Dan McClellan recently exposed some academic dishonesty from a prominent Christian apologist. That apologist did the typical Mormon/Christian apologist action and decided to spin and lie his way out of it with a response video.
Then the Christian apologist community decided to circle the wagons and personally attack Dan McClellan. Most of these apologists believe that Dan is leading people away from Christianity, despite the fact Dan is a professing Mormon believer.
It turns out the evidence that Dan provided was so overwhelming that these apologists have had to remove their attack videos and apologize to Dan.
They’re embarrassed that their knee jerk reaction was to demonize and misrepresent Dan. However no one should be surprised - this is the core of Mormon and Christian apologetics.
Upholding dogma and faith is the core value in apologetics. Facts and truth merely get in the way, and just be massaged and swept under the rug to keep people in the pews.
A video about the situation, one of many, is available here as an overview of what happened.
https://www.youtube.com/live/_oDotgbGbF0
I would hope that someday Mormon and Christian apologists look back at what Dan McClellan is doing and learn from it. If Dan is leading people out of the church by presenting facts and evidence, maybe that is a good thing. Maybe that’s a sign that those churches need to change.
Dan McClellan embarrasses Christian apologists
-
drumdude
- God
- Posts: 8173
- Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 5:29 am
-
Marcus
- God
- Posts: 8297
- Joined: Mon Oct 25, 2021 10:44 pm
Re: Dan McClellan embarrasses Christian apologists
This is why I don't listen to podcasts. I am 3 min and 39 sec into your link and the guy has yet to say ANYTHING. Dear GOD can he not get to the point????!!!! his podcast is over an hour long!! No offense to you, drumdude, but this is why I READ. Is there a written summary anywhere?
-
Philo Sofee
- God
- Posts: 6145
- Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 1:18 am
Re: Dan McClellan embarrasses Christian apologists
I get to the point in my videos pretty quick. But... if I don't, you can go just underneath the video and click in the description the word "more" at the end of the description and it will let you scroll down, and you find the "transcript" button. Click on it, and the transcript comes up next to the video. Turn the sound down, and stop the video from playing, and read instead of watch slow. You can also speed up the video. But, I am offering some pretty solid refutation of Mormon apologists, so reading what I say is an option.... just lettin' ya know......Marcus wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 6:31 amThis is why I don't listen to podcasts. I am 3 min and 39 sec into your link and the guy has yet to say ANYTHING. Dear GOD can he not get to the point????!!!! His podcast is over an hour long!! No offense to you, drumdude, but this is why I READ. is there a written summary anywhere?
-
Marcus
- God
- Posts: 8297
- Joined: Mon Oct 25, 2021 10:44 pm
Re: Dan McClellan embarrasses Christian apologists
i'm sorry, philo, i'm not talking about yours! I was just frustrated at this one. You have very interesting things to say and this guy, understandably on one level, is just trying to carefully discuss his friend's error.Philo Sofee wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 7:35 amI get to the point in my videos pretty quick. But... if I don't, you can go just underneath the video and click in the description the word "more" at the end of the description and it will let you scroll down, and you find the "transcript" button. Click on it, and the transcript comes up next to the video. Turn the sound down, and stop the video from playing, and read instead of watch slow. You can also speed up the video. But, I am offering some pretty solid refutation of Mormon apologists, so reading what I say is an option.... just lettin' ya know......Marcus wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 6:31 amThis is why I don't listen to podcasts. I am 3 min and 39 sec into your link and the guy has yet to say ANYTHING. Dear GOD can he not get to the point????!!!! His podcast is over an hour long!! No offense to you, drumdude, but this is why I READ. is there a written summary anywhere?
-
drumdude
- God
- Posts: 8173
- Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 5:29 am
Re: Dan McClellan embarrasses Christian apologists
Essentially, McClellan found that Wes Huff plagiarized the work of others and edited that work to claim it as his own. This work was used in his course work to earn his degree.
The Christian apologists early on called the whole thing a “nothing burger” but to their credit eventually realized that this was a very serious problem. Not before trying to trash Dan McClellan as some sort of evil villain though.
One interesting argument those apologists used was that once you’re done at school, you can plagiarize all you want while doing apologetics. I guess that’s why DCP feels so comfortable doing it outside of the very narrow confines of university work.
The Christian apologists early on called the whole thing a “nothing burger” but to their credit eventually realized that this was a very serious problem. Not before trying to trash Dan McClellan as some sort of evil villain though.
One interesting argument those apologists used was that once you’re done at school, you can plagiarize all you want while doing apologetics. I guess that’s why DCP feels so comfortable doing it outside of the very narrow confines of university work.
-
Marcus
- God
- Posts: 8297
- Joined: Mon Oct 25, 2021 10:44 pm
Re: Dan McClellan embarrasses Christian apologists
Wow, thank you for the recap. Wow. That's pretty huge. No wonder the guy took an hour to try to explain what his friend did. Wow again.drumdude wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 3:19 pmEssentially, McClellan found that Wes Huff plagiarized the work of others and edited that work to claim it as his own. This work was used in his course work to earn his degree.
The Christian apologists early on called the whole thing a “nothing burger” but to their credit eventually realized that this was a very serious problem. Not before trying to trash Dan McClellan as some sort of evil villain though.
One interesting argument those apologists used was that once you’re done at school, you can plagiarize all you want while doing apologetics. I guess that’s why DCP feels so comfortable doing it outside of the very narrow confines of university work.
Interesting that plagiarism is found acceptable by some. 'Lying for the Lord' takes on new meaning.
An article was put up today, in the Christian Post, titled with byline:
Especally interesting to me were some of the responses to being accused of plagiarism, similar to what we have heard before from a Mormon apologist:"Wes Huff addresses plagiarism allegations amid review: 'Honesty and integrity matter' " .
By Jon Brown, Christian Post Reporter
Saturday, November 14, 2026
https://www.christianpost.com/news/wes- ... eview.html
Bolding added by me. Even DCP's excuses for his plagiarism aren't original, apparently....Huff noted that he had used Academia.edu a decade ago like a Dropbox for his drafts and notes, claiming some were unfinished and never formally submitted. He said he had personally apologized to Wright, the other scholar he was accused of plagiarizing, who appeared in the video and subsequently told The Blaze that he believes "in extending grace and forgiveness, recognizing that forgiveness does not excuse wrongdoing or eliminate accountability."
In the since-deleted video, Huff also expressed appreciation for McClellan's "pursuit of truth and accountability," but noted "the way his interactions have come across have made me wonder about his agenda."
In another article, a few more details are given about huff's now deleted first apology video:
...While some people were satisfied, others were not, saying his framing of their objections was inadequate. Huff then unlisted the video and later deleted it, though we have archived a copy of it here.
Since then, more people have brought forward accusations, pointing to content on his website that appears to be unattributed and plagued by the same issues as his Academia papers. As a result, all the content was removed from his site, with only links to his socials remaining before ultimately going offline...
https://protestia.com/2026/11/13/apolog ... bably-why/
Last edited by Marcus on Sat Nov 14, 2026 4:48 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
drumdude
- God
- Posts: 8173
- Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 5:29 am
Re: Dan McClellan embarrasses Christian apologists
His agenda is simply putting facts and evidence above dogma. McClellan routinely states that there is zero empirical data for the supernatural, for neither the resurrection nor the historicity of the Book of Mormon, while simultaneously remaining an active, practicing member of the Mormon Church.
It’s really, really hard for 99 percent of Christians and Mormons to understand that. They just can’t wrap their tiny worldview around it. But I’m hopeful that Dan’s style of belief will become more popular amongst the religious as time goes on.
It’s really, really hard for 99 percent of Christians and Mormons to understand that. They just can’t wrap their tiny worldview around it. But I’m hopeful that Dan’s style of belief will become more popular amongst the religious as time goes on.
-
huckelberry
- God
- Posts: 4129
- Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2020 3:48 pm
Re: Dan McClellan embarrasses Christian apologists
Marcus I definitely second your point. It seems to be a YouTube plague. Some presenter has a title for a presentation which sounds like it could be interesting. Click on it and somebody meanders on and on after an overly long introduction, about how his subject has come up and is important, and how he is going to tell us about it sometime if we sit back and learn to enjoy his voice as much as he does, well, sometime I suppose.Marcus wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 6:31 amThis is why I don't listen to podcasts. I am 3 min and 39 sec into your link and the guy has yet to say ANYTHING. Dear GOD can he not get to the point????!!!! his podcast is over an hour long!! No offense to you, drumdude, but this is why I READ. Is there a written summary anywhere?