Those Were the Days.

The catch-all forum for general topics and debates. Minimal moderation. Rated PG to PG-13.
Post Reply
I Have Questions
God
Posts: 4581
Joined: Tue May 23, 2023 9:09 am

Re: Those Were the Days.

Post by I Have Questions »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 13, 2026 12:11 am
I Have Questions wrote: ↑
Thu Nov 12, 2026 11:43 pm
You’re accepting at face value second or third hand accounts from people with a vested interest in presenting him that way. I don’t think you’d accept that kind of thing as valid for anything that didn’t point to something you already wanted to believe.

…snip…

I tend to agree. Religious people are not open to normal enquiry and suggestion if the outcome runs contrary to what it is they have chosen to believe.
Identical? Ouch.
:lol: Sorry. Sometimes my directness becomes brutally blunt. I’m working on it…
I think there is a difference in that evidence directly points away from Joseph and his claims whereas there isn’t evidence of plagiarism or other contrary evidence against resurrection. At least to my knowledge—if you have anything please let me know.
I think that’s a fair distinction. The only writing I’m aware of about the resurrection is that which we find in the Bible. But I take the content of the Bible with a pinch of salt, not literally. My thought is that the writers whose writing was selected for inclusion in that compilation would use allegorical presentations. Would the followers of Jesus not really have recognised him just three days after they last saw him? I’m not convinced by the narrative, and I can see no reason to conclude that a person can be dead for three days and come back to life. I know there are relatively recent examples of people seemingly coming back to life, but who were not deceased in the first place. I could see that mistake being the case for Jesus, and then him scarpering into hiding to avoid the Romans finishing the job.
I do agree that if I wanted to pretend to believe something like Joseph’s claims I could do so. But it would be pretending. The explanation about human nature and the need for salvation in the New Testament has had a powerful impact on my understanding as well. I’m not pretending about that—those explanations make a lot of sense to me.
That’s fair enough.
One objection I’d have to your characterization is the “face value” comment. I’ve acknowledged that the accounts have uncertain authorship, that the Gospel writers, whoever they were, probably shaped their accounts around Hebrew scripture, and that alternative explanations for resurrection experiences cannot be ruled out. Those are substantial challenges that I’ve taken into account.
That’s fair enough. But the objective evidence runs contrary to your chosen belief. You are making it fit what you have chosen to believe. If God is capable of intervening in your life to give you peace etc then there needs to be an explanation for why he chooses to not do that for, say, victims of child abuse. Where was he during The Holocaust? How do you rationalise that he was there for you in your situation, but not there for them in theirs?

Limnor, Matthew describes something extraordinary happening immediately after Jesus dies - An earthquake occurs. Rocks split apart. Tombs open. Dead holy people are raised to life. After Jesus' resurrection, these people enter Jerusalem and appear to many people.

51 And, behold, the veil of the temple was rent in twain from the top to the bottom; and the earth did quake, and the rocks rent;
52 And the graves were opened; and many bodies of the saints which slept arose,
53 And came out of the graves after his resurrection, and went into the holy city, and appeared unto many.

The astonishing part is that none of the other three Gospels mentions this event. Neither Mark, Luke nor John mentions dozens or potentially hundreds of dead people coming back to life and appearing in Jerusalem. If this happened literally, it would arguably be one of the most extraordinary public events in Jerusalem's history. Yet we have no independent contemporary account of it.

There is also a scholarly argument that Matthew constructed this passage using earlier Jewish apocalyptic traditions with which he was familiar. New Testament scholar Ronald Troxel specifically argues that Matthew created this scene, drawing on imagery from 1 Enoch.

Do you find Mathew’s account of multiple resurrections credible?

Mark is widely credited as being the first gospel account written, albeit many years after the death of Jesus. The earliest recoverable ending of Mark is generally considered to be Mark 16:8. It ends with the women discovering the empty tomb, being told that Jesus has risen, and fleeing in fear. The Gospel ends with "They said nothing to anyone, because they were afraid." There are no appearances of the resurrected Jesus in this original ending. The longer ending, Mark 16:9–20, which includes appearances of Jesus, is absent from the two earliest complete Greek manuscripts of Mark and is widely regarded as a later addition. So the idea that Jesus was resurrected was an embellishment. I think that reduces the likelihood that it actually happened.

For reference. It looks to me that Mark wrote something which was later added to making it more miraculous. The other 3 gospels, all written later, seem to me to be just embellishments of Mark.
Premise 1. Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable.
Premise 2. The best evidence for the Book of Mormon is eyewitness testimony.
Conclusion. Therefore, the best evidence for the Book of Mormon is notoriously unreliable.
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: Those Were the Days.

Post by Limnor »

I Have Questions wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 13, 2026 7:08 am
Sometimes my directness becomes brutally blunt. I’m working on it…
No worries—the “ouch” was more an admission that you are right, at least partially. I respect your directness and believe you hold the truth as valuable, as do many here. It’s one of the reasons I attend. I don’t think the method is exactly the same though. It isn’t the feeling of peace that drives belief for me. The feeling of peace comes “after” the belief. He died for me—that’s a very unique sacrifice from a God. I’m a military man and self sacrifice is a value I hold, so any God I could imagine (insert winky emoji here) should hold that same value. I also had a thought that a counterfeit is supposed to look similar to the real thing but I haven’t expanded that thought fully.

I want to push back a little on the idea that I’m making the evidence fit what I’ve chosen to believe. From my perspective, what I’m doing is trying to think through and sufficiently explain what I actually believe, why I believe it, and what might cause me to reconsider it. So I don’t think the objective evidence runs contrary to the resurrection, but I do think there is good reason for skepticism. That’s not the same as someone producing the body or evidence of fabrication—contradictory evidence of what is written. I’m not trying to manipulate what evidence we do have, and admit that the belief goes beyond what the evidence can demonstrate beyond doubt. I mean, like you said, it’s uncommon for people to come back from the dead.

I think part of what we are discussing could extend to “why do people believe things and what does it mean to believe anything?”

Your second question is considerably harder. I don’t know why God allows some people to suffer while others experience peace or a sense of His presence. There are some who experience peace in spite of suffering, or at least claim to. I’ve done so myself, though I wouldn’t claim that any suffering I’ve gone through compares to some others, for example I won’t argue that suffering of abused children as part of some divine plan or that anything I’ve suffered compares. Nor would I claim that experiencing God’s peace means He favored me over someone who experienced nothing but suffering. I can only tell you what I’ve experienced and how I’ve understood it.

But maybe this brings us back to why the resurrection matters so much to me. There is no promise that we won’t suffer or experience hardship. In fact we are told to expect it. But the resurrection promises that suffering and death don’t have the final word. If the resurrection didn’t happen, then the rest is meaningless.

I don’t think I’ve satisfactorily answered your question about why God permits suffering in the first place. I’m not sure anyone can answer that to that satisfaction of anyone else.
I Have Questions wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 13, 2026 10:19 am
The earliest recoverable ending of Mark is generally considered to be Mark 16:8. It ends with the women discovering the empty tomb, being told that Jesus has risen, and fleeing in fear. The Gospel ends with "They said nothing to anyone, because they were afraid." There are no appearances of the resurrected Jesus in this original ending. The longer ending, Mark 16:9–20, which includes appearances of Jesus, is absent from the two earliest complete Greek manuscripts of Mark and is widely regarded as a later addition. So the idea that Jesus was resurrected was an embellishment. I think that reduces the likelihood that it actually happened.
This is interesting, but I only have time for a brief response and more later. in the shorter ending, Mark 16:6 states that Jesus has risen, and verse 7 says the disciples will see him in Galilee. So I’m not sure the conclusion that there wasn't an understanding that He was resurrected was added in the longer ending. It’s already there.
I Have Questions
God
Posts: 4581
Joined: Tue May 23, 2023 9:09 am

Re: Those Were the Days.

Post by I Have Questions »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 13, 2026 1:09 pm
I Have Questions wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 13, 2026 10:19 am
The earliest recoverable ending of Mark is generally considered to be Mark 16:8. It ends with the women discovering the empty tomb, being told that Jesus has risen, and fleeing in fear. The Gospel ends with "They said nothing to anyone, because they were afraid." There are no appearances of the resurrected Jesus in this original ending. The longer ending, Mark 16:9–20, which includes appearances of Jesus, is absent from the two earliest complete Greek manuscripts of Mark and is widely regarded as a later addition. So the idea that Jesus was resurrected was an embellishment. I think that reduces the likelihood that it actually happened.
This is interesting, but I only have time for a brief response and more later. in the shorter ending, Mark 16:6 states that Jesus has risen, and verse 7 says the disciples will see him in Galilee. So I’m not sure the conclusion that there wasn't an understanding that He was resurrected was added in the longer ending. It’s already there.
Well let’s have a look at 5 & 6 to see the context.
5. “And entering into the sepulchre, they saw a young man sitting on the right side, clothed in a long white garment; and they were affrighted.”
6. “And he saith unto them, Be not affrighted: Ye seek Jesus of Nazareth, which was crucified: he is risen; he is not here: behold the place where they laid him.”

So it’s an account of an unknown young man claiming he is risen based on the tomb being empty. (The “they” who are supposedly recounting this tale are the two Marys). One unnamed young man saying “he is risen” on the basis of an empty tomb is not the same as an eye witness saying they’ve seen the resurrected Jesus in the flesh. It’s also a convenient witness, based on the miraculous narrative that Mark was trying to create. The sightings come in the additional ending that was created later.

There’s a parallel in Mormonism - the accounts of Joseph Smiths vision. Nothing was noted at the time it supposedly happened, it becomes more miraculous and spectacular over time as different versions are recounted. Until the Church picks a version that suits the narrative they want to portray.
Premise 1. Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable.
Premise 2. The best evidence for the Book of Mormon is eyewitness testimony.
Conclusion. Therefore, the best evidence for the Book of Mormon is notoriously unreliable.
User avatar
Rivendale
God
Posts: 2030
Joined: Tue Mar 16, 2021 5:21 pm

Re: Those Were the Days.

Post by Rivendale »

huckelberry wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 13, 2026 2:22 am
Rivendale wrote: ↑
Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:04 pm

It was common for people to claim to be the resurrected person of a deceased person. Nero one of the more famous. One was so convincing that he convinced armies to go to battle and was eventually executed.

My question is, if the Resurrection was granted how do we make the leap it was supernatural? There are many naturalistic explanations that are far more probable.
Rivendale. I can respect your caution. I do note that Jesus disappeared unlike the Nero standins. Of course that may only mean he was really dead. Much of the resurrection belief can appear to be based upon visions of him in supernatural power. It is even possible visions were the primary basis for the belief. I do know of an objective way to be sure of that.
Sure he allegedly ascended into heaven but not before hundreds of Graves opened and they chatted with the living. Almost all religious cultures have had resurrection narratives in their history so it's not unique. I am far far from any biblical scholar but I am fairly sure the old testament had a fairly good description of what the messiah would be and Jesus did not fit those qualifications. Especially the fulfillment of any of the messianic prophecies. There is also logical problems with the trinity and the three O's of god(s). And my greatest hurdle is by far the problem of evil. Christians as far as I know can't twist themselves into enough contortions to fix that.
I Have Questions
God
Posts: 4581
Joined: Tue May 23, 2023 9:09 am

Re: Those Were the Days.

Post by I Have Questions »

Rivendale wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 13, 2026 2:11 pm
huckelberry wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 13, 2026 2:22 am
Rivendale. I can respect your caution. I do note that Jesus disappeared unlike the Nero standins. Of course that may only mean he was really dead. Much of the resurrection belief can appear to be based upon visions of him in supernatural power. It is even possible visions were the primary basis for the belief. I do know of an objective way to be sure of that.
Sure he allegedly ascended into heaven but not before hundreds of Graves opened and they chatted with the living. Almost all religious cultures have had resurrection narratives in their history so it's not unique. I am far far from any biblical scholar but I am fairly sure the old testament had a fairly good description of what the messiah would be and Jesus did not fit those qualifications. Especially the fulfillment of any of the messianic prophecies. There is also logical problems with the trinity and the three O's of god(s). And my greatest hurdle is by far the problem of evil. Christians as far as I know can't twist themselves into enough contortions to fix that.
Didn't Lazarus break the bounds of death before Jesus did? Then you’ve got Elijah who raised the windows son from the dead. And so on. Lots of claimed resurrections before Jesus. There have been other resurrection since…
On October 2, 1571, recently deceased young farmer Matthew Wall was lying in a coffin on the way to his own funeral. Even though the day was cool and damp, the whole village of Braughing in Hertfordshire was out for the event, including Wall's distressed fiancée. As the procession made their way to the church, one of the pallbearers slipped on the wet leaves, dropping the coffin to the ground. The commotion was surprising.
But when the men lifted the coffin again, they were even more shocked by what they heard next: the sound of knocking. Matthew Wall had come back to life and was banging on the walls of his own coffin!
Wall eventually went on to marry his fiancée and live for another 24 years. Since then, Braughing village has commemorated Old Man's Day every year on October 2nd. To celebrate, village children bring brooms to sweep leaves from the lane in front of the church, presumably so no one slips on them.
Why (or why not) is this a legitimate resurrection in the same way as that of Jesus?
Premise 1. Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable.
Premise 2. The best evidence for the Book of Mormon is eyewitness testimony.
Conclusion. Therefore, the best evidence for the Book of Mormon is notoriously unreliable.
huckelberry
God
Posts: 4129
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 3:48 pm

Re: Those Were the Days.

Post by huckelberry »

I Have Questions wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 13, 2026 1:41 pm
Limnor wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 13, 2026 1:09 pm
This is interesting, but I only have time for a brief response and more later. in the shorter ending, Mark 16:6 states that Jesus has risen, and verse 7 says the disciples will see him in Galilee. So I’m not sure the conclusion that there wasn't an understanding that He was resurrected was added in the longer ending. It’s already there.
Well let’s have a look at 5 & 6 to see the context.

5. “And entering into the sepulchre, they saw a young man sitting on the right side, clothed in a long white garment; and they were affrighted.”
6. “And he saith unto them, Be not affrighted: Ye seek Jesus of Nazareth, which was crucified: he is risen; he is not here: behold the place where they laid him.”

So it’s an account of an unknown young man claiming he is risen based on the tomb being empty. (The “they” who are supposedly recounting this tale are the two Marys). One unnamed young man saying “he is risen” on the basis of an empty tomb is not the same as an eye witness saying they’ve seen the resurrected Jesus in the flesh. It’s also a convenient witness, based on the miraculous narrative that Mark was trying to create. The sightings come in the additional ending that was created later.

There’s a parallel in Mormonism - the accounts of Joseph Smiths vision. Nothing was noted at the time it supposedly happened, it becomes more miraculous and spectacular over time as different versions are recounted. Until the Church picks a version that suits the narrative they want to portray.
Question, a couple of thoughts about Mark's ending. First the earliest reports of resurrection are from Paul not Mark. I do not think Mark left out details because the idea had not yet formed. Mark carefully shapes his narrative to express a rushed mystery about Jesus and his actions. His associates as well as others did not understand him in the perspective Mark presents. The short ending fits that sense of open ended mystery.

I do not think it is possible to know when the longer ending was composed but it was not reporting a new idea.
I Have Questions
God
Posts: 4581
Joined: Tue May 23, 2023 9:09 am

Re: Those Were the Days.

Post by I Have Questions »

huckelberry wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 13, 2026 6:19 pm
I Have Questions wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 13, 2026 1:41 pm
Well let’s have a look at 5 & 6 to see the context.

5. “And entering into the sepulchre, they saw a young man sitting on the right side, clothed in a long white garment; and they were affrighted.”
6. “And he saith unto them, Be not affrighted: Ye seek Jesus of Nazareth, which was crucified: he is risen; he is not here: behold the place where they laid him.”

So it’s an account of an unknown young man claiming he is risen based on the tomb being empty. (The “they” who are supposedly recounting this tale are the two Marys). One unnamed young man saying “he is risen” on the basis of an empty tomb is not the same as an eye witness saying they’ve seen the resurrected Jesus in the flesh. It’s also a convenient witness, based on the miraculous narrative that Mark was trying to create. The sightings come in the additional ending that was created later.

There’s a parallel in Mormonism - the accounts of Joseph Smiths vision. Nothing was noted at the time it supposedly happened, it becomes more miraculous and spectacular over time as different versions are recounted. Until the Church picks a version that suits the narrative they want to portray.
Question, a couple of thoughts about Mark's ending. First the earliest reports of resurrection are from Paul not Mark. I do not think Mark left out details because the idea had not yet formed. Mark carefully shapes his narrative to express a rushed mystery about Jesus and his actions. His associates as well as others did not understand him in the perspective Mark presents. The short ending fits that sense of open ended mystery.

I do not think it is possible to know when the longer ending was composed but it was not reporting a new idea.
In 1 Corinthians 15:3, Paul says, "I delivered to you what I also received." This suggests that the resurrection proclamation existed before Paul wrote it, possibly within just a few years of Jesus's death. (Corinthians is thought to have been written 20/25 years after the death of Jesus). So, historically speaking, Paul wrote down the earliest surviving account, but he was also passing on an even earlier Christian tradition, like Mark was doing. These writers - Paul, Mark, etc. were not writing without purpose. They had an agenda and wrote what suited that agenda best.
Premise 1. Eyewitness testimony is notoriously unreliable.
Premise 2. The best evidence for the Book of Mormon is eyewitness testimony.
Conclusion. Therefore, the best evidence for the Book of Mormon is notoriously unreliable.
huckelberry
God
Posts: 4129
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 3:48 pm

Re: Those Were the Days.

Post by huckelberry »

I think a couple people have pointed to that odd Matthew story of Graves opening.

I admit I have always suspected that story to be an imagined image for later understanding of Jesus death. Perhaps I am not comfortable with just calling it meaningful fiction even If such things clearly occur in the Bible. It is a bit absurd to picture crowds of dead folks wandering about Jerusalem. On the other hand I could believe some people believing in Jesus having rather private visions or appearances of dead people. These stories could have become part of the community telling.

I do not know for sure but it is possible Jesus appearances were on the visionary side at least often. There seems to be little confusion amongst followers that he really died and was no longer living in the regular predeath life we live.

It makes sense to point out that there are other stories of resurrection. Lazurath but he does not have the power linking this life with divine life that people felt with Jesus.
User avatar
Rivendale
God
Posts: 2030
Joined: Tue Mar 16, 2021 5:21 pm

Re: Those Were the Days.

Post by Rivendale »

huckelberry wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 13, 2026 6:52 pm
I think a couple people have pointed to that odd Matthew story of Graves opening.

I admit I have always suspected that story to be an imagined image for later understanding of Jesus death. Perhaps I am not comfortable with just calling it meaningful fiction even If such things clearly occur in the Bible. It is a bit absurd to picture crowds of dead folks wandering about Jerusalem. On the other hand I could believe some people believing in Jesus having rather private visions or appearances of dead people. These stories could have become part of the community telling.

I do not know for sure but it is possible Jesus appearances were on the visionary side at least often. There seems to be little confusion amongst followers that he really died and was no longer living in the regular predeath life we live.

It makes sense to point out that there are other stories of resurrection. Lazurath but he does not have the power linking this life with divine life that people felt with Jesus
Linking this life with the divine is what Mormonism claims sole authority over. Saving ordinances are similar assertions that other religions make. Catholics claim apostolic succession. Muslims claim the Koran to be the sole authority. Unless you believe their are multiple paths to the summit it appears humans make stuff up at the drop of a hat.
huckelberry
God
Posts: 4129
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 3:48 pm

Re: Those Were the Days.

Post by huckelberry »

Rivendale wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 13, 2026 9:42 pm
Linking this life with the divine is what Mormonism claims sole authority over. Saving ordinances are similar assertions that other religions make. Catholics claim apostolic succession. Muslims claim the Koran to be the sole authority. Unless you believe their are multiple paths to the summit it appears humans make stuff up at the drop of a hat.
Rivendale I can appreciate that people do make things up but I think they much more eagerly overclaim their authority.

I think connecting with God is always a matter of God's initiative and authority. People make many paths some perhaps more helpful than others.
Post Reply