Water Dog wrote:I wouldn't over-complicate it. I simply mean that borders are imaginary in the sense that we humans make them up. God didn't draw some line and say anybody with a specific DNA has a "birth right" to a particular patch of earth. It is owned by whoever owns it... which is defined by their ability to physically assert ownership.
So, maybe more like arbitrary than imaginary?
Water Dog wrote:You pepper me with these questions which are rather beside the point. Most of those are easy targets to armchair quarterback given that they made what in hindsight were obviously poor tactical decisions. The merits of their various causes are however all relative and subjective. If I were Israel today, I'd leave the middle east. Working with my friends in the USA, not to mention ~1/5 of my citizens who have American passports, I'd petition to relocate to say North Dakota or some such wasteland that is not currently being used. And then I would literally just move.
I asked you for some explanation precisely because i wanted to understand the point of this thing you said:
If Israel were smart, they'd drive the Palestinians out... far past the borders of the Jordan river and conquer Jordan, Syria, and Lebanon.
Frankly, it's so obvious that what you proposed was so obviously one of the worst things Israel could do, I assumed I was missing something and asked for clarification. Did the statement represent any thinking at all on your part, or was it just crap that Water Dog says?
Instead of offering any explanation at all, you skipped off to Israel moving to North Dakota. How, exactly, would that work. How many immigrants are we talking here? Does Israel get to be it's own country, or do they all become Americans. What about the folks already living in North Dakota?
If you don't want to be asked about the stupid crap you post, don't post it.
“The ideal subject of totalitarian rule is not the convinced Nazi or the dedicated communist, but people for whom the distinction between fact and fiction, true and false, no longer exists.”
― Hannah Arendt, The Origins of Totalitarianism, 1951