As I have been looking at this since it has become a topic of conversation and I am really liking McClellen's whole approach to the Bible these days (alas! I get older), here is what I see with it. Subject to revision as I learn more, but of course. I would be cautious about claiming that Jesus was teaching a fully developed doctrine of heaven, spirit paradise, and spirit prison in Luke 23. There is just nothing in the text that could justify imagining a systematic theology on Jesus' part here. Heh, we could say that for the entire New Testament though, couldn't we.....Gadianton wrote: ↑Sun Nov 01, 2026 7:57 pmI think this is explained away in A Marvelous Work and a Wonder, which was approved by the Church for missionary use so it's semi-official. What Jesus meant was spirit paradise, vs. spirit prison. The thief would still need to get all his paperwork sorted out and a more thorough repentance to make the Celestial Kingdom.MG wrote:I actually would be quite interested in your knowledge/scholarship in this area. And if it lends credence to where you think Jesus met the thief after the crucifixion.
Doctrinally, it’s kind of a big deal, right?
It sounds natural to members growing up with the doctrines set up and ready to go. It makes no sense otherwise. There is no reason to believe Jesus believed in some complex set of realms.
What we see in the text is a promise of immediate blessed companionship with Jesus, Nowhere is there a geography of the afterlife mentioned or discussed or analyzed by anyone on the cross or the ground.
Looking at it with just regular eyes we can also see that Luke 23:43 promises paradise when the guy dies. But actually, other New Testament passages emphasize resurrection at the end of the age. Whatever resurrection means (Margaret Barker blew the doors off my LDS understanding when I read her theological interpretations) and whatever the end of the age may mean. If we look, I'm willing to bet we can find at least 5 other types of interpretations that do not all agree or cohere into a systematic rational logical view.
If we approach this historically, we find mish mashes of themes and explanations of differing combinations of ideas about the afterlife, which in early Christianity were being further expounded and growing with the Enoch literature, not to mention the Dead Sea Scrolls. Soteriology was never settled. And it was never sedentary, but always developed, changed, and expanded through time.
The very invention of hell as a late comer to the theological field is proof. There was no hell in ancient Judaism of the Old Testament era, but only Sheol, which in some respects was similar to the Greek Hades. They were not equivalent however. So, we get to wonder were early Christians already combining two different ideas about the afterlife? Was there an immediate existence after death and a future bodily resurrection? Are those the only two options? Who can tell? Paradise doesn't solve it, it just means "a garden" from the Persian etymology.
After Jesus is when the New Testament apocrypha literally outran the entire corpus of New Testament scripture writings. Canonical status is simply another man-made doctrine that holds no doctrinal value in relation to what men decided they liked and hence canonized, and what didn't suit their predilections of a pet doctrine when it wasn't supported, so the book was not canonized. It's all arbitrarily based on what one believed and what one didn't. And there has never in all of theological history been agreement on that!