Some Schmo wrote:I'm certain you're aware that several countries around the world have superior healthcare systems to ours. We could pick one.
Right, but you don't know what to go with. We've got a blue wave, we're outraged at capitalism and billionaires, but no idea what to do next, just not capitalism because it's evil. Doctor CamNC4Me says he doesn't know what Medicare part C is. Okay, I applaud his honesty, but he's not going to look it up. It's my job to come before the high council and plead my case. Why this is a problem, is because you guys are way, way better informed than the average American, and if you guys don't know how healthcare works and aren't interested, then the average American is hopeless. Expectations will be trounced, and everyone is going to go right back to "burn it down" voting next round.
I'm not going to explain Medicare part c right now, I will say this though, my right-wing friend uses it and he thinks it's the coolest thing ever; brags about his program all the time. That should give you an idea about how bad it sucks. Actually, that's the only reason I learned about it a few years ago and I recognized immediately from his own sales pitch how bad we're screwed. But it's the final brick wall between where we're at and a true universal system, and there are plenty of other barriers before that.
Healthcare is not any one thing. There are aspects of healthcare that are market driven, and aspects that don't make markets. Privatizing hospitals is generally terrible. The best US hospitals do have some ideological commitment -- academic or religious. The best religious hospital network is ran by a cult, not the Mormons, but the Seventh Day Adventists. Catholics do pretty well also, in terms of scale, at least. Some good protestant hospitals, but the extreme Fox News, MAGA, speak-in-tongues types of faiths who make up the most irresponsible thinkers on the planet, substantially below the Nazis; you guessed it, don't have any. That's the "Christian nation" George Washington founded for us.
Anyway, there is a certain amount of "market" theme going on here due to private non-profits finding incentive to move something forward rather than governments taking charge, though there are examples of secular non-profits also. But religion fuels hospitals about as well as anything else in America. That is a form of free-market expression.
Some more points about capitalism. So, it's true, that in many respects, single-payer systems in Europe have structural advantages that allow them to give better care for cheaper than the American system, though the American system in its broken, uncoordinated mess ends up more or less approximating universal healthcare to a certain extent, at least with emergency services. One of the good guys on my walk, while he was out of a job briefly, had to take his son to the local hospital. They asked for his insurance and he pulled out his credit card, didn't have any. They say, "put that a way", he gets on the charity roster no questions asked. He's white, by the way.
The problem with insurance isn't just insurance on its own, it's insurance plus policy. The gorilla in the room is part C, but there's so much more. If I walk into one of Chap's setups in England, after waiting a year to get approved for the basic benefit package, and I have abdominal pain, if I don't look like I'm dying, I'm going to get grilled for a while, then wait about 20 hours, and then I will probably be given a couple of Tylenol and sent home.
If I go to the ER at an American hospital, the Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act both in fine print, and implicitly by the threat of lawsuits, puts pressure on the ER to bow to the patient's self-assessment. A hospital might resist -- when I sent a family member to the ER a couple years ago (more as an object lesson for the family than anything else) they didn't get everything they thought they would, and we got a nastygram back basically telling us not to waste emergency services. But their risk is well beyond that of the Chap apothecary to say "no". NOW -- suppose I go across the street to the private-equity ER, which I did a few years ago, because my family made such a big deal about it?
So, I know I have a kidney stone, oh boy, it's bad, never had one, but from what I'd heard, nothing to do about it except take ibuprofen, which works very well. So I go in with possibly the smallest stone on record which is about to pass within hours. It would, in fact, probably had passed by the time one of Chaps' NHS doctors got to me. I told them I figured it was a kidney stone, never had one, no history in my family of it, spent the summer building a structure outside in 100+ degree heat, and they recommend an MRI. While I waited they encouraged me to lay down and get some fluids in me, I told them "no, I don't want to pay 1000$ for a glass of water". They laugh, so I wait in a chair, get the news, and they give me horrible advice on how to handle it. Then they beg me to lay down for a while and get an IV because I'm terribly dehydrated. I got out of there as soon as possible. Seven months later, I get a bill for 14,000$ for the MRI alone. If I suspected something seriously wrong with me, do you think I would have went there? Hell no! there's a single doctor there who barely knows medicine better than I do, and they can't do anything but ship me somewhere else to start a new round of billing if it's something actually serious.
So that's why I got interested in MRIs. The first thing I did when I got that bill is look up the cost of an MRI machine. 350k for the one I'm pretty sure they had. I'm thinking, “F”, I should start my own MRI business! I could make a killing and charge people less than insurance. Hound/Binger should seriously get one for his next venture. And so, fast forward a few years, and I ran into a guy doing just that. I spent a half hour on the phone with the owner getting his back story. So let's put this together: The Chap-level service depends on the judgment of the delegate of the state. The American Hospital service forces the hospital to give me what I want, to a point, but they try to push back. The American boutique ER pushes me to use every available service they can sell me on because they're billing at level 5 ER rates, if they can suggest to me the MRI is the way to go. This is a marriage between policy and profit incentives, not profit incentives alone -- we free-market types are well aware of Adam Smith's warnings of the unintended consequence of policy. In this case, PE exploits the blind spots of well-intend policy meant to protect people. There will be a whole lot of that if people are asleep at the wheel and cheer over making "small" wins for health coverage.
So yeah. Here's one we aren't prepared for. The American right of the individual. Universal health care quite strongly makes personal healthcare a public matter. Are Americans ready for that? So, I looked up (I apologize that I'm willing to research something rather than just trade barbs about capitalism and communism) the differences between failure rates in ER care in England vs. the US. The US is substantially worse. England does fail due to wait times and misdiagnosis or not taking the patient seriously enough. The US fails at least twice as bad. But, it's less because of that, and more because of the American lifestyle. If we're all paying for everyone's healthcare, is it really fair that the grocery store has about 20 square feet worth of food items a person should actually eat and the rest is fueling ER visits? Americans and their cardiovascular disease, inactivity-related illnesses, guns, and car crashes lose to England, even though strongly insured Americans do better once they get admitted to the hospital.
But think about that. Think about how bad that actually is. If Americans can't change their lifestyles to be more appropriate for a community related concept of health, then you're going to add the complexities of the poor American diet and exercise regiment to the cheaper, but slower moving universal system, and have even more deaths!
One last item before I go and make a sandwich that is halfway healthy but not totally. This is a doosey. Let's talk about America's pharmaceutical greed. Oh, Americans and those greedy pharmaceutical companies! 500,000$ treatments for cancer or treatments for kids with genetic diseases and so on. I get it. I too am scared of a cancer diagnosis not because I might die, but because I might have to pay for it!
In England you get those same treatments for free!
Oh, Chap is so much better off. He's totally more enlightened about economics and doesn't have to worry about cancer. But why? Greedy American capitalists, and they can be real bastards there is no doubt, pour boatloads of money into treatments to cure the effects of the American lifestyle the pharma CEO's neighbor promote with their artificial food-stuffs. So we, America, develop cutting edge cancer treatment, rob our own people blind, but -- these companies with break-through treatments have what we call a
monopoly. What do monopolies do? They price discriminate. After raking their fellow Cheeto-sickened Americans over the coals to cure their cancer, you've got good ole England on the horn saying, "Look, we have universal healthcare here. We don't have as many radioactive folks but we do have a few, and we can use that medication, but nobody is allowed to charge more than x amount of dollars for it, so take it or leave it."
So they take it. They'll take two dollars for it, why not? That's how monopolies work.
Where the defacto broad similarity diverges between the English system and the American system is when getting into high-tech expensive care. This crap isn't invented by government programs, but greedy industrialists taking HUGE financial risks on the hope of making a killer profit. So these American pharma monopolies can bill to the moon at home, and then get what they can abroad from European countries. So Chap can talk about socialism being the more enlightened way, while secretly freeloading off of the "failures" of American capitalism.
But surely America isn't the only game in town for high-tech. It isn't. Germany and Netherlands produce excellent MRI machines -- and drugs, lots of good drugs invented in Europe -- Denmark invented Ozempic, which my right-wing friend's friend takes, of course. So there you go, universal healthcare can also produce high-tech solutions, right? Sure.
But only because they can make a boatload selling it to Americans first! It's not just America abusing it's own citizens, it's the entire world incentivized to innovate in medicines that only the f'd over Americans have the ability to pay for. So yeah, after getting rich selling MRI machines and Ozempic to American care providers willing to charge an arm-and-a-leg to Americans, these Euro countries, with combined populations of about 750 people, can use the exact same playbook American industrialists use, and after raping America, sell the rest for whatever they can abroad, including their own countries.
So once America becomes enlightened enough to run a shoestring-budget universal health system, who is going to take the risk to invent high-cost, cutting edge treatments?