Has the Seal of Book of Mormon Mulek Been Found?

The catch-all forum for general topics and debates. Minimal moderation. Rated PG to PG-13.
Post Reply
Philo Sofee
God
Posts: 6145
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 1:18 am

Has the Seal of Book of Mormon Mulek Been Found?

Post by Philo Sofee »

Here is my second presentation for You Tube on the Mulekites and the archaeological, historical, and biblical evidences LDS scholars have brought forward through the years showing these are real historical people who actually lived. I will present this as part 2 on my You Tube series of videos on Mulek.

Jeffrey Chadwick: The Mulek Seal
HAS THE SEAL OF MULEK BEEN FOUND?

A critical assessment of Jeffrey R. Chadwick's argument, the Hebrew evidence, and the archaeological controversy
We now have a substantial response to Chadwick. And the most effective way to present it is not to begin by declaring his seal a forgery or his argument ridiculous. It is to grant his strongest evidence, explain why it matters, and then examine exactly what conclusions follow.
Our central finding: Chadwick has identified a potentially meaningful connection between an ancient Hebrew inscription and Jeremiah 38:6. But the identification of that individual with the Book of Mormon's Mulek requires several additional arguments, none of which has been conclusively demonstrated.

1. The actual archaeological evidence
Book of Mormon Evidence: Mulek | ScriptureCentral
scripturecentral.org

In 2003, Jeffrey R. Chadwick published his article in the Journal of Book of Mormon Studies, examining a small stamp seal inscribed:
למלכיהו בן המלך
Le-Malkiyahu ben ha-melekh
“Belonging to Malkiyahu, son of the king.”

The seal is a small malachite object measuring approximately 15 × 11 × 7 millimeters. It contains an ancient Hebrew inscription and decorative pomegranates.
It first appeared publicly in a 1991 antiquities-market catalog and subsequently entered the Shlomo Moussaieff collection.
Chadwick's proposal is that this seal may have belonged to Mulek, the son of Zedekiah mentioned in the Book of Mormon.
The inscription itself contains no reference to Mulek, the Americas, or an escape from Jerusalem.

2. Authenticity: what we can responsibly say
The seal was not recovered in a documented archaeological excavation. Its original findspot, archaeological layer, and chain of custody are unknown.
That does not prove forgery. Many genuine ancient artifacts have entered collections without recorded excavation contexts.
But it makes independent verification more difficult.

The principal scholarly positions are:
Scholar Contribution
André Lemaire His 1995 assessment raised questions about authenticity, as reported by Chadwick
Nahman Avigad Considered the seal authentic, according to the Avigad–Sass corpus
Benjamin Sass Expressed broader caution about groups of elaborate unprovenanced seals
Leonard Wolfe Identified an unusual bet on WSS 15 as a possible warning sign
Jeffrey Chadwick Defended authenticity using comparisons with similar seals

Wolfe's criticism is especially useful because it is specific rather than merely suspicious of the antiquities market. He identifies an unusual formation of the letter bet but acknowledges that the remaining letters appear compatible with ancient writing.
We should also recognize the limitation of that criticism. An unusual letter form does not automatically identify a modern forgery. Ancient engravers varied in skill, technique, and style.
Neither Wolfe's concern nor Avigad's favorable assessment constitutes an independently documented laboratory authentication of this particular seal.

Our conclusion on authenticity: The seal may be genuine, but the evidence presently examined does not justify treating its authenticity as settled beyond reasonable dispute.
For the rest of my analysis, however, we can grant Chadwick the assumption that it is entirely authentic.
That makes the historical argument stronger.

3. The biblical connection is real, but what does it mean?

Jeremiah 38:6 refers to Malkiyahu, son of the king. The King James Version renders the expression as “Malchiah the son of Hammelech,” obscuring the fact that ha-melekh means “the king,” not a personal name.
Chadwick correctly emphasizes this translation issue.
And the agreement between the seal and Jeremiah is significant. We are not merely comparing two vaguely similar names. We have the same personal name and the same royal designation.
That makes the proposed identification historically interesting.
However, several questions remain unresolved.

First, was the seal's owner the same person mentioned in Jeremiah? The shared name and designation support the possibility, but the seal lacks a secure archaeological context that would independently establish the identification.

Second, what exactly did ben ha-melekh mean? It could refer to a biological royal son. Some scholars have also considered its use as a court designation or a title associated with the wider royal household.

Third, even if Malkiyahu was literally a king's son, was Zedekiah necessarily his father? The inscription does not name the king.
Chadwick argues that the surrounding context of Jeremiah 38 makes Zedekiah the natural candidate. That is a reasonable argument, but not a conclusive one.

There is another subtle point. Jeremiah 38:6 identifies a cistern associated with Malkiyahu. It does not tell us Malkiyahu's age, whether he was the heir to the throne, or whether he personally participated in Jeremiah's imprisonment.
These are distinctions between what the ancient source says and what a modern reconstruction proposes.

4. The linguistic problem: Malkiyahu is not automatically Mulek
This is probably our strongest critical argument, particularly because an LDS Hebrew scholar identified it decades ago.
Robert F. Smith and Benjamin Urrutia proposed that Mulek could be a shortened form of Malkiyahu.
That is not an inherently unreasonable idea. Hebrew personal names frequently contained divine-name elements, and shortened personal names certainly existed.

The problem is demonstrating this particular shortening.
Removing the divine element -yahu from Malkiyahu does not automatically produce the form Mulek. The proposed vowel changes still require an explanation.

David Rolph Seely's 1993 critique
In his review of Reexploring the Book of Mormon, David Rolph Seely criticized the tendency to present the proposed Malkiyahu–Mulek connection as an established linguistic fact.
His analysis was unusually detailed. He examined Hebrew noun patterns, proposed Semitic parallels, and the difficulties surrounding the initial vowel in Mulek.

His conclusion was that the relationship remained possible but could not be demonstrated by known comparative Semitic parallels.
He also criticized the Encyclopedia of Mormonism for turning tentative proposals into confident assertions.
That is a particularly valuable observation for this presentation: the overstatement was identified by a believing LDS scholar, not merely by outside critics.

Another complication: the original Book of Mormon spelling
The Book of Mormon's early textual history also deserves attention. The name appears as Muloch in the printer's manuscript and Mulok in early printed editions, before the later standardized Mulek.

FAIR itself acknowledges this textual history and Seely's objections to the Arabic diminutive explanation associated with Hugh Nibley.
This means our linguistic investigation must distinguish three separate matters: the original Hebrew consonants, the hypothetical ancient pronunciation, and the nineteenth-century English spelling of the Book of Mormon name.
We cannot simply assume that the modern spelling preserves an exact sixth-century BCE Hebrew pronunciation.

5. An important development: the Baruch seal comparison has its own authenticity problem
This may be the most significant additional finding for this response.
Chadwick and earlier LDS scholars appealed to the relationship between the names Berekhyahu and Baruch as an analogy for the proposed relationship between Malkiyahu and Mulek.

The argument originally drew support from seal impressions attributed to Jeremiah's scribe Baruch.
But subsequent research has seriously questioned the authenticity of those particular bullae.

In 2014, Yuval Goren and Eran Arie published “The Authenticity of the Bullae of Berekhyahu Son of Neriyahu the Scribe,” in Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research 372, pp. 147–158.
And here is the particularly interesting part: LDS researcher Neal Rappleye acknowledged this problem in his 2017 FAIR conference presentation, “Put Away Childish Things.”

Rappleye specifically noted that the Baruch bullae cited in the Mulek discussion had subsequently been judged likely forgeries. He nevertheless argued that the broader linguistic phenomenon of shortened Hebrew names remains valid.
That is an appropriate distinction.

The questionable bullae weaken the archaeological illustration, but they do not establish that Hebrew names could never be shortened.
However, the decisive question remains whether Mulek is an attested or linguistically defensible shortened form of Malkiyahu.
Seely's criticism survives the authenticity debate over the Baruch bullae.

6. The Book of Mormon's historical claim goes much further
The Book of Mormon identifies Mulek as a son of Zedekiah who survived Jerusalem's destruction and whose descendants eventually became associated with Zarahemla.
The relevant passages include Omni 1:14–19, Mosiah 25:2, Helaman 6:10, and Helaman 8:21.
The biblical account in 2 Kings 25:7 reports the execution of Zedekiah's sons.

Chadwick and other defenders correctly observe that the passage does not explicitly say every son was executed. A son who was absent could theoretically have survived.
But this is evidence of possibility, not evidence that a particular son escaped.

Chadwick proposes that Malkiyahu might have been a young royal heir sent to Egypt for diplomatic or protective reasons. This is a conceivable reconstruction, especially given Judah's political relations with Egypt.
Yet we possess no independent document establishing that Malkiyahu was sent to Egypt, escaped the Babylonian conquest, or later crossed the ocean.
The archaeological seal does not supply that missing information.

7. What the Elephantine papyri contribute
The Elephantine papyri give us valuable historical context.
They demonstrate that Yahweh-worshipping communities lived in Egypt and that a temple dedicated to YHW existed there before the Persian conquest of Egypt in 525 BCE.

A petition dated 407 BCE describes the temple's destruction in 410 BCE and requests authorization to rebuild. A subsequent memorandum supports reconstruction with restrictions on offerings.

This is relevant in two ways.
First, it shows that Judean and related religious communities could establish themselves outside Judah. That makes the general idea of migration to Egypt historically unsurprising.
Second, the Elephantine temple provides a legitimate parallel for discussing Nephi's construction of a temple in 2 Nephi 5:16.
But the papyri principally document a later period. They do not identify Mulek or demonstrate a migration to the Americas.
The occurrence of names belonging to the Malkiyahu/Malchiah family in Egyptian documentary material establishes the broader use of such names, not the identity of Jeremiah's Malkiyahu.
And the Elephantine temple's exact founding date remains unknown. Its existence before 525 BCE does not establish that it was standing around 600 BCE.
This is another excellent example of a parallel correcting an overly broad objection without independently verifying a particular historical narrative.

8. The LDS scholarly disagreement is worth highlighting
The Latter-day Saint scholarship has not had one uniform position.

Robert F. Smith and Benjamin Urrutia
Proposed the Malkiyahu–Mulek identification and the linguistic relationship between the names. Their work helped establish the apologetic argument later developed by Chadwick.

Jeffrey R. Chadwick
Defended the seal's authenticity, the royal-son interpretation, and the possibility that the seal belonged to Mulek. His conclusion was considerably more confident than the evidence alone requires.

David Rolph Seely
Criticized the linguistic derivation and the presentation of tentative proposals as established facts. His 1993 review remains one of the most important sources for our analysis.

Neal Rappleye
Acknowledged later authenticity problems involving the Baruch bullae while defending the broader plausibility of the Malkiyahu identification. He also cites Lawrence Mykytiuk's classification of the seal-to-biblical-person identification as a Grade 2 identification. This is qualified rather than certain.

FAIR and Book of Mormon Central
These organizations have continued presenting the identification as potentially significant Book of Mormon evidence. Book of Mormon Central's 2016 discussion explicitly concedes that the identification cannot be definitively proved, while nevertheless regarding Mulek as a strong candidate.

Some LDS scholars advance the claim confidently; others recognize substantial methodological problems.

THE FINAL EVIDENCE ASSESSMENT FOR NOW
Question Our assessment
Is the inscription linguistically readable? Yes
Is the seal securely provenanced? No
Is the seal authentic? Plausible, disputed
Does Jeremiah mention Malkiyahu, son of the king? Yes
Could the seal owner be Jeremiah's Malkiyahu? Yes, a meaningful possibility
Could he be Zedekiah's biological son? Yes, but unconfirmed
Is Mulek demonstrably a shortened form of Malkiyahu? No
Could a son of Zedekiah have escaped? Possible, not independently documented
Does the seal corroborate a voyage to America? No
Has Chadwick established that this is Mulek's seal? No

CONCLUSION
The question Jeffrey Chadwick raises is genuinely interesting. A small Hebrew seal names a man called Malkiyahu, son of the king. Jeremiah 38:6 also mentions a man with that name and designation.
This is not something we should dismiss. The correspondence deserves serious historical investigation.
But we must use all the evidence and analysis of contexts, literary, archaeological, historical, and others, to distinguish the actual evidence from the interpretations placed upon it.

First, the seal lacks a documented archaeological provenance, and scholars have disagreed about its authenticity. We cannot simply declare it genuine because it supports a desired historical conclusion. Nor should we declare it forged merely because it was acquired through the antiquities market.

Second, even if the seal is genuine, we cannot establish with certainty that its owner was the same Malkiyahu mentioned in Jeremiah. And even if he was, the inscription does not identify his father by name.

Third, the proposed linguistic relationship between Malkiyahu and Mulek remains unproven. This was recognized by LDS scholar David Rolph Seely in 1993. He specifically warned against presenting interesting possibilities as established facts.

Fourth, the biblical account does not explicitly rule out the survival of an absent royal son. But neither does it document such a survivor. We have no independent evidence that Malkiyahu escaped to Egypt, crossed the ocean, or founded a population in ancient America.

The Elephantine papyri demonstrate that Judean communities existed in Egypt and even maintained a temple there. These are valuable historical facts. But they cannot establish Mulek's identity or travels.

Therefore, even if Chadwick's seal is authentic, even if it belonged to Jeremiah's Malkiyahu, and even if that individual was a biological son of Zedekiah, we still have not demonstrated that he was the Book of Mormon's Mulek.

The historical evidence supports possibilities at several stages. It does not establish the entire chain of identification.
And that is the essential distinction between historical plausibility and historical confirmation.

A genuine ancient artifact can tell us something important about ancient Judah without proving a much larger narrative attached to it.
Our responsibility with scholarship and research into historical issues concerning scripture is to follow the evidence as far as it goes. And we have to recognize where it stops.

Principal sources for this presentation of Part Two
1. Jeffrey R. Chadwick, “Has the Seal of Mulek Been Found?” Journal of Book of Mormon Studies 12/2 (2003): 72–83, 117–118.
2. David Rolph Seely, review of Reexploring the Book of Mormon Review of Books on the Book of Mormon 5/1 (1993): 305–316, especially 311–315.
3. Nahman Avigad and Benjamin Sass, Corpus of West Semitic Stamp Seals (1997), no. 15, p. 55.
4. André Lemaire, “Épigraphie palestinienne: Nouveaux documents II,” Henoch 17 (1995), item 162. Original relevant pages not independently inspected.
5. Robert Deutsch and André Lemaire, Biblical Period Personal Seals in the Shlomo Moussaieff Collection (2000), no. 23, p. 29. Original relevant pages not independently inspected.
6. Leonard Wolfe, “A Critical Assessment of Unprovenanced Seals, and Other Artifacts Known since 1968 and Characterised by a ‘Lame Bet’,” especially his evaluation of WSS 15.
7. Yuval Goren and Eran Arie, “The Authenticity of the Bullae of Berekhyahu Son of Neriyahu the Scribe,” BASOR 372 (2014): 147–158.
8. Neal Rappleye, “Put Away Childish Things” FAIR Conference (2017).
9. Book of Mormon Central, KnoWhy 103 (2016).
10. Elephantine temple petition (407 BCE), with historical commentary.

For my larger Mulek series, I think this is a coherent response for part two: I present a fair and consistent presentation of the archaeological evidence, the serious LDS scholarly disagreements, the linguistic problems, and the distinction between a plausible ancient Judahite identification and an unproven Book of Mormon identification.

And there is one especially effective scholarly voice to emphasize: David Rolph Seely recognized the central linguistic problem before Chadwick's article was even published. That deserves a prominent place in this response.
User avatar
Limnor
God
Posts: 2014
Joined: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:55 am

Re: Has the Seal of Book of Mormon Mulek Been Found?

Post by Limnor »

Interesting stuff, Philo.

Another point of interest might be the idea that a descendant of David voluntarily relinquishes kingship, the scepter, to a descendent of Joseph. That approach would overturn a few hundred years of prophecy and expectations.

A different parallel to examine in addition to that which the scholars have tried to accomplish could be to consider the 19th century parallel. Rigdon and Zarahemla hold authority in their sphere of influence in the Kirtland and Zarahemla areas. Mosiah and Joseph possess the brass plates and the ability to translate them. Authority changes hands based on that ability.
Philo Sofee
God
Posts: 6145
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 1:18 am

Re: Has the Seal of Book of Mormon Mulek Been Found?

Post by Philo Sofee »

Limnor wrote: ↑
Sun Nov 15, 2026 6:45 pm
Interesting stuff, Philo.

Another point of interest might be the idea that a descendant of David voluntarily relinquishes kingship, the scepter, to a descendent of Joseph. That approach would overturn a few hundred years of prophecy and expectations.
Well, it would be fascinating to see if that is biblical or if it is from the Mormon end of things.... but good point! I shall look into it.
User avatar
Gabriel
Priest
Posts: 293
Joined: Thu Jan 21, 2021 10:20 pm

Re: Has the Seal of Book of Mormon Mulek Been Found?

Post by Gabriel »

OK, in the Old World this possible son of Zedekiah has a given name which can be Englished as "God is my King". Then, this same man escapes death and makes it to the New World in a miraculous manner, and then he decides that he wants everyone else to just call him "King". What an ungrateful bastard!
Philo Sofee
God
Posts: 6145
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 1:18 am

Re: Has the Seal of Book of Mormon Mulek Been Found?

Post by Philo Sofee »

Gabriel wrote: ↑
Mon Nov 16, 2026 5:16 am
OK, in the Old World this possible son of Zedekiah has a given name which can be Englished as "God is my King". Then, this same man escapes death and makes it to the New World in a miraculous manner, and then he decides that he wants everyone else to just call him "King". What an ungrateful bastard!
What's more the Mulekites don't thrive either. THey are actually assimilated, whereas in the Old World, the branch of David continued on into New Testament times in Jesus......
Post Reply