong conclusions to be reached easily.
"He disturbs the laws of his country, he forces himself upon women, and he puts men to death without trial.” ~Otanes on the monarch, Herodotus Histories 3.80.
- Dr. Shades
- Founder and Visionary
- Posts: 3286
- Joined: Mon Oct 26, 2020 2:48 pm
Re: Brian Muraresku The Immortality Key
Nope, nothing came of it.Philo Sofee wrote: ↑Sat Oct 31, 2026 4:01 pmDid anything come of Muraresku's phenomenal book The Immortality Key?
I don't think so.Has anyone heard anything else about Muraresku?
No.Did he get his projects he was working on completed?
.
"When the Mormon God requires a PR crisis to act moral, we've clearly outgrown him."
--Everybody Wang Chung, 06-01-2026
"When the Mormon God requires a PR crisis to act moral, we've clearly outgrown him."
--Everybody Wang Chung, 06-01-2026
- canpakes
- God
- Posts: 10719
- Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 1:25 am
Re: Brian Muraresku The Immortality Key
Actual immortality would have helped here.Dr. Shades wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 8:28 amNope, nothing came of it.Philo Sofee wrote: ↑Sat Oct 31, 2026 4:01 pmDid anything come of Muraresku's phenomenal book The Immortality Key?
I don't think so.Has anyone heard anything else about Muraresku?
No.Did he get his projects he was working on completed?